Skip to content

Let's talk about "toxicity"

Sintaur··6 votes·1,071 views

Hi,

I'm a competitive person who takes everything he does seriously. I'm also considered to be a pretty intelligent person, and I'm currently finishing a Ph.D. at one of the most prestigious programs in my field. I'm not stating that to give myself any sort of credentials. However, use of foul language has been showing to correlate with a larger vocabulary and general intelligence:

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S038800011400151X

http://www.sciencealert.com/people-who-curse-a-lot-have-better-vocabularies-than-those-who-don-t-study-finds

I'd like to start a discussion about what is true toxicity in League of Legends. I've been banned a few times for toxicity, and that toxicity specifically refers to flaming teammates when we are losing and they continually make poor decisions that exacerbate our situation (usually by doing the same thing over and over). Yes, I cuss, and yes, I get genuinely angry. Yes, I've called other players trash (fairly or not). I've just started to think about the nature of these situations and, while foul-mouthed, whether I'm actually toxic.

I pretty much only play ranked, and I play ranked because I want to do my best and play in a competitive environment. I play normals occasionally in order to just goof off or to practice a new champ. For me, the real world equivalent would be playing in a competitive soccer league, whether professionally or not (ranked) vs. playing pick-up soccer with randoms/friends (normals). I've played competitive sports throughout my life, and when the heat is on, I can't really think of any time there hasn't been flaming of some sort. It happens. It's in the heat of the moment. It's born out of frustration, and it's a method of venting, so that the game can go on. Obviously, some people respond more or less poorly than others.

Does this make flaming okay? I don't know. Probably not. But, the ethos of playing ranked is that you are playing to compete with other people of like mind. I believe that there should be an expectation and acceptance of a certain level of expressive language. I will say, however, that with a physical-world sports team, you play with the same people, and there's a level of trust and understanding that what is said isn't deeply meant. And this brings me to a sort of realization of this issue of "toxicity."

In real-world scenarios, you have a pretty good understanding of your skill level, the skill levels of your teammates, and maybe even the skill levels of your opponents. This allows you to set your expectations for how well or poorly you expect to do. Often, the highest levels of flaming occur when those expectations are not met. In League of Legends, this expectation is supposedly set by your playing with other people near your MMR. However, there is a HUGE variance in true skill/ability among players of the same MMR, which leads to unmet expectations, which leads to "toxicity" a la flaming. I would posit that the toxic environment is actually created by the failure of the ladder system to match players/teams of near equal true skill. Yes, I am putting this back on Riot. I don't think someone being genuinely and rightfully (imo) angry and expressing that is toxic. I think an environment where people are so mismatched but believe they're equally as skilled breeds toxicity and could be considered toxicity itself.

Of course, there are people who are just plain jerks, who are not good, and who just want to provoke, anger, and cause pain. That's toxic and should be addressed. However, I'm not that person. I will gladly post my chat logs and let the readers decide, too. And obviously, there are all kinds of other toxic behaviors, such as trolling, feeding, afking, etc. I have never done a single one of those things. Despite my "salty" attitude sometimes, I've always tried, even if I've said "I'm done" (which I usually say as a last-ditch chance to motivate my team to change they way they're playing, and which often actually seems to have a positive effect, oddly enough).

I want to hear others' thoughts, though. I do hold Riot responsible to a high degree for creating environments that breed/foster toxic behavior. I believe the automated restriction/ban system (which I'm pretty sure accounts for at least 90% of their bans, and probably at least 90% of those bans are due to flaming/foul language, but I'd love to see data) is a band-aid and a way to say "Look at how good we're doing to stop toxicity!" and ultimately doesn't address or help correct the underlying issues.

TL;DR Ha, yeah right. Go read this. You can't make a reasoned response based off of a one-sentence summary.

30 Comments

UnwardiI5 votes

This is my situation exactly, though you put it more eloquently and reasonably than I generally do.

I would like wise love to see ANY data about what their system actually does. How, for instance, can their system tell the difference between an intentional feeder running down mid and a shut down tank who gets killed in successive mid game aram engagements without being able to get off any spells because they are doing their job, standing in the front and eating skill shots? Their post game data will look IDENTICAL, the difference is intent. All it takes is someone to report them for feeding and they will be punished when they did nothing wrong. Accusation=Guilt. Good 3rd century morals there Rito.

Likewise, someone spamming the chat, yelling at their team mates about things WHILE DEAD is vastly different to them doing so while standing afk in the middle of a team fight. GET BARON! GET FUCKING BARON! BARON NOW YOU FUCKING PRICKS! Is not, in my opinion, a toxic thing to say. First off, if you only say it the once, it is entirely probably that half your team simply wont see the message pop up, and if you don't use firm language, they are far less likely to actually listen to you, however, if you then go on to lose the game, you end up making yourself a scape goat. They all report you for being "toxic" and this somehow absolves them of any personal failure.

