Shyvana The Winged Beast Analysis

GreatSirZachary·1/2/2020, 5:18:02 PM·9 votes·11,199 views

Hello, GreatSirZachary here. You may have seen my previous threads on the topic of Shyvana’s lore, character design, and gameplay.

Shyvana’s color story, The Winged Beast, is significant because it was the farthest along we’ve ever pushed Shyvana’s narrative until the mention in the Lux comic. We get to see how Shyvana beaves now that she is a part of Demacian society. In the past versions of Shyvana’s lore things stopped after she returned with Jarvan IV to Demacia. It also reaffirms Shyvana’s main themes. As I discussed in my analysis of Shyvana’s bio those are empathy and community. I will also be discussing another theme, one of my favorites. In fiction, characters with fire powers usually get hotheaded, volatile, personalities that can spiral out of control. You know, like a forest fire. The other common thing these kinds of characters explore is self-control. What that means depends on the author. Sometimes it means unhealthily suppressing how they really feel. Sometimes it means letting out those feelings and all of those destructive consequences. Other times, and this is my favorite, it means whether you wield power or whether power wields you. To put it another way, the struggle between civilization mastering the wild and the wild resisting mastery. That is where Shyvana comes in.

In the Winged Beast Shyvana investigates a watchtower and finds that the guard, Thomme, is not at his post. She smells his blood.

She chewed her tongue to distract herself from her growing hunger at the scent.

This is the first indication of Shyvana’s fight against her beastial side in this story. Let’s make sure we go this clear: Shyvana is literally bloodthirsty here. Smelling human blood makes her hungry! But that bloodthirstiness and Shyvana’s ability to track the creature that killed Thomme come from the same source. Shyvana turns her fixation on blood into something that serves her humanity by tracking the creature with her sense of smell. When Shyvana catches up to the creature using her keen sense of smell it is stated explicitly:

The smell of fresh blood was intoxicating, but Shyvana forced herself to focus on the hunt. She had joined Demacia to be part of something greater, not to surrender to her animalistic desires.

Here we reaffirm Shyvana choosing community and civilization over predation and savagery. When Shyvana comes face to face with the creature, the vellox, she sees that the face looks human. I think this is more than just make the human-eating creature scary, it is to present Shyvana with a dark reflection. Something that has a resemblance to humanity, but has chosen savagery. The creature talks to Shyvana, another resemblance to humans. The ability to speak also shows us velloxes are intelligent. An intelligent creature can wield agency, can choose and the vellox has chosen the beast.

When approached by Shyvana this vellox, currently eating Thomme, simply smiles and says “All yours,” and runs away. It is clear immediately that the vellox assumes Shyvana is acting as a predator, not as a civilized person. The vellox interprets the situation differently. The vellox sees this as a lion scaring a hyena off of a buffalo carcass and claiming it as their own. The vellox has already eaten some and decides it isn’t worth the effort to fight over the leftovers. We, the human readers, and Shyvana the civilized half-dragon see a vicious murder that must be punished.

Once again, Shyvana follows the scent of Thomme’s blood to track the vellox. The beast serving the human. When she hits a ravine she has to rely further on the beast, but doing so makes controlling it more difficult. She transforms into her dragon form by embracing “her hunger until it powered the furnace-heat beneath her skin.” She must feed the fire a bit to make it useful. However, the bigger a fire gets the harder it is to control.

