Skip to content

The Idiocy of Leagues Privacy and punishment system

The Native 192··9 votes·3,106 views
What Deters Crime? Comparing the Effectiveness of Legal, Social, and Internal Sanctions Across Countries

League of legends has been known for a long time for its toxic community. Many would like to blame the people who play the game for the toxic nature; however, Riot directly contributes to the toxic community by failing to VISUALLY punish the worst offenders. Just like a man being sentenced to jail in a court room. Psychologically people who can visually see the punishments handed out are much less likely to follow suite.(https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4744856/) If a person is not notified when punishment is handed out, then a person is likely to go so far as to believe that no punishment has been given. TRUSTING the system will NEVER be a solution! How can one trust the system when so many people remain toxic in games. If this was a brand new system maybe people could begin by trusting it; yet, when every other game a teammate is flaming someone else on my team the system clearly is not working. Now you might be wondering why League of Legends is so toxic.

In order to break it down, I will separate it into three categories.

League of legends has one problem that can never be resolved that will create toxicity in the community. That concept is that when people are anonymous they feel more free will to share a negative attitude creating toxic behavior. Now the easiest way to reduce toxicity from anonymity would simply be to have a VISUAL ban system. You report a player and you get notified that the ghost cleanse nunu was permanently banned you are much less likely to have feelings of hatred to the nunu jungle who is having a bad game 3 games down the line. Although the only perfect solution would be to disclose the identities of people with accounts for privacy reasons that is not a feasible solutions. However, disclosing action has been taken against an anonymous name does not violate any privacy regulations and should not be seen as a violation of privacy.

  • The cycle of toxicity and the lack of punishment for the worst offenders.

Now, almost every player in League of Legends has experienced one or more players intentionally feeding the enemy, giving up on the game, or rage quitting from a game, and most would agree that these players are the worst members of the community. As such, the punishment for these offenders MUST be harsh and VISUAL. As discussed before, if highlighting the fact that a teammate was punished for deliberately ruining a game people can draw the line where someone is having a bad game versus someone is intentional feeding. If I play ten games in a row and I get three 0-8 teammates but one of them gave up and ran it down mid while the others died under tower to a dive most people would still be toxic to similarly to all three players. This just results in more flame and toxicity for all three players. However, if I knew that action had been taken in the past and was likely to be taken in the future I would be less likely to say anything in game and simply report them in the end game menu. This does two important things. First, if less people are toxic and flame people for having a bad game then that person is likely to not tilt as hard in their following game. In fact, people who do intentionally feed usually do so after loss streaks with poor performances inherently showing that tilt is directly contributing to toxicity and toxicity is breaded by tilt. Second, if I feel confident in the reporting system I can focus more on the game rather than on dealing with a troll. If I feel less negative emotion because I know a troll will get permanently banned for intentionally feeding then I will bring less negative emotion and toxicity into my next game. Less inters = less toxicity and less toxicity = less tilt and less tilt= less inters.

  • Make the report system after games longer and add a pregame lobby report feature (before dodging)

I can't tell you how many times people just report people for "intentionally feeding" after the person was just having a bad game. If you added an area where people can maybe put a video link to show them running it down or a place to show screenshots of a ghost cleanse nunu dancing in mid and added a required amount of text in order to submit a report people would be much less likely to submit false reports. Currently the system is over cluttered with spam reports probably making it very difficult to punish the real offenders. Plus, if there was more work to report someone then people would only do so if they had strong feelings about what that player did. Thus, more accurate reports and less useless information to shuffle through. The second aspect of this category is to add a dodge button with an explanation/report area. Lets say for example I have a ghost cleanse nunu saying he is going to run it down. I click the dodge icon in the top right and it takes me to an instant feedback area where I can highlight the player who was about to int my game and report them. You can also add categories such as "I can't play right now" or "I did not like my team composition" or "I did not have my role/Champion". This simple change will stop people holding champ select hostage which happens in ever one out of four games in Diamond elo and I can only image how bad it is at lower ranks.