Unlike you though, I'm far beyond being civil or reasonable about any of this. It's bullshit, plain and simple, and I now make it my mission to get as many people wrongly banned as possible.

Sintaur4 votes

{quoted}

This is my situation exactly, though you put it more eloquently and reasonably than I generally do.

I would like wise love to see ANY data about what their system actually does. How, for instance, can their system tell the difference between an intentional feeder running down mid and a shut down tank who gets killed in successive mid game aram engagements without being able to get off any spells because they are doing their job, standing in the front and eating skill shots? Their post game data will look IDENTICAL, the difference is intent. All it takes is someone to report them for feeding and they will be punished when they did nothing wrong. Accusation=Guilt. Good 3rd century morals there Rito.

Likewise, someone spamming the chat, yelling at their team mates about things WHILE DEAD is vastly different to them doing so while standing afk in the middle of a team fight. GET BARON! GET FUCKING BARON! BARON NOW YOU FUCKING PRICKS! Is not, in my opinion, a toxic thing to say. First off, if you only say it the once, it is entirely probably that half your team simply wont see the message pop up, and if you don't use firm language, they are far less likely to actually listen to you, however, if you then go on to lose the game, you end up making yourself a scape goat. They all report you for being "toxic" and this somehow absolves them of any personal failure.

Unlike you though, I'm far beyond being civil or reasonable about any of this. It's bullshit, plain and simple, and I now make it my mission to get as many people wrongly banned as possible.

Yeah, exactly. I really agree with the part about finding a scapegoat. If you were the squeakiest wheel, your team puts all the responsibility on you and your language, report you, and they feel good about themselves because they "got something" out of the game. The reality of the situation has little bearing, here. And yes, one person's play/attitude doesn't make it okay to be likewise nasty, but I feel like the automated system is abused and busted at this point, and I may just have to walk away from it all.

UnwardiI5 votes

Well, Dynamic Queue is what will do it for me, but I'll give them till the end of the year to get it sorted or I'm walking. In the mean time though, there's plenty of catharsis to be had.

Proxiimus3 votes

LOL.. 'BARON NOW YOU FUCKING PRICKS! Is not, in my opinion, a toxic thing to say'.. Me, as a fellow league player, would not mind seeing you gone. If you can't see the toxicity in that.. you obviously have issues that Riot is justified in booting you off their game for good.

Sintaur5 votes

{quoted}

LOL.. 'BARON NOW YOU FUCKING PRICKS! Is not, in my opinion, a toxic thing to say'.. Me, as a fellow league player, would not mind seeing you gone. If you can't see the toxicity in that.. you obviously have issues that Riot is justified in booting you off their game for good.

His point, and mine, is that people come from widely varied cultural backgrounds and levels of acceptance of language. I go further to suggest that those who are used to highly competitive environments are more comfortable using and receiving that sort of language, not taking it too seriously. My question is does that make a person actually toxic? Is that actually toxic to say? To me, it's not at all. It's someone playing his/her heart out and being passionate.

Furthermore, I actually find your flat-out declaration that "If you can't see the toxicity in that.. you obviously have issues that Riot is justified in booting you off their game for good" to be toxic. You don't bother to explain what you find toxic about the person's statement. You assume that because you have the opinion that it's toxic it automatically is, and you come off as condescending and incendiary. Telling someone you don't know that they obviously have issue is derogatory and toxic in it's own right, but it is much harder to identify automatically.

If you want to respond reasonably and contribute to this discussion in a thoughtful way, I would love to dialogue with you some more.

Dankstin3 votes

The catharsis of flaming sometimes has black hole-level gravity, and you just have to say something mean. I think it's just human nature to want to say something. You can mean it or not, but typing the thought out is just so liberating. Does the player know they're having bad game? Of course they do. They're the one messing up so badly it warrants mention from a teammate. Do we need remind them of this failure? No, we really don't, but being "offended" by some words doesn't effect your mmr the same way a player who is offended is ruining your game with their paltry skills. In a ranked setting, it isn't fair for people to play badly by making extremely stupid decisions. They, as per ethos of ranked, were supposed to enter queue with in mind their absolute best performance. Experimental itemization, ignoring your team losing team fights being forced upon them due to you being the most damaging player on the team while you're split pushing... like don't be acting like you're the victim when you're the one physically nailing yourself to the cross.