When Shyvana catches up to the vellox the creature finally realizes who Shyvana isThe vellox’s attitude shows us that from its point of view Shyvana has chosen wrong in choosing humanity. The vellox thinks Shyvana has sacrificed her freedom and that it isn’t worth it. Their dialogue lays it all out

“I know you,” the vellox snarled, fighting to break free. “They call you the Chained One.” The golden beast leapt, slashing taloned paws and grazing her throat with its teeth. Shyvana sank her claws into its back and savored the sensation of tearing flesh. “Why do you hunt me?” the vellox asked. “We are not enemies.” “You killed a soldier of the Demacian army,” Shyvana said. “Thomme.” The vellox drew blood from her neck, but she exhaled plumes of fire and it spun away to avoid the flames. “Was he your friend?” “No.” “And yet you attempt to avenge his death. I fear the rumors are true. You are merely a tamed pet.” Shyvana growled. “At least I am no killer of men,” she said. “Truly?” the vellox smiled through its stained teeth. “You have no thirst for human blood?” Shyvana circled the vellox. “I see the hunger in your eyes,” it said. “The taste for living meat. You need the hunt as much as I. After all, where’s the fun in a meal without a good chase?”

Notice that Shyvana enjoys clawing the vellox, Notice how the vellox calls her out for enjoying the hunt. They are not all that different. The vellox rejects the concept of comradery or tribal identification beyond the ones you personally know. Shyvana, in contrast, stands by her ideas of community and duty. They fight and Shyvana wins, but that is not the important part. The important part is after she kills him.

Though her hunger was unrelenting, Shyvana stopped herself before she devoured his flesh.

Shyvana exhibits executive control. She consciously overrides her instincts and leaves behind the vellox’s body. This is what makes Shyvana heroic, she chooses the human over the beast even though it is harder. It requires continuous conscious effort to become the kind of person she wants to be. However, Shyvana also would not have succeeded without the beast. The strength lies in her ability to wield power (make the beast serve the human) and not be wielded by it (devour the flesh of the vellox). Our connection as readers is we need anger and fury and fear and all of those things. It is all about knowing when and how to administer those things that makes for an emotionally mature person.

7 Comments

AIQ1/2/2020, 7:26:08 PM4 votes

It's great to have this and your analysis of this section is spot on.

Unfortunately, this only makes sense if she grew up with her father in the "wild" if you will. As you are well aware, Shyvanas 4th iteration coincides well with this story, but her 5th... well not so much.

Her being raised in Piltover, would have quickly quelled he lust for flesh as humans would be all she knows. Hunting, while still possibly instinctive, would not be Shyvanas primary source of searching for food, such as an actual domesticated "pet" like the vellox calls her. Her being raised with a human for the majority of her life, takes her beastly side away and makes this story lose a lot of power, and makes the vellox right.

Based on the time, Shyvana also would not likely be well known in Demacia or the wild creatures of Demacia like the vellox states "the know her as The Chained One." Because either this is before Sylas, and she would have been kept under wraps. Or this is after him and she was in Piltover the entire time till just recently meaning she was a big deal and everyone knows she's a dragon or no one really does.

Hope that makes sense.

So while this story does exhibit her self control, unfortunately the retcon makes it make no sense that she should be struggling with this animalistic desire, unless the thief was really bad and... you know... let her hunt. Which in that case, it all makes sense, lol.

mrmeddyman1/2/2020, 9:09:32 PM3 votes

How big is Shyvana is her dragon form? Maybe the Vellox is similarily huge, but the story makes it seem like she's on par with it given the fight.

Is she rideable dragon or more Wyvern-like

zounet1/2/2020, 5:59:05 PM2 votes

Great post! Your analysis is really well done*[slayer-pantheon-thumbs]*

thefatlazycat1/2/2020, 5:55:07 PM1 votes

Imagine reading the title of this and not knowing the title of shyvana's colour story, I was so excited for a moment

Whyte Lyon1/3/2020, 1:12:55 AM1 votes

I'd recommend uploading this to the official reddit page. Just because I feel like your analysis can reach the vast amount of people who arent in the know about lore and more inclined to learn a lot out of this analysis

I say this as, at least imo, majority of people who float around SA&S boards are pretty familiar with 90% of the lore and the themes contained in the individual stories. Like I read this post and thought the thematics and whatnot were self-evident. But Reddit contains many more who arent so much "aficionados".