Ultimately, These changes highlighted are not recommendations but changes that need to happen if League of Legends wants its community to continue on. Toxicity and trolling has long existed in the League community and Riot has taken little to no action to actually reduce the toxicity. As a registered psychologist who enjoys this game I have shared my opinion. Its your choice to listen.

29 Comments

Baby Ghoul3 votes

Riot used to warn people that they were getting reported too often and need to change their behavior, but I don't think they do that anymore.

SonicAF2 votes

[{quoted}](name=Baby Ghoul,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=4Aj5bGYz,comment-id=0001,timestamp=2018-10-27T05:11:44.856+0000)

Riot used to warn people that they were getting reported too often and need to change their behavior, but I don't think they do that anymore.

Riot doesn't need to warn people that they get reported. It needs to warn that their behaviour is punishable. It has to be exact, not vague.

The Native 1922 votes

I think this is a great point. Clarity leads to less misunderstandings and more improvement in the long term.

mlm olo mlm3 votes

Transparency won't work because Riot rarely punishes game play. Probably even back fires because the trolls find out Riot won't touch them as long as their chat logs are clean.

The chat system is in desperate need of transparency though. It is unbelievable to me that Riot will collect evidence over several games and never inform anyone. The police don't wait for the criminals to commit multiple crimes before they arrest them. "Oh that was just a one time theft. If they do it again let us know and we might do something."

The Native 1922 votes

[{quoted}](name=mlm olo mlm,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=4Aj5bGYz,comment-id=0002,timestamp=2018-10-27T06:44:46.232+0000)

Transparency won't work because Riot rarely punishes game play. Probably even back fires because the trolls find out Riot won't touch them as long as their chat logs are clean.

The chat system is in desperate need of transparency though. It is unbelievable to me that Riot will collect evidence over several games and never inform anyone. The police don't wait for the criminals to commit multiple crimes before they arrest them. "Oh that was just a one time theft. If they do it again let us know and we might do something."

Smart man. However, transparency holds Riot accountable and that's why they have not implemented it.

mlm olo mlm1 votes

[{quoted}](name=The Native 192,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=4Aj5bGYz,comment-id=00020000,timestamp=2018-10-27T15:40:46.606+0000)

Smart man. However, transparency holds Riot accountable and that's why they have not implemented it.

What do you mean by accountable?

The Native 1921 votes
  1. (of a person, organization, or institution) required or expected to justify actions or decisions; responsible. "government must be accountable to its citizens"

If I make a ticketed report, I want to have some form of justification regarding what actions were taken to prevent the issue I experience in game to not happen again. If they are not forced to disclose any information then they can do nothing as it is clear that nothing has been done in regard to the players I have reported. They rely on an automated system that is not nearly sufficient.

mlm olo mlm1 votes

[{quoted}](name=The Native 192,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=4Aj5bGYz,comment-id=0002000000000000,timestamp=2018-10-28T22:05:02.786+0000) prevent the issue I experience in game to not happen again.

That simply is not possible. Even with improved transparency. Punishment systems always react. They do not prevent.

What would you suggest in the following situation:

I report someone. Riot is transparent. Riot punishes. Offender repeats the offenses on an alternate account.

The Native 1921 votes

To clarify, the implementation of transparency is not a permanent fix to toxicity but rather a way to reduce toxicity. Yes, a player can go get 21 accounts like Tyler1 did and go through the hassle of leveling them up or buying them online. However, there comes a point in time where for sanity sake the person is deterred to stop being toxic or to stop trolling games. Now, this will not happen with everyone. There will be the Tyler1's who continue to be toxic and troll; however, as a member of this community, I know multiple people who have intentionally fed on an account (took around 50 games for them to actually be banned in case your wondering) because they wanted to derank from tilt and then they made a new account and have not did it since. The other key is the deterrence factor. If Riot is transparent and visual with punishment, Players are likely to not to act in ways that will get them punished. For example, if someone is getting pulled over in front of me and I was going over the speed limit I am likely to slow down.

