So for the Second Time, Older but Good Splash Arts are Being Replaced by Crappy Chinese Ones...

The Loli Support·3/26/2016, 3:24:21 PM·113 votes·14,132 views

The first time this happened was when the marvelous, full of life splash of Blood Moon Akali was replaced by a slightly higher resolution, but far less lively and interesting one from the Chinese client one. I was unhappy then, as the first skin I bought was Blood Moon Akali, and to a large degree due to how much I loved the old splash art. Eventually though, I forgot about that.

I had seen the Riot Art Team become amazing, and pull out some really spectacular pieces, most recent of which the new Poppy skins splashes. I had really started growing hopeful. So when I heard that all old splashes are getting updated, I did not even think that they would repeat the fiasco from a few years back. I was thinking we'll get something Poppy-like for all the old splashes. Oh, how wrong I was.

Once again, we have good, if somewhat aged splash arts being replaced by obviously subpar, cheap, expressionless and overall bland Chinese artwork, some of which is absolutely appallingly generic to the point you would have a hard time of recognizing the character for what it is ingame. Many of my favorite splash arts are getting replaced with things I would pay money not to see, but the one that hurts the most is another splash by KNKL - the maker of the old Blood Moon Akali, Redeemed Riven, and several other ones that single-handedly made me want the skins - the Midnight Ahri one. It is a great example of just how unnecessary and destructive the change is. For comparison, this is the new artwork and this is the old one. The obviously failed attempt to mesh the new one's style with the old one aside - the whole mysticism, expression, feeling of the old art is gone, replaced by the usual bland, expressionless dollface so typical of cheap, and I underline, cheap Chinese art pieces. There are many great Chinese artists and art pieces, and I did not see a single good one that is at all representative of League's artstyle among the new ones. Hell, just look at the new Karma ones, and you'll probably want to cry too.

Riot Art Team. I have great respect for you. I am not expecting a response, but please. As a professional artist myself, please answer me, and give me one good reason to replace current good-looking art, even if slightly aged, with what we seem to be getting soon. Do you honestly believe that those "new" splash arts are representative of League's style and feeling? I fully understand the need to unify splash arts between regions, and support it. But why replace the GOOD Western art with the BAD Eastern art? If it was good Eastern art, I would have nothing against it - I do not want to turn this into a regional difference issue. But from an artistic standpoint, those pieces have absolutely nothing to offer over most of the current ones besides questionably higher resolution. And resolution is far from anything. It pains me to see good art go to waste and be forgotten, just to be replaced with cheap imitations or pieces that lack even the slightest glint of the expressiveness, feeling and emotions shown in ones we have.

You can do better than this. I know you can, because you have.

93 Comments

yay nibbers3/26/2016, 8:05:37 PM33 votes

Yo if you have a problem with the Ahri splashes, that's cool. I kinda agree that they're pretty unnecessary, it's literally just face changes. But a lot of the Chinese art is really cool and are perfectly good pieces. You can't just link the Ahri face change and say that all the Chinese art is equally lame. Here's some good ones for example, that all are just as good if not improvements over the originals: https://2.bp.blogspot.com/--8Kxq4gvKac/VvWrdnPfm7I/AAAAAAAAMp8/-oy_KSSQELI_wNL9ENfjWgjGyJaC36gow/s1600/MissFortune_Splash_5.jpg https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-UkPE3_XFh44/VvWrda65XbI/AAAAAAAAMqA/lJjW8PVpgRgxUvFkr9Zi1vSCO9wsfNEng/s1600/MissFortune_Splash_3.jpg https://3.bp.blogspot.com/-V9Fvgql4GDw/VvWrXsoKbhI/AAAAAAAAMn4/y2oGLtQpZ0Qz8foeee0IMnqIP4T2WU_gA/s1600/Akali_Splash_6.jpg https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-e1ketrNSkPE/VvWrXRYby_I/AAAAAAAAMn0/ZjXEGq0yFWMNhhyBKvVHqdqLFgs6Pdi8A/s1600/Akali_Splash_2.jpg https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-uDrZZPuQMpY/VvWrX2wKEDI/AAAAAAAAMn8/6ThCpjB8GskN30Xm6pFbXFrxyWPpyhCDw/s1600/Alistar_Splash_4.jpg https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-8ViplORhINE/VvWraEjJMKI/AAAAAAAAMow/_d0if8DF1UsE6EWo_14WRRDOcqqYL2xfw/s1600/Evelynn_Splash_1.jpg https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-iQ_XrKlOCpo/VvWrbu8RVpI/AAAAAAAAMpQ/HWMRqOMOmGUVBDFwdpSx5M6Oisff6uS0Q/s1600/Janna_Splash_1.jpg https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-k6CXLykldCw/VvWrc-5pq-I/AAAAAAAAMps/_-W31_DyMQYnthrQDUIN3pdGoXHc8gq6g/s1600/MasterYi_Splash_4.jpg That's all just from the current batch on the PBE and it's not even all the good ones.

