Multiple Harrowings in 1 year, why haven't folk there left already

Rito Staff··7 votes·3,242 views

If the Harrowing was something that happened once every so years I see how people could fight it or try their luck through the darkness... (I know now that is rather inconsistent, but my point remains :3)

Happening once, or even multiple times a year, makes no sense for common folk to hold their ground (even more because it's not actual people they're fighting, but dead things, who can't be defeated)

And from what we read from the Shadow and Fortune event - where the dead took whole ships, the ghost Kraken destroyed a whole neighborhood - My question is, how is Bilgewater still up and running? In just one go Bilgewater got completely wrecked. Lots of people have died, the story having turned out to be grim as it is, and if it happens 2+ times in the same year? People would be migrating (even if illegaly) somewhere else for sure.

I love reading it and it's exciting, but I don't see how people actually stay in Bilgewater, knowing what hunts it very so often... I'm saying here that with these events it should've been explored by the writters clear and definite ways the people there fight off the dead, or keep them away. I'm talking about candles and lamb sacrifices, chalk drewn pentagrams and that sort of things.

Happens once, "what was that?", happens twice "we should get the f outta here"

These events opened up the world a bit but I hope for future Harrowings of this scope we get more information on what can trigger it (the dead simply decide to go for it? too much sin accumulated?), and what people over the decades started doing to help themselves and if the dead have an agenda of their own.

I think it would've been logical for Bilgewater to be better equipped against Harrowings though, like iron walls that would slide through a whole building façade shutting it close completely.

And what about the tunnels beneath the city?

The walls of the cave were pale limestone, gouged from the cliffs upon which Bilgewater was built. The motion of water and the stone picks of the natives had crafted a labyrinth beneath the city few knew of or even suspected existed. The pale rock walls were etched with looping spirals, rippling waves and things that might have been unblinking eyes.

That's what I'm talking about, just not many BW inhabitants know about it...

17 Comments

RiotDinopawz15 votes

That's a very good point, and it's one I took some time to think about at the start of all this...

I liken people who stay in Bilgewater to the folk who live on the slopes of a volcano (or near one). The soil around such places was incredibly fertile and great for growing crops, so folk stayed in place because they could grow food and feed their families, make a living etc. All the while praying that the Angry Volcano God wouldn't blow its top and fry them. Or praying that their chosen deity would keep it from erupting. Also, they might not have a choice but to stay. A lot of people in Bilgewater are there because there's stuff they can do there that they can't do anywhere else, and there's also the fact that some might not be able to leave...either by not having any money, it's too dangerous to be out on the road without a company of warriors, the (unknown) world beyond is too scary, rumours of war coming from Noxus and the Freljord and all manner of tales of monsters and dark tidings.

Sometimes it's better to stick with the devil you know, hide under the kitchen table clutching your symbol of the bearded lady and pray it takes the people next door instead of you...

Chromatic Eagle1 votes

So why don't the other nations seem concerned about the Harrowing? Why not send aid to Bilgewater? Olaf seemed to not be aware of it being a thing.

Dan Squared4 votes
  1. Valoran is a City-State society....the other states are under zero obligation to help out

  2. If its so far only hitting Bilgewater, the other city-states so far might see no need to bother until its an actual threat to their own people

  3. Who would help them anyway?
    Bilgewater is a land of thieves and pirates, Demacians would be just as likely to execute or arrest everyone they saw as they would to fight undead.
    Noxus would literally not care in the slightest, deciding that the folks of Bilgewater just weren't strong enough.
    Freljord is engulfed in Civil War.
    Zaun/Piltover aren't know for being big military powerhouses. Ionia is either still under Noxian occupation or are recovering from it depending on how new lore treats that event. Bandle City is actually pretty isolationist.

and again...these other city-states would be risking their own people and resources to help an entire society of thieves, pirates, and con-artists

I would honestly be AMAZED if there was an organized relief effort from any other political organization on Valoran

Chromatic Eagle1 votes
  1. Well that's one of the downsides of retconning the IoW.
  2. Well we know Noxus lost some ships to both the Harrowing and Gangplank. That seems to be enough reason to "relieve" them.
  3. Besides Noxus, You're probably right about Freljord. Demacia may be the ultra lawful state, but I imagine that they still have some morality. Purging the undead for their own sake is still helpful. Everything else I agree. These nations are either too busy, isolated, not military enough, or we don't know their current state.
Dan Squared1 votes

I'll give you Demacia might see the undead as the "greater" evil compared to bilgewater...but once the harrowing was fought off they wouldn't just walk away, not while bilgewater is engulfed in such chaos and ruled by petty criminals.
They would then see it as their moral duty to bring Demacian justice to the lawless region.

and yeah, Noxus is not a state that "helps" people, your either already under Noxian rule, or something to be conquered and brought under Noxian rule.
Same logic applies as Demacia, even if they decided stopping the Black Mist was important...they wouldn't just leave and let Bilgewater be. It would be serve Noxus by choice...or die

Chromatic Eagle3 votes

So why don't the other nations seem concerned about the Harrowing? Why not send aid to Bilgewater? Olaf seemed to not be aware of it being a thing.