Quiet Dude2 votes

Im a registered english major

Imperial Pandaa2 votes

Hmm. So because people clearly get penalized and sent to jail/prison, then that means no one should be commiting any crimes? That seems to be your argument. Yet, crimes still happen and we are stuck trusting that the system will handle the people breaking the law/rules. That isn't even accounting for "repeat" offenders who get penalized again and again. No matter what, you either trust the system to work and follow the rules, or you don't. Increasing feedback notifications isn't going to make that better.

Sure, get a dodge button; you still have to deal with the dodge penalties of using it though. If there isn't penalties for dodging, then people are likely to dodge until they get a comp/players they like.

The Native 1923 votes

My argument is not a question of whether punishment is being handed out correctly, but rather a question of visualizing it to the player base. If a murder is sentenced to life in prison and its blasted across the news logically people would be less inclined to commit murder. Moreover, the whole concept of trusting the system only works if people still trust the system but that is long gone. Visualizing punishment to players is a way to create trust showing that action is being taken.

Second, you never address why a dodge button is bad. I give multiple reasons why it should be added (which you ignore) and try to over simplify my argument by claiming it is not needed. If you have played league of legends, you will at some point experience a player instalocking nunu with ghost and cleanse for some random reason (maybe not getting their role or having their champion banned). If you can report a player and still dodge, less troll games will go through which is always beneficial.

Imperial Pandaa1 votes

The problem is you don't equate it immediately to murder. If you want to do crimes in general, fine; but you don't get to pick a specific high offense crime to use as an example. Speeding is illegal and I know multiple people get tickets for it. Does that stop people from speeding? Nope. Shoplifting is illegal. Does no one shop lift? People still do it though. You wanted to mention murder, well that still happens too. That 14 day reform card they get even warns that the next punishment will most likely be a permanent ban. Repeat offenders probably will reach that point, but others will probably stop before then. People don't exactly trust the justice system or political system, yet they exist still.

Okay, I'll repeat.

If there isn't penalties for dodging, then people are likely to dodge until they get a comp/players they like.

I did not ignore your points, I did address them with effectively 1 reply. Fine though, I'll disect your idea.

You can also add categories such as "I can't play right now"

Then why the fuck did they even queue up? If an emergency suddenly happened, they should be taking the quickest route to handle it. Which means either clicking that x to exit league or if ban/pick hasn't happened for them; afking to auto dodge while they handle whatever.

or "I did not like my team composition"

You really don't see a problem with this? Like, really? Example: Because the top laner picked a split push champ instead of a tank I want to dodge because not getting my way.

or "I did not have my role/Champion".

Again, you don't see this being abused?

Which is why I said:

Sure, get a dodge button; you still have to deal with the dodge penalties of using it though. If there isn't penalties for dodging, then people are likely to dodge until they get a comp/players they like.

People will dodge until they get the FOTM champs on their team or until they get rhings exactly as they want. Which probably will make queues last forever as people continue to dodge for free with your system.

The Native 1922 votes

Your quote "If there isn't penalties for dodging, then people are likely to dodge until they get a comp/players they like."

I never said remove penalties for dodging. Reading is important. I asked for a report system so even if you dodge a game where someone is holding you hostage in champ select (loosing the 3 lp and getting the game timer) people still can be reported rather than forcing the game to go through to report them.

Also regarding the penalty, I never said people would stop trolling, afking and inting games. However, I would say that IF a penalty was clear and IF people knew that Riot was taking action THEN people would be significantly less likely to troll/int/afk in the first place. If you don't understand that simple logic you can look in states where speeding fines are higher and you will notice that ticket numbers actually go down as the price of the ticket goes up. My solution is not the fix all to every problem people face in game. However, it sure would go a long way to helping players who have consistent trolls in their game.

Imperial Pandaa1 votes

You're right, reading is important. So are clarifying details. But hey, I can play that way too! Also my quote in full ~.

Sure, get a dodge button; you still have to deal with the dodge penalties of using it though. If there isn't penalties for dodging, then people are likely to dodge until they get a comp/players they like.

