Criticism is a double-edged sword

Monlyth·3/25/2019, 10:13:33 PM·12 votes·9,444 views

Just a general reminder for you all. Criticizing people is risky business. Not just in-game, but in real life as well; that's besides the point, though.

Let's say someone makes a misplay. Maybe they missed a skillshot that lets someone get away, maybe they gave up first blood, maybe they flashed unnecessarily, maybe they reacted a little too slowly to a gank from the allied jungler. You point out this error to them, saying something like "Why would you overextend?"

Now, which is more likely: that they will accept the criticism and their play will immediately improve as a result of your criticism, or that they will feel personally attacked by your criticism and go on tilt?

In my experience, the latter is far more likely. It's just how people work psychologically. For most people, criticism hurts their own sense of self-esteem, and thus anger is the first instinctive response to being criticized. It often requires a lot of patience and discipline to control that anger. And a lot of people, when playing League, don't have the patience or discipline to control their anger, because they're playing for fun and don't want to put in the effort to control themselves after a long day of work.

So for those with a teammate who makes a mistake, my advice is this:

  1. Always think carefully before you criticize someone, for any reason. Is it really worth the risk of starting an argument or tilting them?

  2. If you must criticize someone, be as polite as possible. Don't spam pings, don't use insults, and be forgiving. Remind yourself that everyone makes misplays, even pros.

Thanks for listening.

46 Comments

TheUrbanKitsune3/25/2019, 10:19:59 PM6 votes

A little bit of kindness really does go a long way, and people are usually more willing to listen if you just act like a decent human being.

R107 Games3/25/2019, 10:44:58 PM2 votes

Criticism is not intended for the receiver to "feel good"; it is intended for the receiver to be informed of their mistakes.

It's no one's fault when the receiver perceives the criticism as an "insult" or something of the like

Salty Mc Feed3/29/2019, 3:23:13 PM2 votes

Banning people with zero tolerance because they criticize is also a double edged sword and probably even worse, because you are supporting narcissism, ignorance and psychopathic behavior.

If you look at history and nations that were under an authoritarian regime with a lot of censorship you will find that the worst kind of narcissistic and abusive people always climb to power in such an environment. People that act nice but then backstab you if you step out of line.

I guess people want this for League of Legends too.

An environment where everybody acts nice on the outside but actually lost all respect for fellow players, where nobody dares to give an honest opinion because they are afraid to get backstabbed.

GG comrades

Schoenberg3/27/2019, 4:33:40 PM2 votes

3 Word the criticism differently.

“Why would you overextend” reads as somewhat aggressive since you’re asking them to explain their mistake... They. Need. To. Explain. Themselves. Instead, try something like, “next time don’t overextend :d.”

Bonus points for putting in the face and maybe a please

Extra bonus points for pointing out your own mistakes to lessen tension.

Extra extra bonus points to the folks who dish out criticism and take “criticism” purely as criticism. Heads up, they usually don’t take it well.

Makarakarn3/28/2019, 7:32:44 PM2 votes

ANNOUNCEMENT: INSULTS AND PASSIVE AGGRESSIVE COMMENTS DO NOT EQUAL CRITICISM

WarmAndCrispy3/28/2019, 7:39:07 PM2 votes

yea if you remove the human ego from the equation, people would laugh off criticism, learn from it, and keep playing to win. Unfortunately the ego is inseparable from the human psyche because it was a necessity that aided in our survival in our ancestral environment. Long story short humans in general are a bunch of soft, squishy, whiny fucking babies, until they're lucky enough to have the right life experiences smack it out of them. Even then it's not fully gone.

The right choice is to say nothing. You'd think riot would be smart enough to just remove chat from the game, as it does more harm than good, or at least reserve it for high elo, but then they wouldn't have an excuse to rob you of everything you earned so you can buy it back on your new account! :) $$$$$$$

xDogMeatx3/26/2019, 1:08:54 AM1 votes

just say "its my bad sorry" i was mashing X point and click skill not using a skillshot ability.

EthreainAmbusher3/26/2019, 1:22:26 AM1 votes

_ARE YOU CRITICIZING PEOPLE WHO CRITICIZE? _

ChaosReyn3/25/2019, 10:40:56 PM1 votes

I think by far the biggest pain is holding one's tongue only to watch the person who misplayed immediately start saying it's another person's fault they got caught out. Maybe it's just my bias as a support main...but when that adc gets caught out and dies for the 3rd time in a row before you can clear that enemy pink ward, and then turns around and blames either you for no vision or your jungler for never ganking while he's getting camped...you sort of have to draw a line somewhere and say "dude...come on. You know the enemy jungler's there, and you know I can't safely clear that ward yet."