[{quoted}](name=Chromatic Eagle,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=W1smZWIk,comment-id=000500040000000100000001,timestamp=2015-09-20T15:03:38.141+0000)
So what's the world of the Guardians of the Sands? I imagine it's a parallel world, but what's their story?
Have you considered adding an opposing skinline against the Arclights? Do they have any connection with the Justicar skins?
Blood Moon is a bit of a sore spot with me. It started out as a lore skin depicting an event. Then it morphed into the cultural portrayal of Shadow Isle champions, with Elise being a controversial skin. Now we have Zilean, with people begging you to do Diana. Do these skins have lore to them still, or is it about what looks cool? That last part isn't necessarily bad, but a little disappointing from me.
From the Gaurdian of the Sands launch:
Deep in the sands lies an arcane temple forsaken by a ruined kingdom. Deep in that temple lies an imposing tomb burnished with mystic runes and emerald scarabs. Deep in that tomb lies an ancient being of treacherous power.
These guys guard the temple next to that one.
And Risen Fiddlesticks:
The sands rise at his command. The guardians fall to his power. The scarabs flock to their master.
Everyone else just runs like hell.
This copy was written at the beginning of the year without much context from the concept artists and reminds me how much we've improved this year. Now we try to ensure that the initial ideas follow right through the production to ensure the final skins feel really thematically cohesive and the overall impression is strong. When I did the concept for GotS Kha'zix I was a freelance artist working from home and I only had a Shurima style guide to work from without much communication to drive story so I focused on creating a cool design that was basically 'What if Kha'zix was like Nasus and Renekton'. From what was written at launch I see the Guardians kind of like Nasus and Renekton; standing watch over the tomb that sealed a dangerous enemy of Shurima. In this case instead of Xerath it was Fiddlesticks, in a world where he is an all-powerful mummy commanding an army of scarabs. I often referred to him as feeling even more ancient than Azir and wanted him to have a custom taunt about how Azir may have ruled Shurima, but he built Shurima. I like to imagine him as the cursed return of the first emperor of the sands! obligatory reminder that this is not canon
The Shadowfire Kindred skin would suggest that there is a balance between forces of light and darkness, so I see skins like Gatekeeper Galio and Infernal Nasus as being the opposing force to Arclight. But where Arclight are organised under the all knowing eye of the might Vel'koz the Infernal seem to be more chaotic, serving themselves and bringing destruction without purpose. I guess Infernal are the disease and Arclight is the cure? Justicar comes from a time when skin names carried less weight; Justicar Syndra could have been Arclight perhaps and there really isn't anything that ties Syndra to Aatrox which makes it very difficult to even understand what the theme of Justicar is. We talk about it a lot internally because, while it's funny to joke about it (Arclight if the name starts with 'V' otherwise call it Justicar), it does point out the importance of a name and also to put thought into colour/shape/materials when fleshing out a skin line to ensure we meet player's expectations.
The original Bloodmoon skins were from 2011. I'm not sure any concept artist on the skins team now worked on the skins team then, which means it does happen that very old notes can get overlooked. From the launch of BM Thresh/Elise:
A sanguine moon stains a canvas of stars as two figures utter an ancient oath, swearing allegiance. They murmur the final words. Bloody light surges from their bodies. Power courses through transformed veins as masks materialize in their hands. Thresh and Elise embrace the Blood Moon. Join the ranks of an ancient sect with Blood Moon Elise and Blood Moon Thresh...
Yes the new skins aren't lore, but there's still this idea of performance and the Blood Moon night. Only instead of being part of the performance in the Serene Gardens, they are being initiated into an evil Ionian cult. They still however retain some theatrical elements as the cult has as much ritual and performance as the other events happening throughout Ionia on that evening:
We the animators decided it'd be cool if their recalls were related to traditional Japanese culture in some form or another. It just so happened that Kabuki was a strong influence on Kalista (which I also animated) and Thresh. For Elise I wanted to do something else that played off the more beautiful and calm appearance of her human form as well as the lore of the "Jorōgumo". -Riot Whist
As Riot Ant in Oz has said, BM Kalista is very much how she would be portrayed if one year at the Festival of Fire they told her story. Finally BM Zilean is considered to be linked to Thresh and Elise and is the Grand Master of the secret Blood Moon sect. His splash depicts him descending upon a crowd and absorbing their blood magic into his 'moons'. But is it his loyal followers or a hapless audience during the festivities?
So these skins all share some themes; Japanese folklore and Kabuki theatre, performances in Ionia on the night of the Blood Moon. However you are right they are loose ties that allow us to design a skin that best plays up the chosen champion. For example if we made BM Diana would she be a member of the cult, herself dressed as a hero from Ionian lore, or an Ionian representation of the Lunari from ancient times? That flexibility is very desirable in design.