[Theory] The Watchers, The Void and the Fermi Paradox

Blood Magicks·3/25/2019, 8:08:48 PM·20 votes·13,401 views

As discussed in the past, cosmic horror is what makes Lovecraftian fiction shine. Authors like Lovecraft, Ligotti and Junji Ito make readers feel their own insignificance in the face of a malevolent cosmic force dictating humanity’s doom. When executed well, this horror works because it banks almost entirely on the fear of the unknown, yet ends up chillingy believable due to its philosophical, speculative nature.

I want to analyze League's Watchers because I think the allegory behind them is too obvious to be a pure coincidence.

##I think the Watchers/the Void are an allegory for the Great Filter in the context of the Fermi paradox.

In short, many of you have probably heard about the Fermi Paradox. It says that if the Universe has existed for billions of years and there are so many stars with Earth-like planets, then how come we've encountered no evidence of alien life, or even alien life capable of interstellar travel and expansion? Also known as Fermi's famous “Where is everybody?” this paradox has several proposed solutions, one of which is the Great Filter.

Essentially some scientist think there exists a cosmic principle that makes alien civilisations unlikely to survive until they become technologically advanced. This can be anything, from the fact that once a species discovers nukes or fossil fuels or nanotech it inevitably makes its planet uninhabitable, to a literal malevolent alien patrol dedicated to wiping out life as soon as it is born. Here a video I like:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UjtOGPJ0URM&

I think the really clever bit about the Void in League is a metaphor for all of the above, and maybe more:

  • In McNeill's Icathia we see the self-destructive impulse of an enslaved nation as they invoke the Void to destroy both their enemies and themselves. Here, I think, opening a Void rift shares many characteristics with nuclear warfare.

  • In Reynolds’ Eye in the Abyss we see the malevolent cosmic patrol bit of it, and we follow the Frostguard on a tense and futile battle to hold the end of the world at bay. There's something quintessentially lovecraftian in the cold, hard intelligence of the beings that will inevitably bring about the end of Runeterra.

The Void is both of the above, the absence of things, annihilation one way or another. It's also endlessly poetic how, just like us, Runeterrans both fight their own destruction and subconsciously desire it.

##Finally, it’s scary because it’s real, a concept that to this day terrifies scientists and philosophers alike.

So, if this is an intentional allegory, well done lore team. I've not really talked to Rioters about the Void, so this is just speculation. But if it's correct, then it raises another question:

Are the Watchers the reason Runeterra is the only living world in the League universe, solving League's own Fermi Paradox?

11 Comments

Oleandervine3/25/2019, 9:14:21 PM5 votes

Oh boy. That paradox sounds hella hokey. It wants us to legitimately believe that we're "the chosen ones," a sentient society that has somehow evaded killing ourselves or having our planet's shifting climate accidentally kill us.

I would say that the reason we perceive ourselves to be alone is that we can't detect other societies yet, AND the math is simply against us in that the probability of the same science happening that spawned life here would be pretty small. The paradox assumes that we should have been visited by aliens already in the billions of years the earth has been around, and cites no evidence for it. Yet it can't know this, mainly because it wasn't until extremely recently that we've been able to properly document things. Plus, we are also unaware of HOW alien technology works, so we could have been visited without leaving evidence, especially if they treat us like how we treat nature preserves - leave only footprints, take only pictures.

I also think that applying this paradox to the Void is a fallacy. The Void is primarily based on the monsters and unknown eldritch horrors in HP Lovecraft's work, since they're also monstrous entities from the space between dimensions in the great unknown the mind cannot perceive. Given that Lovecraft mostly preceded Fermi, and that knowledge and information wasn't as easily spread in those days as it is now, it's a pretty safe assumption to say that Lovecraft probably didn't base his works off of Fermi. So I think you're making a coincidental correlation here.

tamaya3/25/2019, 8:53:45 PM2 votes

Oh by the way, I saw such an answer with Kayle and Morgana's AMA. "When they encounter a common enemy they may cooperate again." There was a president who made such remarks in the real world. What was the enemy he said?

Also, I have felt that Pirutova‘s story has not written the shortcomings of this city hitherto. However, if this theory is correct,Great filters will be in front of them, not behind them, and "city of progress"Pirutova may become the most dicey area for Runeterra.

One more, It's interesting to think about holographic theory, Rune Terra and the real world.

Galiö3/25/2019, 8:18:05 PM1 votes

But if the watchers learn about self destructiveness, wont they also end up destroying themselves?

How much joy does this bring mundo?

Teehee

But in all seriousness interesting ideas

Lewanor3/25/2019, 9:13:32 PM1 votes

I think it's like this, it is the perfect weapon to end the universe. Here is the other Kurzgesagt video on Fermi Paradox with the timestamped of the thing i speak of. Magic instead of technology and I think the ones in our planet were in dormant state. Watchers are some kind of ancient beings that are very powerful, but in the end just exploited this kind of weapon.

https://youtu.be/1fQkVqno-uI?t=194

Vlada Cut3/29/2019, 8:45:16 AM1 votes

No. The Watchers want ALL live forms dead sk their starlight can stop eaking them up in their own dark universe