Proxiimus2 votes

Not to mention.. If you want your team to do baron.. all you do is have to type 'BARON' and spam ping assistance on Baron.. usually works 90% of the time.

Amasa Delano2 votes

I don't understand why anything more than this would be necessary. I'm not more likely to do Baron if someone says "DO BARON FUCKING PRICKS" than if someone says "BARON" and pings it.

Sintaur1 votes

See the above comment for context. :)

Amasa Delano2 votes

Yours is a very interesting thought.

You mention that flaming happens typically when expectations are not met. I never flame at my teammates, and I would say, based on your paradigm here, that that's probably because I go into every game with no expectations. I hope to win, and I do the absolute best I can do, but I hold no expectations about what anyone else is going to do. I've done the same thing on physical sports teams in the past as well, with the exception that perhaps I had some slight expectations about what my teammates could do, based mostly on their past performances and how on the ball they were during warm ups.

What would be the negative implications (if any) of lowering expectations going into games? Play your best, yes, help your team, yes, all the other things that make games be won, but just don't have expectations about how your teammates or opponents will play. If your teammates are as good as you, great! If not, expectations are not unmet, so flaming doesn't need to happen (although teaching opportunities are still there).

Are there any downsides to playing this way that I am not thinking of? I would genuinely love to know. Thank you!

Sintaur2 votes

I'd say that's definitely a solution to that treats the symptoms without really addressing the environment. You're right the games I play where I have little to no expectation of my teammates, I don't get riled up.

If I'm being honest, however, I probably am not trying my hardest in those games. It's hard to fully invest my mental/emotional energy into a situation where I don't expect the same from others. It probably causes me to play a little more passively until I can see whether my team is up to the task. I don't think this is good, either.

So, outright, no, I don't think there are any explicit negatives to lowered expectations. I would suggest that it alters a person's playstyle and ability, though, even if they tell themselves they're "trying their best."

What do you think? Thanks for your thoughts and insights and contribution to this discussion.

Amasa Delano1 votes

I understand not being able to fully invest your energy into a situation without expecting the same from others. That really is the main negative that you've pointed out, that it "alters a person's playstyle" to go in without expectations.

One of the reasons I prefer to make the tradeoff is because I believe that people generally respond better to encouragement than to insults. So, if I want to win, I believe I have a greater chance of doing so if I encourage my teammates rather than flame at them when they do poorly. I've found this to be the case in physical sports as well as in team video games, although it's much more pronounced in physical sports since you can see the emotional effect that flaming has on your teammates much more easily.

I grant that there may be people who respond better to insults than to encouragement (you may even be one of them! who knows!). But I think that, generally, encouraging someone who responds better to insults is probably not nearly as detrimental to their performance as insulting someone who responds better to encouragement. So, to be safe, I try and encourage in all of my games.

Thank you also! Your initial post was clear and well-thought-out, which was why I responded.

scazzman2 votes

[{quoted}](name=Amasa Delano,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=nNwYgd0X,comment-id=0004,timestamp=2016-06-29T17:55:02.355+0000)

Yours is a very interesting thought.

You mention that flaming happens typically when expectations are not met. I never flame at my teammates, and I would say, based on your paradigm here, that that's probably because I go into every game with no expectations. I hope to win, and I do the absolute best I can do, but I hold no expectations about what anyone else is going to do. I've done the same thing on physical sports teams in the past as well, with the exception that perhaps I had some slight expectations about what my teammates could do, based mostly on their past performances and how on the ball they were during warm ups.

What would be the negative implications (if any) of lowering expectations going into games? Play your best, yes, help your team, yes, all the other things that make games be won, but just don't have expectations about how your teammates or opponents will play. If your teammates are as good as you, great! If not, expectations are not unmet, so flaming doesn't need to happen (although teaching opportunities are still there).

Are there any downsides to playing this way that I am not thinking of? I would genuinely love to know. Thank you!

also. keep in mind too. if you play a sport. there is usually a coach in the game calling plays, so even if people have different ideas on how the game should go. they won't argue with each other over it. in league. unless you're in a premade with a designated leader. it's a free for all. and people will ignore you for the sole purpose of ignoring you

Amasa Delano2 votes

You're right, it is very different for certain sports, because of the playcalling aspect. However, not everyone who plays League ignores their teammates, although the ones who do are extra annoying and probably stand out in my memory stronger than the ones who listen. Some players do listen to pings, baron calls, etc.

Sintaur2 votes

You still see people, especially in football, soccer, and basketball, calling out/cussing out their teammates in the heat of the moment. (Good) Coaches (imo) allow a certain level of autonomy for the players to sort things out among themselves.

