My Thoughts On Yuumi As An Enchanter Main

Freed By Frailty·4/26/2019, 11:25:10 PM·52 votes·20,317 views

I'm kind of disappointed, to be honest.

This doesn't come from a point of gameplay, her abilities look incredible and I'm eager to try her out once she's released, but she simply feels like all the other Enchanters we have in terms of thematic.

Janna Nami Lulu Sona Soraka These are all the "pure" Enchanters, in the sense that they're not a hybrid of another class, such as how Karma, Rakan, and Morgana could be considered Enchanter-Catcher hybrids, as even though they have decent utility, their focus is more on damage and CC.

Aside from a similar gameplay design, they also all for the most part fulfill the same thematic "The Ethereal Healer" with small niches to separate them. Nami having a more confident headstrong personality, Lulu being a bit crazy though still well intentioned, Janna being a wind spirit that wants only to protect the helpless, Sona and her music, and Soraka being a celestial entity.

Yuumi doesn't do anything to diversify the roster of Enchanters, or the League roster in general, with the only thing that makes her really stand out from a thematic point of view being the simple fact that she's a cat. Turn her into a woman, a woman shaped spirit, or even a Yordle, and she would be essentially invisible in comparison to the other Enchanters.

A healer or simply somebody helping people doesn't have to be contained to some mystical being, and more importantly, it doesn't have to be contained just to woman. While yes, Yuumi is a cat, she's still female, which causes her to even further fall into the same bland overused thematic. As a male Enchanter main, what disappointed me the most about Yuumi wasn't that she uses the same overall design the rest of the Enchanters use, but it's just one more female.

They could have created a male Frost Priest as a new champion, diversifying the Enchanter roster by having a heavier, more dreary design, owing to his use of Dark Ice and worship of Lissandra. Maybe a male Noxian alchemist hardened by war who supports the Empire on the frontlines, throwing explosive potions to heal his allies and debilitate his enemies.

In the end, I just wanted a male Enchanter so I could feel represented, even if it's just in that small simple way. Rakan came close, but he's not a pure Enchanter, only a hybrid, and the same for Taric, who's really just a tank with a mediocre heal.

Again, I'm not angry at Yuumi, I'm definitely going to play her, I just think Riot could have done something truly different.

60 Comments

I Smell Pizza4/27/2019, 1:06:52 AM16 votes

yeah, i really liked bard and rakan bc they were unique. but they aren't really enchanter like i want

NSFWaifus4/27/2019, 2:32:16 AM13 votes

Me waiting for an enchanter from Noxus that has more personalty than just "pRoTeCC InnOcEnCt PeOplE"

Illabethe4/27/2019, 2:04:06 AM6 votes

Did you even research how her skills work?

She can literally make herself untargetable by attaching to another champ.

No other champ can do that.

If she wants to, she can detach from an ally and block shots aimed at them as well.

Again..... no other champ can do that....

She comes with both a broken utility feature of being untargettable, at the risk of hurting an ally, while being able to go Untargetable to save herself.

I don't care about gender. I care about new mechanisms. This is one.

Original Sin4/27/2019, 9:45:43 AM5 votes

My thoughts is that they've run out of ideas

kda akali4/27/2019, 5:30:14 PM4 votes

I really hate how Riot keeps making enchanters cute whimsical female champions. It perpetuates the idea that all enchanter players are female, it really isn't true. Riot could have at least done something more interesting, a male Yordle cat champion would have been cool or maybe a male Vastayan cat champion. They also could have created something different from a cat. Some interesting things I've came up in my head are a champion from the shadow isles that infects champions with the black mist, a swarm of voidlings that attach to a different champion, maybe a puppeteer that attaches and controls other champions, or maybe even a robot from Zaun that attaches onto a champion and turns into armor around them. They really could have done so much other things. A cat is cute and whimsical and fits the kit really well, if they changed the kit around a little bit and redid the visual design they could have such a cool more unique enchanter support.... Im kind of happy with Yummi but it could honestly be better.

Frontline Fury4/27/2019, 12:55:47 AM4 votes

Riot doesn't like making enchanters that aren't adorable females. I guess it's not manly enough for them.

Frankly i'm just disappointed we basically got a mix of Sona and Lulu. There's nothing actually new with this champion. She's just a bundle of recycled spells and concepts.

iiGazeii4/27/2019, 8:14:35 AM3 votes

Totally agree. I was hoping beyond hope that we were going to get a scruffy old Yordle cleric or something along those lines.

