Skip to content

Is it wrong to open mid after an early afk?

MK Ultralord··2 votes·3,455 views

Just got a chat restriction due to being reported for telling the enemy team "open mid." Our midlaner Akali died first blood to a Singed; nobody said anything to her, but she instantly ragequit at level 3. My understanding is that this is the one circumstance where "open mid" is warranted, but I got flamed by my other 3 teammates for it. I didn't 100% give up; I still farmed/ganked/took objectives, and ended up taking their base and nexus with my top laner.

Is it really so wrong to open mid after losing a player due to ragequit (not DC) before 10 minutes? I don't understand why anyone would want to play a game like that, much less get upset at someone that doesn't want to play a game like that.

Edit: this was a normal draft game, not ranked

25 Comments

ModThe Djinn5 votes

Did everyone in the game on both teams agree that's okay? Feel free.

Is the above not 100% true? Don't do it.

R107 Games3 votes

You should ask for your team's consent first

Pika Fox3 votes

Open mid is intentionally throwing a game, and should never be allowed.

Pxerkza2 votes

opening is your teams choice when few individuals decide they want to keep you hostage as long as the majority of your team are fine with it there is no problem but if you are the only lane doing poorly and you open without your team wanting to do so you will be liable to a punishment

you can always dispute a ban/punishment with a support ticket

MK Ultralord2 votes

Not really trying to dispute it, just wanted a consensus on whether it was warranted. Looks like next time I'll ask my team if they want to keep trying.

rujitra5 votes

This is not true. It is not a majority vote. If one single person is against open mid, it is griefing to do so.

You agreed to play a full game when you queued up. You don't get to decide later you don't want to.

Pxerkza1 votes

what does surrendering do bro? it takes 4 people to surrender @20 it takes 2 people to surrender @3

if 4 people want to surrender @10 and the 0/6 dude is saying no HE IS THE ONE GRIEFING

thats why i said majority you ask for a open and if your team agrees you open im not gonna stay in a game for 20 minutes just because an inter wanted to keep me hostage

rujitra4 votes

When you open mid, you are not surrendering where everyone can move on to a new game. You are holding both other players on your team and on the enemy team hostage in a game that is unfun as you are not trying.

Riot has previously punished players for "open mid" when the entire team (and enemy) did not agree to it. It is not acceptable behavior to not try in a game, period. When you surrender, the game is over.

Furthermore, anyone can vote on a surrender how they want. Voting no on a surrender is not griefing. Period.

Pxerkza1 votes

it definitely is when the No vote comes from a guy that doesn't have the intention to win period.

there is a difference between losing your lane and opening your lane (this is purely afk and griefing) and asking for an open as your whole team is getting destroyed by obviously better players and you are playing a comp that can't afford to get stomped and then the majority of your team agreeing

the enemy team has no say if you open or not the decision is all on your team and as long as 4 people agree to it it's completely acceptable even if it's 10 min into the game Opening has been a part of the game for years and especially a systematic thing in korea don't come preaching that you have to play out a disaster of a game just because 1 dude is delusional

rujitra4 votes

It is not. If you do not have the intention to play out a game, don't queue up.

Pxerkza2 votes

so lets remove surrenders then and 3 min ffs since if you can't guarantee a stable connection and client don't queue up

and ban everyone that doesn't want to play out a 0/20 score game

wouldn't that be great

Midg3t1 votes

[deleted]

Pxerkza1 votes

i mean riot has been implementing snowball mechanics to reduce the longevity of sure losses riot has implemented the 15min surrender to reduce the amount of time players have to stay in sure losses

people have found a way to even further reduce the time required to stay in a sure loss and it just as much requires the majority to agree and this time it's somehow against the rules and griefing and trolling?

so if it's a player decision it's trolling if its riots decision it's fine

i don't know maybe he doesn't play the game indeed

Midg3t1 votes

{quoted}

i mean riot has been implementing snowball mechanics to reduce the longevity of sure losses riot has implemented the 15min surrender to reduce the amount of time players have to stay in sure losses

people have found a way to even further reduce the time required to stay in a sure loss and it just as much requires the majority to agree and this time it's somehow against the rules and griefing and trolling?

so if it's a player decision it's trolling if its riots decision it's fine

i don't know maybe he doesn't play the game indeed

Maybe he's an older player who just doesnt play anymore, cuz I had the same "never surrender" mentality.

But that was back in s7 when games were much slower and comebacks were very possible, depending on how good are you at playing defensively.

Times changed, once youre behind there is not much you can do. Even if youre fed, if half of your team is behind its prolly lost. (look at my game where I had Thresh top for example, top mid and jg are behind, me and adc were the only one who won our lane, but we couldnt hold enemies off post-laning phase.) In those situations I think it's the best to just accept the game is done and move on, otherwise you will just waste your mental energy. If more people realised that we wouldnt see so many tilted and/or toxic players.

