Ionia might not be the pretty utopia of freedom and magic.

carrotbunny·2/16/2019, 9:16:07 PM·6 votes·2,927 views

So before I start I'm going to admit that I'm no lore expert and I haven't really read much. However as far as I know Ionia is supposed to be a land of peace and freedom where everything is nice and dandy as opposed to places like Zaun or Demacia, which might not be true after all. Xayah's quotes seem to try really hard at hinting this but no matter how much I tried to I could never buy them, especially after reading one of her stories where other vastayah wanted to seek help with the Kinkou but she outright refused just because they are humans, so I simply took her hate for civilization as negligence rather than wisdom and made me dislike her quite a bit (and even more for how brainwashed she has poor Rakan). Yet the more I think about the more Ionia seems to be as if not more autoritarion than places like Demacia. Like the fact that they keep sending assassins to kill Yasuo with no chance to claim his innocence (then again he doesn't seemt to be trying that hard, to the point where he even murdered his own brother so maybe he's the one at fault here, maybe not), the fact that Jhin was released from prison to be used as an assassin and other questionable decisions makes me wonder if Ionia is what it claims to be. I would hope for someone who knows more about lore to either support or discredit my theory since I have yet much to read.

(Still don't like Xayah though, hopefully since the lore is supposedly moving forward now we'll see her grow up a bit)

7 Comments

LordRedStone Nr12/16/2019, 11:32:29 PM3 votes

If you are interested, read "Confessions of a Broken Blade" (3 parts, part 1 here .), it continues Yasuo's story.

With Jhin, you are right. The circumstances of his release are still unclear, but he certainly can not do anything good.

Xayah is a special case. She does not hate all humans, she's trying to secure a life for her tribe. Vastaya need magic in the environment, magic that humans try to enslave and use. Take "Wild Magic", their teaser, where Zed uses this magical thing (I know there is a name for it, I'm just too lazy to search for it) to "steal" the magic of the land, which later returns to it in the last shot. However, the years of fighting may have changed her and that's how she developed her hatred for humans, even if she would agree with some of them (Karma & Shen maybe)

Now, in Ionia certainly not everything is right and life is hard, especially after the noxian invasion. But most of the citizens are hard-working farmers that try to live in peace with the magic around them - the government on the other hand is something we know almost nothing about. The government that freed Jhin, mind you.

RyzeTheSmurfMage2/17/2019, 6:30:41 AM3 votes
  1. Yasuo has been proven innocent recently so no more assasins sent after him
  2. Yeah Ionia is very corrupt.
some degenerate2/17/2019, 2:19:47 AM2 votes

It isn't. You already provided more than enough evidence in your post to support your statement.

IMO, the real problem is that Riot's writing team hasn't given us a proper story or a lore reveal that details Ionia's inner societal & political corruption in a meaningful and in-depth matter yet, like they've already done for Demacia, Noxus, Piltover and Zaun. Sure, we've gotten small notions and mentions that briefly allude to Ionia's inner evils on a surface level - but nothing more than that. And this has been going on for years, to the point where I can't help but think that Riot's intentionally avoiding it for some reason or another. So much so, that they're willing to introduce a second Noxian invasion into the lore that'll undoubtedly continue to push Ionia as some forever-victimized, harmonious, good-guy utopia.

And I don't think it's a coincidence that the factions which received these "moral" grey lore updates/retcons just-so happened to be factions that were strongly based off of western society. And I don't think it's a coincidence that the Ionian champions who just-so happen to have some personal beef with their faction are all of Ionia's seemingly "evil" or "morally-questionable" champions, either. Zed, Syndra, Jhin, Kayn, Xayah and Rakan all have their own varying issues with Ionian society and culture - but I wouldn't consider any of them to be "good" people whose beliefs and views are wholly justified through their actions, as they've all done some _very bad _ things at some point in their lore.

The only one who didn't comply to the status quo was Yasuo, who was forced to kill bounty hunters, his peers and even his own brother entirely out of self-defense. In fact Yasuo's backstory would've provided Riot with a perfect opportunity to explore Ionia's darker side if the murder of his master happened to be inside-job from a rival family clan or dojo... but that didn't turn out to be the case. Instead it turns out that Riven really was the murderer all along and she was just suffering from some half-assed, mumbo-jumbo PTSD delusion. And even then, Yasuo's mentor wasn't acting in self-defense when Riven barged into his temple. She simply asked him to remove the evil curse that Leblanc enchanted into her rune blade. He (surprisingly and unrealistically) obliges and then the blade explodes in his face, killing him in the process. So it all turns out being the underwhelming aftermath of a complete accident.

Eventually one Ionian counsel holds a trial for both Yasuo and Riven in their latest short story, and through a series of borderline laughable events, their jury and judge declare both of them innocent, despite Riven's past affiliations as an important enemy soldier, or the fact that Yasuo killed dozens and dozens of people while he was a wanted man. There's a brief mention a shady priest who tried to frame Yasuo as a guilty man during his short trial, but I doubt Riot's ever going to explore this plot point in the near future any time soon, since they've yet to do the same with any other notable point points that've briefly mentioned anything about Ionia's inner corruption in the past.

Maybe I'm just jumping to conclusions... but it's almost like Riot's terrified at the possibility of potentially offending their massive Asian consumer base by implementing their own innate cultural issues and societal corruption into Ionia's lore. Sounds crazy and maybe even borderline-offensive to some, but I'm just going to assume that this is the case if China's political censorship in movies, games and TV media is anything to go by. Meanwhile most western nations don't really seem to care if a company takes a page or two from the corruption that's prevalent in their societies, governments, economies or social classes and uses it as worldbuilding inspiration for their IP, which is probably the reason why Zaun, Demacia, Noxus and Piltover have clearly defined & explored "good sides" and "bad sides."

tamaya2/17/2019, 4:38:22 AM2 votes

Usually I see such topics, I think that it is the same in Piltover but why does not it come up to the topic. [sg-lux-2]

Psyrix2/17/2019, 5:12:43 AM2 votes

lol, I agree, tho i think 's subtle. Syndra's original lore lead quite a few to theorize that the elders weren't all that benevolent, and I'd always hoped Riot would expand upon that, add some political nuance to Ionia.... Which they did do... but they changed Syndra's character so it wouldnt fit the mold anymore... before she was a misunderstood, powerful person with little restraint who'd been betrayed then threatened, thus lashed out understandably. Now she's still misunderstood, yes... but she wasnt threatened, the was being placated and she blew up instead... somrthing that utterly destroyed quite a few metric tons of sympathy/empathizing/relatability