[Idea] Regarding parent child visibility

Verandure·12/6/2013, 8:31:54 PM·1 votes·263 views

As discussions progress, it is not uncommon for there to be a linear decrease in legibility. To combat this, the original format calls for the side shift of posts (to break the column and help anchor one's eyes to a certain post); however, when there are multiple responses linked to a single parent -- some with, some without, children of their own -- the readability greatly diminishes.

To resolve this; I suggest the implementation of auto-collapsed sub-discussions under certain parameters. Instead of just showing the parent of this discussion; however, show a short thesis as writ by that poster at the time of writing. This would evolve larger discussions into a format that would reciprocate the front page of the Platform; allowing for more efficient dissemination of information by the reader and promotes better writing on part of the respondents by giving them a thesis around which to build their response.

I am not familiar with the language used for websites, so my example is in pure logical form:

If child greater-than-or-equal-to ___, then collapse discussion. Hyperlink text equal to thesis title

To even better promote visibility; expand very large sub-discussions in a new window (child greater than or equal to 10)much like the formatting options, rather than a full tab. This all may lead to a "rabbit hole effect", but I feel that it would drastically improve legibility an organization for readers coming to an already busy discussion [see. Yasuo a.m.a. on Reddit]

The thesis should be character bounded to the same number of characters as normal discussion titles. They are meant as a sub-title to capture the entire theme of the discussion. Of course, there will be many times in the course of the platform when the intent for a discussion will go ignored, but these cases happen even with the current system whereby posters post completely non-sequitur comments that gain traction.

1 Comments

Archainis12/8/2013, 12:26:36 AM1 votes

Judging from my observations of other forums where posts can include a post title, I'm inclined to believe that most posters won't bother writing a post thesis.

I think a better solution would be to have stronger visual indications of which posts are children and which posts are siblings. The nesting as of current doesn't really pop (and if the gradients got crazier, it might be rougher to read), so it might be a good idea to try to implement either an interface that allows skipping between posts (like the red tracker) or a visual indicator that connects parents to children but not siblings to siblings.