Theory: The "Bilgewater Tithe" is some sort of Pirate code
So, Nautilus got his lore updated to make him look more of a good-natured kind of entity that helps the wretched but drowns the greedy.
The one thing that stayed the same from his "placeholder" lore though is the mention of a so-called "Bilgewater Tithe". Now, for those unaware, a tithe is some sort of a tax, suggesting that there's some sort of ritual the denizens of Bilgewater indulge in where they do have to pay this tithe.
But is it materialistic in nature? I honestly do not think so. I believe the Bilgewater Tithe is some sort of code of honor, the one thing that keeps Bilgewater from just collapsing unto itself as people just eat each other with no regards for their common good.
I think this tithe is some sort of pirate code, some sort of commandments that help this pirate nation to actually not only keep existing but also to thrive. A code that helps the common sailors, the bilge rats to not get swallowed whole and exploited by their captains, ergo why Naut drowns the greedy.
So, is the tithe a code of honor bent on keeping the powerful from exploiting those who are the basis of their might? What is a captain without their crew anyways?
Thoughts?
is just Nagakabouros tax collector.