Addition to Champ Select Idea [WARNING: Medium ammount of text][NOT direct champ selct report idea]
So I read a post a bit ago (http://boards.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/c/player-behavior-moderation/FAPuc40N-programmers-fix-your-broken-game-with-one-button) where the poster had an idea to combat being stuck with champ select trolls who where in your last lobby. While their idea was somewhat flawed, and had multiple openings for malicious players to abuse the system, at its core, it was a decent idea. I thought of some revisions that actually could(even though there is a .0001 chance of this actually happening)work.
I am pretty sure we all have, at some point, experienced a champ select with a champion select troll(s). Generally, the first thing you see is something along the lines of "mid only", and then if they are lower on the pick order, and that role is about to be taken, follow up with something like "im going mid no matter what, idc if its multiple people mid, im going". Alot of the time, someone probably dodges, and you heave a sigh of relief, as your queue up again. And then, you end up with the same player.
The idea posted, that I am improving on, could help. Next to each players name in champion select, there would be a little button you could click, and clicking it would ensure you would not end up with that player again. Obviously, without any sort of addition, trolls could wreck the game and cause massive queue times, as was pointed out. However, my idea to improve on it, and fix that problem, is somewhat simple, and has other benefits.
Each player can have only ONE player marked at a time. This mark will ensure that you will NOT be placed onto a team with this player. Even this improvement could still result in long queue times due from an the possibility so many conditions, so I had a further idea. The mark would be wiped after the end of the champion select of the game after your next. And, you only get one mark per day(or whatever amount of time). What I proposed about the mark being wiped may have sounded confusing so I will elaborate.
-Champ select 1: you end up with a troll and mark them, and someone dodges -Champion select 2: you are with a normal team and you play a game. -The game -Champion select 3: You are with a normal team and champion select ends: At the end of that champion select, as the game begins, the mark is wiped from the troll player. ----Or, you could have changed your mark(unless there is some per-day limit)
If nobody dodges, then they will remain marked so you avoid the risk of having to play a second game with them, and the mark will stay until the end of the next champion select.
This would reduce the possible backlog of conditions, that would otherwise result in potential huge queue times.
A system like this has an additional benefit to the game: Combating champion select trolls continual playing. Frequently, players ask for a champion select report system, however, it would be highly difficult to organize. However, this could keep track of players being marked, and if a player consistently has been marked, by many players, over a stretch of time, they would be flagged, and their logs could be reviewed by a Rioter for possible punishment.
This wouldn't just help with that kind of troll, also it would prevent players from having to play with people who are incredibly unpleasant in champion select, and cause someone to dodge. This would lead to many more opportunities to catch highly toxic players.
note: While I know S6 will have a different champion select, a player still must select two roles, and could still refuse to do their second choice role.
Thanks for reading!