Compare them to some of the current splashes: http://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/leagueoflegends/images/9/9c/Akali_SilverfangSkin.jpg/revision/20160325210318 http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/leagueoflegends/images/8/8f/Evelynn_ShadowSkin.jpg/revision/20160325224005 http://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/leagueoflegends/images/5/52/Janna_TempestSkin.jpg/revision/20160326005313 I know taste is subjective, but the Chinese ones are way better than these.

You can't just go cherry picking and making blanket statements about the other splashes. Yes, some are pretty lame. The Fiora splash is particularly lame compared to the current. But to say they're all just as bad is just wrong.

scoot3/26/2016, 5:43:34 PM14 votes

Honestly, I'm pretty displeased with a lot of the decisions Riot has been making lately in regards to story for champions (re: Diana and Leona) as well as art. I'm all for using the same art on all things, but when they get really awesome art, like Poppy Poppy's art or Annie Annie's newer default NA splash, and replace it with what they're doing with Sanguine Garen's new art? It just feels bad.

I mean, don't get me wrong, the previous artwork on Sanguine Garen could use updating to match the new style that League had been going for as of late, but to replace it with something that's basically of (in my opinion as a player and as an artist) lower quality seems like a really bad decision. Riot wants the excitement of "Oh yeah, new art!" but they're just recycling older art that has a lot of problems in it to begin with. In the new Sanguine Garen skin, the perspective is waay off. It reminds me of the original character art that they used to have. Like Evelynn's old splash art (like the art used on the old version of Shadow Evelynn)

I don't think ALL of the eastern art is bad-- take the new art for Masquerade Evelynn and Shadow Evelynn. Both of those are exponentially better than what was previously used.

But to take something that isn't super great as it is and to replace it with something of equally not-so-great quality seems like a cheap way of Riot trying to cut corners and not have to actually purchase art that's of the same quality as some of the newer skins.

On to the matter of the new Midnight Ahri splash: I do think that this art could use updating to match the new style of League's art, but what they've done seems REALLY shady of a thing to do. It looks like they just photoshopped a different head onto the already existing art. It doesn't look "better" this way. I don't think the new head itself is bad on its OWN, but with this whole piece, it looks really horribly done.

Riot, I know you want to make as much money as possible, and a lot of the easiest way to do that is to cut corners with stuff like this instead of purchasing/paying artists to make new versions, but COME ON. That head doesn't even match the rest of the style of that picture! Maybe you're thinking "oh, someone that isn't an artist won't notice" or something, but it's PAINFUL to look at.

All in all, I agree with OP's displeasure. I'm really losing faith in Riot nowadays, so I guess I should have expected them to cut corners and do cheap things like this instead of investing in actual good art for characters whose art needs updating.

JackMcSnipeyz3/26/2016, 8:43:42 PM9 votes

I must add, the new caitlyn safari and arctic warfare are also both terrible. Safari caitlyn looked classy and polite, and had actual safari in her picture. New one is just generic, big boob, smooth legs girl with a sniper, next to a waterfall? Its so bad i consider not using it anymore.

xVaseFullofAcidx3/26/2016, 9:51:10 PM8 votes

Im just gonna bring this splash art that we will be getting. And this is one of my favorite skins now I will probably never use this skin again.

http://i.imgur.com/JDuLqoD.jpg[/img]

Bladerunner77773/26/2016, 8:04:34 PM8 votes

I agree

The Chinese Infiltrator Irelia splash art looks decent: http://i.imgur.com/DLEy85L.jpg

But she looks like she's modeling. The current infiltrator Irelia is a snapshot of the action; like Irelia is actually infiltrating something. Chinese splash looks like she's being abducted by aliens. I would prefer an interesting low res splash instead of a boring high res splash.

Current splash btw: https://i.ytimg.com/vi/sSlNApr_DKI/maxresdefault.jpg

Solitair3/26/2016, 11:44:24 PM6 votes

You people have zero understanding or ability to percieve any manner of art. The great "fiasco" of the midnight ahri splash is literally just giving her a higher quality face. That is the only change. Her face is still dead-eyed and expressionless in the old splash. No special something has been lost, simply, a low-budget fix has been applied to a lower-budget splash. I really don't understand this misguided waifu-overprotectiveness.

H4C1lM1aRJ3/26/2016, 10:26:17 PM6 votes

I personally really like the new Ahri splashes for Midnight and Dynasty. I never really liked Dynasty Ahri's face (I mean it was okay; just never was a huge fan of it :P ). Midnight Ahri's face was fine in the original. But to each their own.