Which means I am all for a dodge button, so long as the penalties remain. Then, and this is yours now, you decided to say this:

Second, you never address why a dodge button is bad.

Now, as you already pointed out, reading is important. Where in my initial post did I say it was bad? Hint, I did not, I just said punishments for dodging should stay. So, while you try to patronize me about how reading is important, maybe you should try it yourself. And in the OP, you weren't clear about penalties still being existent for dodging; only that categories of "No time" and "Hate Comp" could be added.

Here is your fault on the logic you want to present about the afk/troll/etc. You don't have the data to support you. You want to look at different states with different numbers. Great, awesome, however; you can't look at the years when the punishment system became more effective. We can't prove nor disprove that, as an example, the number of people punished decreased when the ifs was implemented by 75%

The Native 1921 votes

I mean you talk about data and information but at the end of the day your base assumption for the system to succeed is for people to trust the system. In fact you deliberately say, "No matter what, you either trust the system to work and follow the rules, or you don't. Increasing feedback notifications isn't going to make that better." However, trust is built not given blindly. For example, lets say someone is about to take a loan from a bank to buy a house. The bank does not give them any amount they desire without any existing proof that they are good at paying back their loans (aka a high credit score). Moreover, before you say there is no reason to trust the system, I have personally reported 6 players with clear violations of the rules and they have yet to be punished. Either they said "this game is over and rage quit" or they intentionally fed the game and ran into the enemy team on purpose. The worst part is in my elo I will consistently get the same players in my game which means I get the same trolls who then ruin more of my games ruining the game.

Imperial Pandaa1 votes

Because, at the simplest base, it boils down to either you trust the system or you don't. People break laws even though they know they exist. Why? Because they think they can get away with it. More transparency won't help with that. We are human, we regularily try to bend the rules to our needs. If we think we can stretch or get away with something, someone will try regardless.

The Native 1921 votes

That is simply not true. Laws are written and portrayed to people so they understand that they do not have the right to break them. Yes people will bend the rules still but if people are not being punished then there is no incentive to stop breaking the rules. Transparency holds riot accountable for banning players with clear violations even if they purchase multiple skins helping their bottom line.

Reapery1232 votes

The hell warning there is 2 or 3 man today that deserve 100% min 1 year ban but what actually you take for staying afk at shop and burning your flash? Type I understand to continue or reducing honor level like this thing (definetly not person) cares. GL HF to improve the most toxic comunity i have ever played in. Indeed i feel the need to see this pure evil elements punished to continue playing leaning on any hope of improvement. I realy feel 80% bad time in LoL lately... I realy like the game but seems switching the entertainer will come soon because of all this toxic (sry i wanted to say TOXIC) society without VISIBLE ACTIONS taken for improvement. Because now bans and punishments are like something that people just talk but not exist irl. And you report report report but its not getting better and you don`t see that someone cares whats going on with you.

The Native 1921 votes

Exactly my point. This problem as you pointed to is exacerbated by Riot not having to SHOW when they take action which allows for inaction to be a possibility and a likely result.

Eleshakai1 votes

These comments always feel to me like someone just wants to get some sick sense of satisfaction out of knowing someone else suffered since that person made them suffer.... and as a player who is rarely, if ever, toxic... these changes would likely make me quit the game, or at least stop reporting someone ever.

The Native 1922 votes

It isn't about satisfaction. It is about bringing trust back into the system that so many people have lost trust in. Also if you don't feel like reporting a troll that's ok. The point is to make it so that those who really feel like someone intentionally trolled them to have the option to plea their case in a setting where riot is not looking through hundreds of reports.

Eleshakai2 votes

Okay so let's take a step back. This is not a legal system, let's be clear. Comparing it to legal systems is not a valid comparison. This is a customer/business relationship.

Businesses are generally not legally allowed to discuss the status of customer accounts publicly without those customers' permissions. It is also generally considered a heavily unethical business practice to do so, even in places where the laws permit it.

Additionally, I have no reason to doubt the system. I don't see this 'growing toxicity' you speak of. I see lots of posts on the forums of people complaining about being banned unfairly, but every case seems like the system was fair. The system, as far as I can see, is working normally. Why would I doubt it?