Pxerkza1 votes

it was more rare for a team wide stomp to occur more often it was just 1 lane being insanely ahead and dictating the game until they throw

now you go into a game you are chilling top: your bot dies, your mid gets ganked, your bot dies again, your jungler gets invaded and killed by 3 people, your bot dies again all in 7 minutes, you are playing nasus into aatrox and you ask for open because there is no way in hell you can do anything anymore

every lane is lost you have 2 early game champions that don't scale you have no comeback options even if the enemy team penta ints into the fountain you would still not win this game

and somehow this is against the rules...

Midg3t1 votes

{quoted}

it was more rare for a team wide stomp to occur more often it was just 1 lane being insanely ahead and dictating the game until they throw

now you go into a game you are chilling top: your bot dies, your mid gets ganked, your bot dies again, your jungler gets invaded and killed by 3 people, your bot dies again all in 7 minutes, you are playing nasus into aatrox and you ask for open because there is no way in hell you can do anything anymore

every lane is lost you have 2 early game champions that don't scale you have no comeback options even if the enemy team penta ints into the fountain you would still not win this game

and somehow this is against the rules...

Well technically it IS against the rules...but just as all gameplay-related rules, they're flawed and/or can have exceptions and loopholes.

Remember Nubrac ban? How majority of players said he was trolling, but Nubrac was constantly falling back on ToS? That's because it wasnt technically against the rules by the ToS, but in the CONTEXT OF GAMEPLAY, it was trolling.

"Opening mid" has the similar problem. It is against the rules by the ToS, but in the CONTEXT OF GAMEPLAY, if all lanes are fucked and there is no (from objective standpoint) way to win, opening mid is simply accepting the reality and allowing the inevitable to happen. But ofc, as long as majority of players are ok with it.

Pxerkza1 votes

thats the argument the majority agreeing

at least in diamond people are well aware of when a game goes straight to the shitter and there is no way of comming back opens aren't common but when they happen they are fully justified

KVbqbFsC8e2 votes

You shouldn't announce it in all chat if none of your teammates are agreeing to open.

zPOOPz2 votes

I don't understand why anyone would want to play a game like that, much less get upset at someone that doesn't want to play a game like that.

People would want to play a game like that because of this

I still farmed/ganked/took objectives, and ended up taking their base and nexus with my top laner.


It is not wrong to open if all your teammates agree to it. Much like a surrender vote, if the majority of your team still want to play the game out, then by the rules, you have to play the game out. It seems like the rest of your team still wanted to play 4v5 so yes, it is wrong to open mid after an early afk.

As far your chat restriction, if you wish to discuss it, then you will need to post your full, unedited chat log of all games shown on your report card so we can discuss what else did you say on top of the "open mid" that warranted the chat restriction.

MK Ultralord1 votes

I don't care to dispute the chat restriction, but out of curiosity, where do I find the "report card" that lists the games that I violated ToS?

zPOOPz1 votes

I believe as long as you haven't cleared your 10/25 chat restricted games, it will pop up every time you finish a game while still under CR. You can also submit a support ticket to ask for it.

Zero Shingetsu1 votes

Personally, I've always found it in poor sport to open a lane. Even when you lose a man; there's always a chance to win. I've literally been part of a 3v5 win before. In particular, jungle is the best possible role to lose, because all your lanes are still covered. You're just missing ganks. Apparently the consensus is that there are times and ways to fairly open a lane, so maybe I'm in the wrong, but it's just my opinion.

Telephone Booth1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Zero Shingetsu,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=KsjoEG9y,comment-id=0005,timestamp=2019-07-14T20:58:42.708+0000)

Personally, I've always found it in poor sport to open a lane. Even when you lose a man; there's always a chance to win. I've literally been part of a 3v5 win before. In particular, jungle is the best possible role to lose, because all your lanes are still covered. You're just missing ganks. Apparently the consensus is that there are times and ways to fairly open a lane, so maybe I'm in the wrong, but it's just my opinion.

Its all anyone's opinion. Majority does not mean right or true.

Umbral Regent1 votes

I'm seeing a fair few comments saying that opening lanes is fine provided the whole team agrees, but I've seen plenty of people given 14-day bans for opening lanes, with no other in-match evidence of intentionally feeding or trolling. Even if your whole team agrees to open lanes, there's a whole 'nother team that hasn't agreed, and may not; the enemy team.

As far as I know, I haven't seen any Riot statements regarding opening lanes, but I feel it's safe to say that it isn't allowed.

Telephone Booth1 votes

Like wrong morally/philosophically? Or wrong according to the rules of the game? The former, noone can tell you. Its merely a matter of opinion, and there is no moral authority over you in this world. The latter, yes.

More from Player Behavior

More by MK Ultralord