Nautilus auto attacks are supposed to snare the enemy, then go on Cooldown against them, that is how the passive is worded
If jax casts E and dodges auto attacks, nautilus' snare will go on cooldown and jax will not be snared or take any damage
DuskDaUmbreon1 votesAnd? That's intended, for almost absolute certain.
Kid Diddles1 votesAnd? That's intended, for almost absolute certain.
Why would nautilus' passive go on cooldown if he didn't snare or damage jax? "Nautilus' basic attacks deal bonus physical damage and immobilize his targets. This effect cannot happen more than once every few seconds on the same target. " The effect did not happen to jax
Void Priest1 votesIf gangplank uses Q on a Jax the ability is dodged but the cooldown is not refunded to the GP. That would be dumb. Naut's CC happens to be attached to his AA. If his AA is dodged, the other effects are as well. IMO this is intended.
Cheat Engine zZz1 votesThat's how it has worked forever and how it was always intended to work. Jax's E will negate effects and block cc and waste any on-hit affects attached to it when taking the attack. Same with udyr E, jarvan passive, even other Jax's W or R-passive. Despite your misunderstandings, the effect still does trigger. Jax just negates the effects.