But even moreso, being reminded of a game that was ruined by toxicity - regardless of HOW I am reminded of it - is a detriment. Getting that 'instant feedback report' actually makes me want to play less. I report people because it is a NECESSARY EVIL to help maintain and improve the quality of everyone's experience. There is no pleasure taken in it. As a result, once I'm done reporting, I just want to move on to the next game and never think about the game again. It's over, it's gone, I've moved on. Seeing that instant feedback report just reminds me of the negative experience I had. It brings me down... because I don't want to think about it. I don't get any joy or satisfaction out of knowing my actions have hurt someone else(ie. someone getting punished).

The changes you propose would make someone who has been a positive contributor to the community - someone who gets honoured in most games he plays, who has made several long-time friends through the game, and who has never been punished - and drive them completely out of the community.

I guess if you want the people who get sick glee out of knowing their impacts have hurt someone else to be the predominant population... then fine.

The Native 1922 votes

First, You reference account information alluding to it as if it were some form of bank account. We are talking about a video game account that is completely anonymous. If you report a profile on Facebook and they remove the account they notify you. Do you know why? Because people ask for accountability. There is no privacy law or restrictions surrounding Riots actions on anonymous accounts based on an inquiry with substantial proof.

Regarding the "negative experience" you have when reporting people, I play with the same players almost all the time. The higher your rank the same players you get in your game. My problem is when I report someone, make a ticket, and provide proof and then I see them in my game the next day and they run down mid I recognize their is no accountability.

I have had 5 ticketed reports of people trolling games in the last week. Now, I am not talking about a player who had a bad game, but rather I am talking about a player who legitimately left the game or ran it down mid. I have their op.ggs and guess what. They are still playing the game. Maybe in high diamond this is more of a than in low gold but Riot has to be held accountable. If you don't care about the result of your report that is ok. You do not have to be notified. However, the fact that it is not an option makes little to no sense.

Eleshakai1 votes

Facebook is the worst case you could give, since there have been lawsuits against them over their mishandling of customer information. Not specifically relating to that, but it has happened multiple times. Facebook is the company who will update their privacy settings and set your account to the LOWEST SETTINGS via an automated process. Sorry, I wouldn't use them as a positive example when it comes to maintaining privacy of customers. They're literally the worst organization in the world when it comes to that sort of thing.

It is really only in like... high diamond... that the pool is small enough for you to reliably see the same people over and over again. Designing a system to punish 99% of the population for the sake of the 1% is foolhardy.

If the option were to exist, it should require BOTH parties to opt into it. ie. I should have to have an option checked to RECEIVE the report, and the person who is punished should have to have an option selected for them to send. I will quit the game if Riot sets up a system that reliably gives customer details to people who report. Full stop. Because, if something happens and I ever do get punished(unlikely), I wouldn't want Riot discussing it with some random stranger to give them some sick satisfaction over it. So, if you WANT to scare off people who aren't toxic in order to get your jollies on reporting, then keep encouraging this... but I guarantee you a system like you suggest WILL cost them players. Because most people in the tech industry are fanatical about their privacy online, and a system that reliably violates that privacy would not fly. I am actually LESS picky about this than most of the people I've worked with, honestly.

BS. If they left the game, they got punished. Leaverbuster has literally 0 forgiveness and punishes a person on their first leave, with escalating punishments as it becomes a pattern. Now... the first few punishments are not 'you are banned', they're escalating periods of time to wait to play. I don't agree with Leaverbuster exactly because it has no accounting for intent, but that's the truth of the system. Your fist leave, you get a minor punishment, and it escalates from there.

As to 5 in a week... I think I've seen one person legitimately troll in the past month... if that. What are tyou doing to these people that they're trolling you that much?