Also, I think you hit upon another key point, which ultimately supports my assertions: while there are players who do know good calls and respond to them (let's call them team players and even good), there are an amazingly high number of players who will just ignore you (bad players but sometimes still in your MMR range) and/or intentionally troll you about it. There are also a number of players in the middle who sometimes need to be harassed into doing one action over another.

Amasa Delano2 votes

In my experience, even though there are players who cuss out their teammates in physical sports and coaches who allow it (to a certain level), in games where team coordination is necessary, having a teammate who cusses out my other teammates often hurts rather than improves the team's performance. I'm not trying to say anything about whether or not it should be allowed, just that, in my experience, insults or swearing do more to make teams play worse than to make them play better, by breaking team cohesion and demoralizing other players.

The point I was trying to make here was that, regardless of how high the number of players who just ignore you is, they will always be more memorable than the players who were good teammates, listened to pings, and tried to play as a team. I would even add that team players don't stand out in memory regardless of how good or bad they are individually, since League is a team game, and working as a team is a very important element to the game.

Does this seem right to you? That you remember teammates who were unresponsive much more than teammates who were responsive?

scazzman1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Amasa Delano,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=nNwYgd0X,comment-id=00040001000000000000,timestamp=2016-06-29T20:32:43.692+0000)

In my experience, even though there are players who cuss out their teammates in physical sports and coaches who allow it (to a certain level), in games where team coordination is necessary, having a teammate who cusses out my other teammates often hurts rather than hinders the team's performance. I'm not trying to say anything about whether or not it should be allowed, just that, in my experience, insults or swearing do more to make teams play worse than to make them play better, by breaking team cohesion and demoralizing other players.

The point I was trying to make here was that, regardless of how high the number of players who just ignore you is, they will always be more memorable than the players who were good teammates, listened to pings, and tried to play as a team. I would even add that team players don't stand out in memory regardless of how good or bad they are individually, since League is a team game, and working as a team is a very important element to the game.

Does this seem right to you? That you remember teammates who were unresponsive much more than teammates who were responsive?

however. in a league match. there is no defined "coach" which leads to players often trying to coach each other. which eventually leads to "too many chiefs, not enough indians"

Amasa Delano1 votes

That can definitely be the case. When that happens, I typically try to back off directing and follow someone else, since working together as a team is usually more important in that case than who has the better idea.

Sintaur3 votes

Because it seems so rare, I actually tend to remember those who were good/positive team players more than anything else. However, you're right that in the context of a game, the negative ones stick out at the end.

It seems that there has been a shift that occurred through my generation and into the newest one, and a distinctly American mindset, towards what someone has to say meaning less than how something is said. I find that most people get wrapped up in how someone says something, and if it's packaged the right way, they like it, even if it's nonsense.

This is an issue from politics to scholarly papers, and it is most clearly exemplified in this article:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2014/02/27/how_nonsense_papers_ended_up_in_respected_scientific_journals.html

In the context of League of Legends, it's much easier to point to someone who uses abrasive language and call them toxic and the reason for the negative environment, regardless of whether they're good players and are saying true things, than it is to actually pinpoint negative/toxic playing by those who are passive-aggressive or refusing to communicate/cooperate with the team. It gets towards the complaint that we teach kids today that everyone's a winner, but that's getting off-topic a bit.

In some ways, I'm saying people should have a bit thicker skin and not get so ruffled at abrasive language. However, I know that people come from different backgrounds and have different levels of sensitivity to that sort of thing. What's missing in most games is two-way respect in regards to this point, and the big problem is that punishments are only really able to be given out for toxicity on one side (at least, automatically).

GULAG 4 U1 votes

Well first of all the only constant factor in this game is you so the best way to play this game is to expect that your teammates will be a bunch of useless bots.

_(--)__/

Sintaur1 votes

I think that's a toxic attitude, though. I also think it's disrespectful to your teammates. I believe that MMR should signify true ability, and I believe we have the right to expect our teammates to play near our own skill level. Otherwise, why a ladder system at all?

GULAG 4 U1 votes

Not saying you should flame or tell them they're bad, but to not expect them to do much.

Rumpletumskin1 votes

I need to ask, have you ever played any other pvp based online game? Riot certainly does not foster toxicity, even before the automated system was put in place. Most of the intel the automated system uses was gathered from real players via the old tribunal, hence why simple things like "gg ez" became ban worthy, the community felt it toxic.

I'd like to know how this is simply a band-aid, while other companies don't do half as much for "bad players" other than ban hackers (which in my opinion, riot could be doing better with - see 3v3 bots).

