Skip to content

Isn't permanent bans way too much?

Hokuto No Shen··3 votes·2,929 views

(Before you downvote this, let me clarify this: I was close to get a permaban two times I'm my entire League career. I got my first 2-week suspension 2 years ago and my second one last year. I got my first suspension because I was a total idiot, but my second suspension was one of the dumpest suspensions I have ever seen. My behavior has been slightly improved. I see someone toxic? I mute and after the game, i report).

Don't you guys think that permabanning people is a bit too much? I mean, I have seen people saying even worse, for example people that say "homophobic slurs" ,are not gettinf banned, but people that don't say any single offensive thing, are getting banned. Also I believe that permabans are bringing worse fame to League. In my opinion, knowing that permabans exist, they make league players even more toxic even those who didn't get any single suspension because they afraid of it.They also hurt bussiness. It makes them feeling unsecured because they might get one while they put all their efforts to improve their accounts collection or giving money and after that, they might stop spending money. For me personally, 1-month suspension after a 2-week suspension instead of a permaban would work just fine.

(Edit: The purpose of this topic is not meant say "toxicity and negative abuse is a good thing", I was just considered some negative stuffs of being permabanned that may hurt the game, not to encourage toxicity or negative abuse, and i wanted to read your thoughts on that)

36 Comments

Imperial Pandaa5 votes

You aren't likely to get a perma for one verbal slip up in one single instance; exception possibly pre-30 if they have labeled you a smurf.

To get perma'd for verbal means you most likely worked through the punishment tiers: 10 game CR 25 Game CR 14 day ban Perm. It is possible to skip the Chat Restrictions if you use Zero Tolerance though, which includes slurs.

You do demonstarte thay you can drop punishment tiers by having neutral behavior or better though.

Hokuto No Shen1 votes

If I remember correctly, before my second 2-week suspension, I had received no chat restrictions and that's one of the many reasons why my second suspension was feeling kinda dumb. In general, I don't know what happened to chat restrictions.

MordridtheBlack1 votes

that can happen, depending on what you were reported for

Riot has full control over what punishment you receive if/when you get reported

I think I've seen people go form never punished before to permabanned (I could be wrong)

but yeah, they can/will skip punishment tiers if need be

DuskDaUmbreon3 votes

People only skip 14 day bans for a few special cases - Chargebacks, scripting, and account sharing are the only three that come to mind right now.

You can only skip to 14 day for inting and using zero-tolerance phrases, neither of which there is any excuse for.

Kei1432 votes

When you use zero tolerance phrases, it skips punishment tiers. After that, you have to play alot of games and show the system that you have reformed in order to drop punishment tiers, leaving the account as is and not doing anything with it does not drop punishment tiers.

I'm assuming the first punishment you got you used zero tolerance phrases and skipped all the chat restrictions. I'm also assuming that you took some time off and didn't play as much since your 14 day ban. So while you dropped one punishment tier, it wasn't enough to drop you down to a clean state, which is why you got 14-day banned again when you got punished.

Does my hypothesis fit with your reality?

Jamaree5 votes

[{quoted}](name=Hokuto No Shen,realm=EUNE,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=vEOrEyJe,comment-id=,timestamp=2019-05-27T09:52:18.837+0000)

Don't you guys think that permabanning people is a bit too much? I mean, I have seen people saying even worse, for example people that say "homophobic slurs" ,are not gettinf banned, but people that don't say any single offensive thing, are getting banned.

I would like you to show me even a single case of this being true.

Also I believe that permabans are bringing worse fame to League. In my opinion, knowing that permabans exist, they make league players even more toxic even those who didn't get any single suspension because they afraid of it.

I don't understand the logic here. How does knowing your account is going to be gone forever if you continue your attitude make you more toxic?

They also hurt bussiness.

So does having players who go out of their way to belittle and treat their allies like shit no matter the circumstance.

It makes them feeling unsecured because they might get one while they put all their efforts to improve their accounts collection or giving money and after that, they might stop spending money.

They don't care about you spending money at that point, they just want you gone.

For me personally, 1-month suspension after a 2-week suspension instead of a permaban would work just fine.

That's you, that isn't everyone, the system used to be far more leninent and be far harder to get a permaban, having to rack up constant 14 day bans to finally get a permaban and an overwhelming majority of those player just kept coming back and continuing to be toxic.