Maratsune3/26/2016, 8:59:02 PM6 votes

The Karma skins are ones that I can only just plead for Riot to not change. I mean, for the Sun Goddess one neither of them are ideal, but the Sakura one is just insulting. The glowing blue fans, the dark green kimono, the ANIME. I just... I really, really don't like it. And it's one of my favourite Karma skins to use. Please please please Riot.

Bret Hitman Hart3/26/2016, 11:00:09 PM5 votes

All of Karthus's Chinese splash arts are worse than his NA ones just because the Chinese have that taboo about skeletons. Skeletons are cool. Sorry China.

I definitely agree with the OP about most of his grievances. What's funniest to me about this whole situation is that the worst NA splash art of them all (Classic Warwick) could have been replaced by the far superior Chinese one, but nah. Just replace all the good skeletal Karthus art and debatably better MF, Akali, Irelia art. A shame.

Meep Man3/26/2016, 6:49:28 PM5 votes

That new splash is pretty decent. The old one didnt have all that many details in the face, the new one just makes it look more similar to her current base splash really. Not much else.

AntiSkillshot3/27/2016, 2:24:08 AM4 votes

Uhm... you do realize that the Ahri splash you showed isn't even the Chinese one, right?

THIS is the Chinese Midnight Ahri splash. http://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/leagueoflegends/images/2/22/Ahri_MidnightSkin_Ch.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20121128190021

And thank God we're not getting that... thing...

Pledgie3/26/2016, 6:17:16 PM4 votes

i do have to say one thing about the midnight ahri thing tho. her new face does look a LOT more like the updated base splash, which was more cat like, with the eyes.

GreenLore3/26/2016, 11:43:32 PM4 votes

While I agree that some of the chinese arts aren't that good,I feel its really odd how you complain about midnight ahri out of all of them.

I mean not only is the change rather small,but the "dull face" as you describe it looks more mystical to me than the old one(the old one looks a bit like she isn't paying attention,which overall makes it kinda derpy for me).

LoL Ergo Urgot3/26/2016, 8:27:07 PM4 votes

Reaper Karthus doesn't even resemble Karth.

Celio Hogane HD3/27/2016, 3:51:04 PM3 votes

you did just put Ahri splash as an example.

You are trolling.

Sassmast3r3/26/2016, 6:51:56 PM3 votes

For me, if it's an already outdated splash itself, and they're simply changing it slightly to make it globally the same (even if it isn't an improvement), as long as it doesn't make the splash worse, then I genuinely do not care. Sun goddess Karma for example, doesn't look good right now, and the china one doesn't look much better, but they're both bad, so it doesn't bother me as much. Whereas, Night Raven Fiora's splash is beautiful, the chinese one is crap, and they're actually considering replacing it with the chinese one just for the sake of globalization, now that pisses me off. I don't recall a single person in the NA server saying "Gosh, I hate the NA splash arts, the chinese ones are so much better." Besides, if they did say that, my response is for them to then go play on the chinese server if they have a problem with it.

Maybe it's just me, but this seems like a subtle way of riot basically saying "It would take too much time to update all the old splash arts again, so we're trying to just globalize them and shift our focus to more "important" things." My response is no, finish what you've started. Don't let us see a piece of cake and not let us eat it, either don't update a single splash art ever, or update all of the ones that are clearly not up to your standard. I can deal with some of them being globalized if they aren't changing that much, but as long as this isn't just a workaround for Riot.

Star Guardían3/26/2016, 10:16:08 PM3 votes

If you fully understand the need to unify slapshes across all regions you'd understand that this is the best compromise that can be made. Both NA and China are losing splashes they love. If this was put up for a vote I assure you the outcome would have been worse for us since there are far more Chinese players that could vote for their splash arts. So you kinda have to roll with the punches until they get updated. Besides you only ever see them for 1min during the loading screen and I doubt you own every skin and champion being replaced.

JacctheInsomniac3/27/2016, 3:26:51 AM3 votes

[deleted]

joliesse3/27/2016, 11:40:38 AM2 votes

Two of the skins I own that I think the NA version do much better are Arctic Warfare Caitlyn and Exiled Morgana. Exiled Morgana really needed an update, but the Chinese version is a total downgrade!

Keevalroy3/26/2016, 9:05:08 PM2 votes

Seeing so much hate for this decision makes me wonder how China is reacting to this. It seems like we want less than a fourth of them - I'm curious if they feel the same way about our splashes being forced on them.

GhostOfShrimpmas3/26/2016, 7:09:34 PM1 votes

Are those two ahri links different? Near as I can tell, that's just the same art with slightly more black space on the far left of the background on one of them.