Petition to Rework Feral Warwick (2017)

rtbf73979129·1/13/2017, 8:28:30 AM·39 votes·4,340 views
https://www.ipetitions.com/petition/rework-feral-warwick-skin-2017

Despite Riot's best efforts in explaining and justifying the rework of the Feral Warwick skin, many of us just can't be satisfied by their approach to let it be because it's already been made, despite many players protests. According to Riot's Reav3, they have no intention of fixing anything but the artwork image.

These protests include the skin ultimately not meeting the skin description, the skin no longer having the same visual value as the original, the skin having less work done on it than other skins (The Tundra skin for example, a 520 rp = $5 skin worth less than the Legacy Feral that is getting it's own vfx and is strikingly more visually appealing than the latter), and the skin resembling the theme of the default base skin too much.

If you are one of these players please lend your support officially in order to have Riot properly address the issue and give us a TRUE Feral Warwick.

Please note: Riot will not refund any money spent on the original Feral Warwick skin without players sacrificing one of their limited 3 lifetime refund tokens. This is known as Bait and Switch and is generally illegal. This is unfair and immoral for Riot to do to those who purchased the original and I do believe they have a duty to the people who bought the original skin to rise up to the complaints and deliver on something more akin to the original skin or give us the option to return the skin for a refund.

56 Comments

Hokuto1/14/2017, 12:07:44 PM11 votes

With the upcoming Warwick rework we have been presented with the reworked skins as well. All of his skins have been changed to fit his new looks and most of them give a pretty distinct feeling when playing the champ. Hyena Warwick gives that funky punker style which was built upon the existing Hyena theme. Firefang and Tundra Warwick have great visuals and present those elements (ice and fire) as Warwicks innate and controllable ability. Big bad Warwick and Marauder Warwick have stayed true to their original designs and haven't been extremely changed as they're, in fact, pretty cheap skins. Grey Warwick is decent, it is a pretty rare skin, due to the act that it was only obtainable through invitations, and a decent amount of effort has been put into making the new one satisfactory for the people that own the skin.

That leaves us with Feral Warwick. Out of all the skins, this one feels the most clunky and patched up together just for the sake of making him.

Splash Art In the splash art, Warwick is presented as an enraged beast. In it's fury, he's tearing down the lab he was trapped in and we can see the legs of what seems to be the person that was experimenting on Warwick (probably not Singed). The lab is heavily damaged; the door has been destroyed and we can see scratch marks on the lab floor coming from Warwick's mechanized arm. Warwick himself is scarred. His body is covered with the remains of his restraints as well as something that appears to be an asylum or a mental institution restrainment clothing. His augmentation seems to be additionally mechanized and improved in this skin. The arm is considerably bulkier than in the original artwork. We're, however, unable to see the augmentation on his back fully. His face depicts an enraged wolf, with saliva splashing around it and him showing off his teeth which is typical wolf behavior. There is however, a strange addition to his face, a small piece of metal that feels extremely out of place. It might be a part of a broken nozzle (unlikely), but it's extremely strange that such a monstrosity that is being experimented on and that is a danger to the people inside the lab has a spiked metal added on top of his already enormous teeth, to help him bite better.

Criticism The art itself is decently done. The background blur isn't too emphasized and it allows us to see the details of the lab Warwick has been held captive in, yet it is visible enough to divert us from looking at the lab and makes us focus on Warwick himself. A job well done. However, Warwick himself has some inconsistent features. It is true that if you're experimenting on Warwick and improving upon his original weaponry, you're aware that he's dangerous and the amount of restrains shown in the picture shows off the amount of security measures they've invested in keeping him restrained (still wasn't enough). However, there is the factor of arming the caged ''animal'' with additional weapons which is blatantly put, stupid and careless. Zaun is indeed a place where questionable experiments are conducted, but it hosts intelligent people and scientists, which I highly doubt would allow their laboratory experiment to run loose with all the augmentations done to his already existing weaponry. Singed was unaware that the subject he had experimented on was still alive, therefore his error was justified. Justifying the error of the scientists that worked on a live specimen is a lot harder. All in all, the splash art is, on the artistic side, a decent representation of the idea, but on the concept side, there are still some inconsistencies that show the lack of thought behind the scenery.

Conversion from old to new Feral Warwick criticism and debate The conversion idea of converting Warwick from a Feral beast that was once caged and is running rampant in the woods causing havoc, to a lab rat that's been extremely experimented on and has broken out of his chains is somewhat, in my personal opinion, questionable and very far from the original design. Feral Warwick was originally shown as a rampaging beast, destroying whatever he finds in his path, with the light of the full moon shining in the background. He was a true werewolf. The name feral used to fit him well. The new Feral Warwick is far from that, if we exclude his rampaging nature shown off in the new skin. He is now a subject of experimentation. While the idea of such a thing happening is decent itself, the name ''Feral'' doesn't fit.