LetMeAfkPlss1 votes

tbh bans make me just angrier cause there's still a shit head in the loose that caused me to get banned and got away scott free so yeah i understand why people come back even more toxic after their bans

Jamaree1 votes

{quoted}

tbh bans make me just angrier cause there's still a shit head in the loose that caused me to get banned and got away scott free so yeah i understand why people come back even more toxic after their bans

Ever think you deserve the punishment and they don’t maybe?

Sona Ping1 votes

{quoted}

I would like you to show me even a single case of this being true.

Now you know that is not fair. You know that nobody is allowed to show you a case of it being true. "naming and shaming" and all that

Jamaree1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Sona Ping,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=vEOrEyJe,comment-id=00010001,timestamp=2019-05-29T11:32:24.135+0000)

Now you know that is not fair. You know that nobody is allowed to show you a case of it being true. "naming and shaming" and all that

Bullshit, literally show me a single case on these forums then.

Sona Ping1 votes

I can't. You know that. I can't show you a game with an Anivia who spent the entire match trying to wall people into the enemy team who didn't get banned. It's against forum rules to show you how they are still playing even with a support ticket assuring me they will "personally look into it". Same with the games of people selling all their items to buy MS items with Mobis to run it down faster.

Jamaree1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Sona Ping,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=vEOrEyJe,comment-id=0001000100000000,timestamp=2019-05-29T11:46:31.709+0000)

I can't. You know that. I can't show you a game with an Anivia who spent the entire match trying to wall people into the enemy team who didn't get banned. It's against forum rules to show you how they are still playing even with a support ticket assuring me they will "personally look into it". Same with the games of people selling all their items to buy MS items with Mobis to run it down faster.

Blur out names, link game in question.

Also, I’m not saying trolls don’t exist or people don’t get punished for your reports, my point was op saying he has seen people say racist or homophobic zero tolerance words and not get punished and isn’t even willing to provide even the basis of any proof of such.

Sona Ping1 votes

{quoted}

Blur out names, link game in question.

I can go get a screenshot of an Anivia wall if you want but that wouldn't do anything.
I can't link the game, that would be identifying, and violating the rules. If I blur out the identifying information, so it wouldn't, you can't confirm that Riot didn't do anything. And I don't feel like getting another warning from a moderator who didn't read the thread.

Also, I’m not saying trolls don’t exist or people don’t get punished for your reports, my point was op saying he has seen people say racist or homophobic zero tolerance words and not get punished and isn’t even willing to provide even the basis of any proof of such.

He can't even do what you are asking. That's the point. No one can. It's not allowed; that's why it's not fair to say that.

Jamaree1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Sona Ping,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=vEOrEyJe,comment-id=000100010000000000000000,timestamp=2019-05-29T11:59:06.830+0000)

I can go get a screenshot of an Anivia wall if you want but that wouldn't do anything.
I can't link the game, that would be identifying, and violating the rules. If I blur out the identifying information, so it wouldn't, you can't confirm that Riot didn't do anything. And I don't feel like getting another warning from a moderator who didn't read the thread.

He can't even do what you are asking. That's the point. No one can. It's not allowed; that's why it's not fair to say that.

So I should just baselessly believe that he is telling the truth then?

Sona Ping1 votes

{quoted}

So I should just baselessly believe that he is telling the truth then?

Yeah, to a degree more or less. You give them the Benefit of the Doubt. So often what there is, is only people's word on the matter so you give them that benefit and accept what they are saying, and think that reason they said what they said is because they meant it and not assume they are trying to be dishonest. That's not the same as taking it as complete 100% fact with no further consideration on the matter, but that's different from assuming they are "Bullshitting" you.

Rest of the thread aside, and my issues with what else he wrote let's look at that part. I can understand that he believes that some people get punished while others who have done worse do not. He said that's what he thinks, so why shouldn't we believe him on that being what he thinks? He said it. It's not as if there's no reason for him to start to think that, I've seen how frequently players who are indisputably breaking the rules are reported to Riot and Riot does nothing about it.

ModThe Djinn1 votes

{quoted}Blur out names, link game in question.

Not okay. If you're linking to a game specifically to shame another player then you're still providing that information, just in a much more roundabout way. "Hey guys, go look at that awful Anivia in my last game" isn't cool.