It's worrisome that when Riot wants to set out to make a "traditional" support champion, they always ends up female. It's not only a disservice to the men out there who love to heal and empower teammates, but also to the women that that love racking up kills or slinging high-impact spells or bullying the enemy team around. Riot just got a ton of backlash for the stereotype of "girls only play support".

I love Yuumi, I think her kit is exciting, her personality is endearing, and her VA did an amazing job. I just think there's a ton of design space for a manly support that Riot simply isn't exploring.

When they rewrote Varus' story, I remember Riot saying that they asked the question "Does this couple need to be a man and a woman", and when they realized that no, it didn't, they were excited to explore that direction. I feel like the question "Does Yuumi need to be a girl", was not asked during her development, or worse, was dismissed, because Yuumi could have just as easily been a male cat and their personality, backstory, and kit could have remained exactly the same.

Meteor Driz4/27/2019, 7:44:52 AM3 votes

Not sure if you guys think this too but she is essentially just a copy from hereos of the storm, the hero Abathur

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YuksSOIfOJU

If she is, which it seems like she is, then her spells should be considerably weaker than normal, as Abathur can enchant any teammate he wants from any range. But his spells are a lot weaker. To compensate, wherever his body is stationed he summons an extra lane minion to apply pressure while he shoots weak spells off of peoples heads.

I'm guessing shes going to be pretty similar to this because I don't see how else you could balance a concept like this

Just my thoughts

Beerstein4/27/2019, 5:38:55 PM2 votes

Let's be real, it was a monetary decision, riot knows females trend towards these, and gear the champ/sales to them. Which from a business standpoint is reasonable. From a "get woke" standpoint that Riot has been trying to push lately though, it's a morally terrible decision. Personally, I agree businesses should cater to what makes cash, but this isn't how riot pretends to conduct themselves. Right now they're doing one thing and saying another.

If they said "that's what makes the money, we don't care about gender politics" that'd be one thing, but they say the exact opposite while doing it.

Ichiibaru4/30/2019, 11:20:26 PM2 votes

[{quoted}](name=Freed By Frailty,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=WA8HwOnO,comment-id=,timestamp=2019-04-26T23:25:10.512+0000)

Yuumi doesn't do anything to diversify the roster of Enchanters, or the League roster in general, with the only thing that makes her really stand out from a thematic point of view being the simple fact that she's a cat. Turn her into a woman, a woman shaped spirit, or even a Yordle, and she would be essentially invisible in comparison to the other Enchanters.

That's kinda disingenuous because you can say the same thing about Sona's music or Lulu's madness. Take that away, and there won't be much left. Yuumi's uniqueness stems from her species, and I think that's just fine.

ShadowGlaive2134/27/2019, 6:33:31 PM1 votes

I think the most disappointing part of this is that it's our first traditional enchanter class champion in 6 years and they chose to pretty much echo what they already have, kind of like what happened with Dunkmaster Ivern. IMO they just overall stopped choosing new designs in season 6 and I'm not sure why. Kai'Sa's concept art is evidence that they are still exploring interesting things, but the final decision seems to always end up being "let's do something close to what we already have".

CasterGilgamesh4/27/2019, 7:59:29 PM1 votes

i mean i love Yuumi but it was disappointing that she is female instead of male.The reason being is we dont have too many whimsical cutesy male champions sure we have them but we havent had a new one is a while.But not gone lie im def going to main her and buy her skins.

DeadUnborn4/27/2019, 9:11:51 PM1 votes

Last couple of enchanters have been Ivern, taric, Rakan and Bard. It was time for a traditional enchanter

ModAcademy Kayn4/27/2019, 11:58:00 PM1 votes

I mean, that kinda begs the question. Does the design flow from the gameplay, or does the gameplay form the design of the champion? If the idea was to add a Magical-Cat type creature into the game, then you decide there where to move them into Gameplay. If the idea was to add a new Enchanter to the line up, you think about the archtypes that fit a Enchanter and move into design.

To me at least, Yuumi looks like she was a "We want to make a Magical Cat" and then her design naturally favored that of an enchanter or a mage, and since we haven't had an enchanter in a while, they went with enchanter.

Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, but you obviously seem to look at it as in "We want a new enchanter" and move from there to make something new. I feel this is just another instance of Designer Vision over Public preference, which is nothing new. Someone wanted to make a Cute kitty, and it lended itself to an enchanter kit, not they wanted an enchanter kit, and just so happened chose to make it a cute kitty.

FlameHalbrdOkido4/28/2019, 10:57:33 PM1 votes

Also keep in mind Riot likes to balanced their releases, and I think that also takes Reworks into account to some degree...