Also,

“Look, I get it, Sarah. We won Bilgewater and you need to fight to hold onto it, to show everyone you’re better than Gangplank. Well, you’ve done that. We went out into the Black Mist and we fought the dead. That’s more than he ever did. Anyone who risks lookin’ out a window is gonna know that. Hell, even the ones who ain’t looking will hear about it. What more do you want?”

So does that mean that MF and GP never worked together to deal with the previous years of the Harrowing? What did he do for each previous one?

Rito Staff2 votes

From what I gather, Bilgewater is a town of pirates and whatnots then! Meaning that it's ideal for outlaws and their doings, hardly they'd be welcomed in other 'civilized' ports - a risky town with a "fertile soil" to make a fortune and a name. Sure there are some families and humble folk who don't know any better, or see themselves with no other avail but to stay (because of the unknown of the open road), but pirates wouldn't be like so, they're free, I mean they do sail around the world I guess, so they go back to Tortuga Bilgewater, the outcast capital or something, their home c:: the "great black pit" of Runeterra!

Silver Fluffenbu1 votes

The soil around such places was incredibly fertile and great for growing crops

What seed may grow in the well harrowed ground? Planted seeds grow in the well harrowed ground.

GreenLore4 votes

Most times the harrowing doesn't even reach bilgewater,but only its surrounding waters. Looking at the harrowing map it looks like only 3 harrowings ever reached bilgewater(I,III and VI),with 3 others being rather close to the place(II,IV,V) http://na.leagueoflegends.com/en/news/game-updates/special-event/first-light-after-harrowing

Rito Staff1 votes

hmm, but for them to have fought the undead before they even reached BW they must've known they (the dead) were coming, or the mist took a while longer to reach, giving enought time for people to get together and arm those defenses 'offshore' BW.

The Battle of Knife Straits. An armada from Bilgewater, led by Miss Fortune and Captain Gangplank – sailing together under an uneasy truce – meets the Black Mist head on. Heavy casualties sustained. Fleet scattered.

This time though we witnessed that the mist came faster, a few minutes max only from the moment the dead birds got up and Olaf heard the screams. Or maybe since GP wasn't around and ppl were too busy fighting each other, no one saw it sooner... if it were predictable it wouldn't be as bad I guess :|

Stars Shaper3 votes

Ppl are still living and building houses at the roots of Mt. Vesuvius... Harrowings ain't that bad compared to what that vulcano will do when the time will come.

The Only Doctor3 votes

But it also says the Harrowing grows in strength each year. The Black Mist and The Shadow Isles themselves are both beneficiaries of death and magic. Since the wells for both are, year in and year out, being added to, it makes absolute sense that the Harrowing would be ever more powerful, which maybe even means that things that used to work against the Harrowing no longer do. The idols and wards and signs that are nailed to doors and frames maybe no longer work as effectively as they once did. Just a way to think about it. IDK

Lord Boltrix2 votes

Maybe, instead, you should ask: why are there multiple harrowings in one year, and why one harrowing just happens to occur after Gangplank falls...

It's almost as if someone is behind the Black Mist, directing it in a way that suits the purposes of the controller.

Mordekaiser

Caytheles2 votes

Bruh, Bilgewater folk are born in Bilgewater, and they Die in Bilgewater.

Zarkkast1 votes

I'd also like to bring up the point that a year on Runeterra might be more time than a year here on Earth.

A year on Saturn, for instance, takes about 30 Earth-years.

LongHair Fox1 votes

As a European I find myself asking the excapt same question every year, but towards people living the so called "hurricane straight" in USA. I guess it is attachment, spite, and a bit of faith and insanity based on how all the houses always seem to be made of wood,

TBakes1 votes

From what we have seen of the people in Bilgewater, they also seem to have a penchant for gambling. I'm sure there are travelers from all over who come to the port just to make a quick buck and get out. It might be the only safe harbor for certain groups of people. It might be a place where criminals and outcasts can live and find a certain amount of success just because others around the world will not follow them there.

The Harrowing is just a downside. Everyone is prepared to certain extent with faith and spirituality.

More from Story, Art, & Sound

More by Rito Staff