Skip to content

[GAMEPLAY] Talon's Rake (W) does not return if he dies in the middle of the animation

gregrunt··1 votes·579 views

Sivir, Ahri, and Gnar all have "boomerang" kind of abilities that return to them. Talon does as well, but when he dies his Rake (W) does not return to him. If you want to reproduce:

  1. Go on Talon and level W
  2. Be close to death
  3. Let someone finish you off while you use Rake
  4. See that Rake doesn't return or deal the second wave of damage

This is 100% reproducible, though the timing may be difficult. It happened to me twice in the game I linked, and it could have secured a kill both times. Thanks!

Link to Reddit thread.

12 Comments

forist2 votes

Its intended. Talon's rake and shadow assault are disjointed on death, because that's how they were designed to work.

gregrunt1 votes

Source? Talon was designed to have a silence. They took that away.

forist1 votes

{quoted}

Source? Talon was designed to have a silence. They took that away.

Here from the lol wiki:

"Additional Information:

Rake's projectiles take about 0.8 seconds to travel out and back to Talon. If Talon dies, Rake's projectiles are disjointed and will not deal damage even though its animation continues."

edit: same is listed for his ult shadow assault as well, so yeah its intended.

gregrunt1 votes

The LoLWiki is not a Riot official resource. Nor do i see a quote from a rioter in anything you posted. The wiki is just pointing out how the interaction currently functions not how it should function.

forist1 votes

Are you like new to playing this champ? It's been this way since release. I don't have sources of riot addressing it, but I'm sure they have multiple times. Btw, ahri's q used to not deal damage when she died. They changed it to continue traveling a couple of patches ago, so I'm sure both ahri and talon's abilities were originally designed with the intention of not dealing damage if they die mid cast.

Haunt1 votes

http://boards.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/c/gameplay-balance/EEIs7Mni-can-we-make-talons-rake-w-come-back-to-him-after-he-is-dead

I've already tried this. It's not a bug either, it is intended. But I do wish they'd change it.

Dies to Wolves1 votes

{quoted}

http://boards.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/c/gameplay-balance/EEIs7Mni-can-we-make-talons-rake-w-come-back-to-him-after-he-is-dead

I've already tried this. It's not a bug either, it is intended. But I do with they'd change it.

so was Ahri's Q, but they changed it last year. As a company that praises clarity and has changed a lot of stuff for the sake of consistency, they should give the same treatment to talon's W

Haunt1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Dies to Wolves,realm=NA,application-id=LqLKtMpN,discussion-id=R9UMsBGc,comment-id=00010000,timestamp=2015-04-28T18:31:22.047+0000)

so was Ahri's Q, but they changed it last year. As a company that praises clarity and has changed a lot of stuff for the sake of consistency, they should give the same treatment to talon's W

Yup. That's what my thread was about. But I guess they just don't care enough.

gregrunt1 votes

If it's intended I would like to see a Riot response claiming that. Otherwise I'll just assume it's ignorance until then. I would also want the same treatment on Shadow Assault (R) considering it's similar to Maokai's, but I feel that may be asking too much.

Haunt1 votes

{quoted}

If it's intended I would like to see a Riot response claiming that. Otherwise I'll just assume it's ignorance until then. I would also want the same treatment on Shadow Assault (R) considering it's similar to Maokai's, but I feel that may be asking too much.

I posted a reason why that would be a bad idea in my thread.

gregrunt1 votes

No totally, I read that. I think it would make his ult too safe and pink wards countering it wouldn't be rewarding. My point about W still stands though.

pleep1 votes

I don't think a change is necessary, it would encourage a suicide playstyle with bad talon players and not really make any difference for good ones.

Would also remove alot of counterplay

More from Report a Bug