The Native 1921 votes

First of all, Riot's privacy policy even says they reserve the right to share your information so you have already opted into sharing of this information. Second, you are still anonymous. Riot is not sharing your personal information, ip address, or email. In fact, there is no abuse that could occur from sharing this information so I do not understand how this is a "huge" problem for you. You like to talk about satisfaction but this has never been about satisfaction. From the beginning, this has always been about accountability and transparency. The reality is this isn't about publicly listing all the usernames that have been banned or trying to punish those who have made mistakes. However, this is about holding Riot accountable from avoiding banning toxic players who purchase skins and increase revenues. You may not experience toxicity or trolling on a regular basis but that is because you are in a much lower elo where people care a lot less about the game. If I queue up for a game, people aggravate others from teammates arguing and blaming each other over insignificant mistakes. That is why people rage quit, int, or afk games and the fact that I continue to get the same teammates who then pick up an argument with one of my new teammates is not reasonable. If I am filling out a report taking my time to help them remove toxic people from the community who ruin games for other members of the community then Riot should have the decency to explain what actions they are taking to combat that player from ruining my next game. Riot goes as far to disclose the instant feedback reports so it is clear that they have realized this is an issue; however, the truth of the matter is they do not disclose their responses to all cases because it would hurt their bottom line to ban a player who spends a lot of money on the game. Riot is not a charity but a business and it is our duty as customers to hold them accountable. If you are so worried about some random person with a random username hearing that you were justifiably banned from intentionally feeding then your interests are far from most members of this community.

Eleshakai2 votes

There's no NEED for that type of transparency. You shouldn't expect transparency about the status of other peoples' accounts. That's such a selfish, uncalled-for expectation. It's ridiculous. Reports on 'number of accounts actioned during x period', etc... general, non-specific, statistic data. That's a valid request. But specifics? No. Not at all. That's just awful.

Why does the transparency matter to you to such an extent that you require specifics? Why is general statistical data insufficient? If you just want proof the system is working, statistical data should be sufficient.

The only reason I can see for why you'd need SPECIFIC info about each account is that you want to be able to gloat internally(or externally) over that person. Which makes it about satisfaction.

Next you're going to be saying 'if I complain about someone when I phone in for support, I expect their management to call me back and tell me in detail what they did to act on my complaint'

The Native 1921 votes

General data can be easily manipulated. There is a reason Monsanto and other companies pay professors to do studies to analyze data and shift the statistical results in their favor. Even so that data and report does not exist. A blind system never works. If your games were getting ruined as much as mine you would want for Riot to do something and it is clear that nothing is being done as the players who I have reported have yet to be punished. You can have fun in low ranks all you want but some people seek a competitive environment and they is not maintained when people are constantly rage quitting from the game or intentionally feedings because of something a random teammate said. Go harass another post if your going to repeat yourself with illogical responses to the arguments I listed.

Eleshakai2 votes

Data is inarguably better to use for PROVING A SYSTEM IS WORKING though than anecdotes. There's a reason why 'anecdotal evidence' is typically frowned upon in any official setting, ESPECIALLY when trying to prove general effectiveness. So if you're looking for real accountability, hard data is what you need.

For example, if you want to know if a product is going to last, do you trust the one person for whom it worked, or the 0.1% positive review score? If you are trying to prove if a medicine is effective, do you trust a stranger who says "Oh ya, it cured me good" OR the scientific studies that show that it is effective in 94% of cases with negative side effects in only 0.01% of cases. If you want to know if a legal system is effective, do you trust Bob who was assaulted last week, or the study showing that since its institution, violent crime rates decreased by 35%. What you're asking for is for them to provide anecdotal evidence in stead of statistical evidence... which is only valuable to make the person receiving the feedback report FEEL GOOD. ie. give them a sense of instant gratification, or satisfaction.

Don't equate 'want a competitive environment' with 'want Riot to breach customer privacy'. There is no valid relationship between those two points. Just because I don't want Riot to discuss customer account status does NOT mean I do not want a competitive environment. It simply means I want them to use ETHICALLY SOUND means to achieve that, which I don't consider your proposal to be... and I want them to stick to providing evidence that ACTUALLY PROVES SOMETHING as opposed to random instant gratification via anecdotal verification.

More from Player Behavior

More by The Native 192