I also loved how you flat out contradicted yourself, you have been banned for toxicity. You sit there and accuse others of trying to provoke bad gameplay patterns, meanwhile admit to doing it yourself... You are, in fact, a "plain jerk" as you call them.

I'm also sick of people make crappy real life analogies, this is a virtual playground. You may as well cite freedom of speech, even though it has no basis here. When you are playing ranked, guess what? You are NOT playing professional soccer, you're playing a video game. You are basically saying "I should only get a 5 minute penalty for assaulting another player, because he instigated it". No.

You are playing Riots game, you abide by their rules. Simple, no?

BigNasty30002 votes

This is the typical board post. Defending ridiculous rules (gg ez banworthy, c'mon son), and then pulling the same card they always do; the "Riot's game, Riot's rules" argument.

We are Riot's customers. If Riot's rules are bad, we will leave. When they start losing money, you'll see them make some drastic changes. So, who really "owns" the game, Riot or the players?

Then there is the other go-to argument for these minions; the "this game isn't comparable to any other competitive game/sport." Why isn't it comparable to soccer? Not pro soccer, but a pick up game at the park? Why isn't it comparable to basketball at the park?

I bet you have no answers for these questions, as you are just regurgitating the same bile you see spewed across these boards everyday.

Rumpletumskin1 votes

I'm not regurgitating a single word. I read the TOS and I abide by their rules.Is that seriously a hard concept? I'm far from a riot fanboy, nor do i agree with their policies. IT IS WHAT IT IS though, crying doesn't change it, riots games, riots rules. I could make a game tomorrow and claim you have to say the n word every 5 days at least 1x per day, and that's how it works.

It is FAR from a "go-to" argument, I simply know how to read.

As for your baseless "what ifs" I couldn't care less if riot choked off their own mistake, it provides them a valuable learning experience.

BigNasty30001 votes

I asked you questions, and you dismissed them instead of addressing them. "It is what it is" is the dumbest statement in the english language, made even more dumb by all-caps. "Crying?" Devaluing complaints by referring to them as "crying" is definitely bad business, and something I can't imagine Riot would do. Google Amy's baking company if you want to see an example of a business acting this way.

Make your game, and see what happens. Truth is, if Riot wants a successful game, they have to listen to their customers. That's the way it is.

You can't even abide by the simple rule of putting two spaces after a period. That seems pretty fucking simple to me.

Sintaur1 votes

I'd love for you to point out where I contradicted myself. I've never tried to provoke someone so that I could report them.

I'm saying that the environment wherein players of the same supposed skill level compete breeds toxicity, because the true skill level of those players has such a wide variance that expectations are unmet.

I never compared it to professional anything. I compared it to similar competitive endeavors. And the "virtual playground" argument really doesn't hold, as the only real difference is that you're using your mind/fingers to play instead of your whole body. Yes, Riot can make whatever rules they want, but that doesn't mean we can't have a discussion and try to shape the culture.

Rumpletumskin1 votes

I don't even... Well sir, let us chastise the NHL, NFL, and the MLS! I believe I already did point out your contradictory remarks. If perhaps you want flat out examples, so be it.

"I've been banned a few times for toxicity, and that toxicity specifically refers to flaming teammates when we are losing and they continually make poor decisions " -- " there are people who are just plain jerks, who are not good, and who just want to provoke, anger, and cause pain. That's toxic and should be addressed."

To point out the things i find bluntly obvious, people did not perform to your standards, so you ridiculed them. You went on to say that you do not like that type of person. Which is it?

^ do i seriously need to say another word?

*i am not native to english forgive me

Sintaur1 votes

I don't find those to be contradictory.

There's a difference (in my mind) between an outburst of anger towards players who are supposedly at the same skill level as you but who play like they're not and someone who's entire intent is to make a game miserable for other players. Those two sentences refer to the two different types of persons.

Because English isn't your native language, I understand how the nuance of that may be lost. You may want to take an approach to conversation more like Asian cultures do, where you assume the person knows what they're saying and the onus of responsibility to understand falls on the reader/listener. That way, you can ask questions and not come off as a jerk.

Finally, the forums are here for discussion of things about the game. Riot has been swayed by arguments and conversations in the past, and changes to the game have been made as a result. I see no problem with discussing this issue. You are free to participate or not.

scazzman1 votes

{quoted}

I'd like to know how this is simply a band-aid, while other companies don't do half as much for "bad players" other than ban hackers (which in my opinion, riot could be doing better with - see 3v3 bots).

i find it ironic how league of legends is the only game that has such a large amount of toxicity. yet they are the ONLY game that i know of that will actually permaban you based off of words

More from Player Behavior

More by Sintaur