Imperial Pandaa1 votes

If it is already a case on the forums, then the OP of the posts Jamaree wants would be linkable in theory since they are "public" at that point. The biggest issue is finding the type of evidence needed as people don't typically go "lolololol I used ZT and didn't get punished."

OP specifically mentions verbal cases aren't being punished. At least at the part Jamaree is asking for proof.

Myrmiron4 votes

I have never been even chat restricted, however I feel the same. IMO permanent bans should be reserved for cheaters and actually illegal speech like threatening someone harm or something, not mere toxicity. That being said, it's Riot's game and they want to keep it as friendly as possible, and I kind of agree with that mentality in principle since arguing in chat will only ever lead to everyone involved playing worse, and I want people that concentrate on playing instead of chatting. (Which is why I also want an opt-in voice chat in league)

MordridtheBlack4 votes

Riot used to have indeffinately scaling punishments (perm bans still exists but were a complete last resort; they wanted people to play)

but sadly those said people found ways around their punishments to continue doing what thy were doing, so Riot yeeted the old system and gave us this new one

you get 1-4 chances to make sure you don't get permaed

and they warn you after the 14 day suspension "Hey; you goofed up. We're watching. Continue this, and you get the boot and shown the door."

they have found that this works far better, as the majority of people who get perm banned do not return to league, only a minority do return

Hokuto No Shen1 votes

About those 1-4 chances , what to do mean with this, and by that do you mean "1-4 2-week suspensions and then you get a permaban" or "1-4 chances during 6 months after a 2-week suspension"?

MordridtheBlack1 votes

no; I mean literally 1-4 chances

10 game chat restriction 25 game chat restriction 14 Day ban. Permanent ban.

since something you do/say can escalate you past previous tiers (even if you have a clean record)

and it roughly takes (according to one poster) at least 300 matches on good behavior (no being reported repeatedly for bad stuff) to de-escalate to a lower punishment tier

Hokuto No Shen1 votes

Oke, thanks

MordridtheBlack1 votes

no problem; and that match estimate isn't 100% confirmed

it was a rough calculation done by a player (which I think a specialist said wasn't entirely right, but the math looked good for what it was...or something along those lines)

GatekeeperTDS2 votes

Riot has said multiple times they're not interested in finding ways for extremely toxic people to keep playing - they want them to stop playing. Follow the rules and keep your account. It really is that goddamn simple.

CharDeeMcDenniz2 votes

[{quoted}](name=Hokuto No Shen,realm=EUNE,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=vEOrEyJe,comment-id=,timestamp=2019-05-27T09:52:18.837+0000) but people that don't say any single offensive thing, are getting banned.

citation needed plz

Hokuto No Shen1 votes

I have seen some people getting banned for extremely hight chat activity, yet there were no toxic activity (and by that I don't mean spamming)

CharDeeMcDenniz3 votes

i saw an alien once, trust me, i swear.

that must be proof they exist

Imperial Pandaa3 votes

The chat logs from that OP definitely weren't positive. Parts were less than neutral. Which means there were negative in chat aka toxic.

CharDeeMcDenniz3 votes

so about that thread you are linking, did you read it?

  • the OP admits to having recently received a 14 day suspension
  • when you get a 14 day suspension it says clearly on that "ANY NEGATIVE BEHAVIOR WILL RESULT IN A PERMA BAN"
  • the OP then uses lines like,

Nice Try: teemo speed inting now Nice Try: starts lane with 2 kills Nice Try: dies 3 times Nice Try: games over

Nice Try: make sure everyone reports teemo Nice Try: end Nice Try: im not Nice Try: waiting for you to end the game teemo threw Nice Try: gg Nice Try: end please

Nice Try: stop talking veig Nice Try: not ganking a trash veig sorry

and on and on....

your example proves nothing except a toxic player got warned, ignored the warning, and was rightfully punished

Hokuto No Shen1 votes

Maybe, but I see this more in my games than toxicity. Yet I report any negative and toxic abuse, and I don't feel that something happens. I don't know.

letsfeedtogether1 votes

you need to get punsihed 4 times or 2 or you do something like inting that is 14 days ban first offence.

4 times and or inting and being toxic 2 times is alot and should be reworded with a perma.

Xurreal1 votes

No. 2 words. Fresh account.

I got banned a few uears ago on another account. I started a new smurf and this is now my main. the new smurf has too few champs on it but its easier to climb for some reason.

gabetheguy1 votes

no.

More from Player Behavior

More by Hokuto No Shen