Champion model criticism and debate

The Feral Warwick champion model is by far the most questionable design decision made. The model itself has too many additions which, as a result make it feel extremely clunky. The added augmentation parts make Warwick feel like a large clump of something and nothing, instead of a werewolf. It is okay to improve the existing things or completely re-imagine them as it was done in all the other skins (Hyena - car engine, Firefang and Tundra - Ice and Fire etc.) but to simply add more of the same is an obvious sign that there was a lack of inspiration. The champion model is a simple color conversion with additional augmentations added to the already existing ones. The spiked nozzle hides his face and mouth, feels clunky, unnecessary and overly emphasized.

My own opinions While the idea of additional experiments on Warwick is okay, the way it was developed isn't thoughtful of the true ''Feral'' theme this skin carried. The Original Feral Warwick was something that a skin owner could have been proud of; it gave off a new feel to the champion as well as a new model, in addition to it being a legacy skin. The new one is by far the least desirable skin Warwick has. It's clunky and visually unattractive, far from the original concept. It is no longer special in any way, aside it being different from the normal one (which is basically better than the Feral). I'd rather have a skin that shows a Feral Werewolf, a forest dweller that occasionally runs rampant in the cities or towns close by, just like the Firefang and Tundra Warwick have their non augmented yet improved arm and back, he could have a robust, muscular arm with huge fangs instead of the overly robust augmentations that feel out of place.

Sukishoo1/13/2017, 8:33:58 PM9 votes

Personally I like the update more than the original.

https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-djTbyMK5Glg/WHV0TGVWYhI/AAAAAAAAbto/VggUQHZV-VczkabdjfJIVcin7rZSpp_pACEw/s1600/ww5compare.jpg

Original to me just looks like a werewolf... there's nothing really "feral" about this. The update you can see is more of a cagged rabbit looking beast and that to me says Feral.

LZRD1/13/2017, 10:09:00 AM8 votes

What? So you'd be cool with them turning it into the old version, same skeleton, model, and all? I honestly don't understand this post. Feral had been a legacy for a long time, a rarely seen skin that was probably used plenty of times by their owners, for a champ that a majority of players knew was in need of an update. I'm someone that believes Feral WW approached slightly differently to give something similar to the old version, but to say that Riot is doing something illegal and giving us an inferior product I'd say is quite naive, irrational, and ungrateful considering the the old version of it was probably his most lazily done skin anyways. He was just naked and brown with some cuffs. Any of the original buyers obviously weren't in search of any fancy particles or animations. Sorry you were the very small group of people that didn't like a great rework. A hipster naked wolf skin wasn't selling, that's it.

ModAcademy Kayn1/13/2017, 10:31:39 AM6 votes

Well it's clear you don't know how law or business works.

A. When you bought Feral Warwick, you bought it at the time it as it was prerework. You used and played it. You got what you believed your money's worth from it. You did not buy it because "It might get reworked someday", you bought what you wanted at the time.

B. What this is anything similar to, is say an update for an iPhone. You bought the iPhone to have an iPhone, and you own it for say two years. One day, the iPhone updates it's Hud/screen/whatever and suddenly you don't like how it looks anymore. This isn't bait and switch... you bought the iPhone originally to have iPhone, not "in case it get's updated into something better"

C. You know how some companies don't let you return used footwear? Or how, if you don't have a receipt, you can't return something? Or, even this, if a certain time has passed you can't return something? This is no different.

The (RUDE due to it being late) TL;DR: You're acting like a whiney little bitch trying to use terms to make you look smart.

TL;DR: You bought something for the time it was released/around. You did not buy it "So it would be updated someday", you bought it to have what was sold.

Edit: You can downvote the rudeness, but you can't downvote the fact that exists in Business.

Lupus1/13/2017, 9:34:05 AM6 votes

Signed as well.

Share it on the skinspotlight youtube video

rtbf739791291/13/2017, 8:35:45 AM5 votes

Upvotes are appreciated as they help attract Riot's Eyes.

Mostro Gallo1/13/2017, 8:48:55 AM3 votes

Signed

VelvetCrotch1/13/2017, 10:08:52 AM2 votes

Can't atm - will try later

VelvetCrotch1/14/2017, 2:31:16 PM2 votes

Done :)

Noctix1/15/2017, 2:57:31 AM1 votes

Signed. I'd love for them to keep the current reworked one, but put it under a new name while reworking something new for Feral Warwick that's a lot truer to the original Feral Warwick skin. As of right now Grey Warwick looks closer to the original Feral Warwick skin then Feral Warwick does.