MORDEKAISER is coming after Yuumi. That guys is probably the most dark evil, (male), character that LoL currently has so when they are planning champions and champion releases they balance stuff like that out so some people don't start complaining that LoL has only been doing one type of champion recently like people tend to do

Don't worry it probably won't be a year b4 we get a dark male enchanter to balance it out, but for now just understand that, and Enjoy Taric and Ivern.

xox BaByDoLL xox4/30/2019, 5:22:35 AM1 votes

I don't understand..... I saw nothing but angry people when they thought the support hero had been skipped over when a dev started talking about an upcoming AD Assassin. All those angry people were mad because they wanted the promised enchanter support. Riot gives us the Enchanter support. Now people are mad that she's too much of an Enchanter?

...........

Oh, people are mad it's a female and dares to be our 3rd of 4th cute champ out of 140+!?!? [slayer-jinx-unamused]

BlackhawkAceX5/14/2019, 8:50:55 PM1 votes

Not sure if that was mentioned here before, but: why don't any of the cat's skills have anything to do with that magical book of hers, whose main attribute (if I understood the lore correctly) is that it allows the reader/wielder to traverse magical gateways/tunnels/portals. Or did I miss anything or read an early draft or something?

Zeanix4/27/2019, 5:24:39 AM1 votes

I mean, they did tease in the first roadmap that it was going to be a female (in the video he stated enchantress) but I also understand how it can be samey too. But I think because of how it’s rather different it is (a cat rather than a person), it can be looked as a “hey that’s pretty unique”, which most people, even me, did.

Though I hope we have other enchanters from other areas. So far we’ve had Ionian, Vastayan, Demacian and now yordle, which imo kinda have a similar play style and also aesthetic (light, whimsy and mystical). Freljord would be a great place to start and of with and can go off from there

Valaran Nara4/27/2019, 6:29:25 AM1 votes

I know this has nothing to do with gameplay, since I saw you argue it has nothing to do with it, but I see that based how the gameplay works, her character niche is..."The Pet"

By that, I mean that she acts like Janna's bird Zephyr or Lulu's Pix.

While she does have Book which would easily be her companion, she technically operates as the ADC's familiar/pet/companion in lane.

The main draw back on diversity is the fact that Yuumi is female. I can't argue that, but I do think that with her tether mechanic and her being a cat definitely lends herself to acting like a "pet". You know what I mean?

Or...did I fall off?

King Mugiwara4/27/2019, 6:31:30 AM1 votes

I'd kinda only see similarities with Soraka. Oh well...

Cevrad4/27/2019, 1:58:31 PM1 votes

WHO

CARES.

They literally do not care about story, none of that stuff, the balance team and design team care about playability and creativity. It is a completely different team that comes up with the lore after the champion is ALREADY FINISHED. It's why Illaoi liked mangos for 2 years. Because nobody gives two fucks about anything to do with lore in this game. People care that their champion feels unique and is fun to play. Its not like you go into game, are going through laning phase and go "man i really wish this super unique champion would be a dark frost queen". LMAO WHAT

14daysuspensionk4/27/2019, 2:53:59 PM1 votes

I don't want any more of these types of champs after this one, Zoe Neeko , I want a more serious theme for the next champ, not rework one tho.

Eleshakai4/27/2019, 3:17:55 PM1 votes

I just wish she wasn't a cat. shudder I'd be excited for the champ if not for that simple flaw. Maybe there will be a Definitely not Yuumi skin that will make her something palatable.

EmpressOfBeauty4/27/2019, 3:52:16 PM1 votes

Is Bard not an enchanter?

Savvyal4/27/2019, 4:04:02 PM1 votes

The reason they probably made yuumi an cute mystical cat was because the last support to come out was pyke. While not an enchanter pyke still filled the edgy male support role that you seem to be looking for. Riot went out of their way to specifically make a whimsical design to differ from their last support so I dont think a heavy dreary design wouldve been right for release right now. I do agree that a quirky fun male enchanter that fit the whimsical theme would've been more unique than yuumi.

Terozu4/27/2019, 4:24:21 PM1 votes

Yeah from a personality standpoint she's very typical. But the fact that shes a champ pet that's playable on her own is pretty cool.

Basically her personality and theme are kind of overdone, while her game play thematic is really cool.

She can attach like Pix, they can both fire a slowing projectile, they both have a heal and a movement buff. They both have magic autos and a shield.

Their abilities link them and give familiars a core identity the same way Ashe Liss and See are linked, or Eve and Tahm.