Boards›Player Behavior

On the use of the words "toxic" versus "negative" in regards to punishable behavior

Deep Terror Nami··13 votes·1,120 views

I think the word "toxic" is overused. Not because it's too often an inappropriate description where used, but because many players define "toxicity" as extreme negative behavior only. Some players think if you have to be "toxic" to get punished, that means you have to be extremely negative.

Simply using the word "negative" is more appropriate for describing all behavior that can result in punishment, as people see it as having a much broader definition and covering both minor and major offenses.

You can get punished for any negative behavior. While this is technically true, that doesn't mean calling someone a "doodoo head" is going to get you banned. It's about the consistency of the negative behavior; it typically takes many games before such minor negative behavior will get your case reviewed and result in punishment, plus there are 4 tiers of punishment to go through.

Basically, I believe using the word "negative" more aptly communicates to players what kind of behavior is punishable, while "toxic" is viewed more typically as only extreme behavior.

#What do you think? Do you feel the word "negative" is more appropriate for describing all punishable behavior, or does the word "toxic" to you include even the most minor offenses?

20 Comments

MUSHROOM MIDGET3 votes

negative isnt right. behavior is toxic because it poisons your whole team. toxic is a much better description.

RcGjWO640w2 votes

Toxicity refers to the action where your negativity adversely affects the behavior of your teammates. It poisons their behavior for the sole purpose of inflaming them and making them angrier.

Negativity on the other hand is just having a bad attitude. It's find if you rage behind your computer screen, Riot doesn't care about that, but the moment you bring that negativity to your team and make them deal with it, that's when they have a problem.

SanKakU2 votes

Negativity shouldn't get punished at all. Warning your top/jungle/mid to come stop(a negative word) the enemy jungle from getting dragon for example can win your team the game.

Toxicity is what should be punished. Stubbornly refusing to help your team win because you all of a sudden aren't having fun anymore is the classic example of toxic behavior. Sure, it's negative because you are refusing to do what you're supposed to do. But it's because your will is toxic. Not because your will is negative. Someone can tell you to stop being that way, and they would be negative because they're trying to deny you the 'right to throw the game' but I don't see how someone asking for mercy from some temper tantrum should be punished.

underscores2222 votes

I define negative as someone with a can't attitude - we can't win. This can also be displayed in a general pessimistic outlook, up to and including complaining about the team and what we should have done earlier (jungler ganks, etc) and generally not being a positive, trying to win player.

Toxic is when this behavior gets out of hand - either by flaming and badmouthing other players, engaging in poor behavior (base running, not helping in team fights, feeding), or by saying things that make the rest of the team lose motivation. It's like the next step after being negative, and is therefore that much worse.

Zombiemaster1 votes

I do agree. I've never really liked the word "toxic" when describing punishable behavior. I use it from time to time if the person I'm discussing with tends to use it a lot, but even then I still prefer using something different, like "negative."

I don't know, I just don't really like the word in general to be honest. Unless of course we're talking about actual toxic stuff, like poison or chemicals, but I rarely find myself in the situation where I am talking about that kind of stuff.

As you pointed out, I feel like "toxic" carries much heavier connotation and that it refers more to extreme behavior rather than all punishable behavior. I personally feel that using "negative" or "unacceptable" is better when talking about punishable behavior.

1wolfpack1 votes

its easier to type toxic as opposed to negative, less letters. to make life easier we should use the letter "X" in place of the work Toxic or Negative. EZ, GG, GL HF

BlueThingamajig1 votes

I think the problem is that the word toxic has been misappropriated. In its first use by Riot, it was very clearly defined as "Behavior that causes other players to be more likely to be negative in their games"

Kinda like how "Netflix and Chill" used to literally mean "hang out and watch shows/movies on Netflix" before it became a euphemism.

AraMoOse1 votes

Distance the trivial labeling of punctual brains.

scazzman1 votes

i personally feel that not ALL negatvity should be punished. for example i feel that if someone tells you kys starts spamming racial/homophobic slurs. or is actively trolling. you're well within your right to tell someone to fuck off. i feel in some instances. retaliation is okay. or at the very least forgivable.

also. if riot wants to have a zero tolerance policy on negativity. thats fine. but in order to do that. they need to completely eliminate trolling in ranked. and make sure that deliberatly trying to get people in trouble is in the same instaban category as homophobia and racial slurs

also. i feel like telling someone "shut up and play the game" isnt toxic

balbraaksel1 votes

You really shouldn't do that, why would you retaliate? Why would you even consider wasting your time to retaliate, destracting you from the match? It only escalates things, the less you type the more likely you are to win.

If the person really is that severely offensive, screenshot it and send a support ticket to Riot (+ report of course).

scazzman1 votes

thats all well and good when everyone is in a clear state of mind, but once adrenaline and testosterone start taking effect. not everyone has the capacity to ignore frustration

balbraaksel1 votes

Yeah I can perfectly understand that, I've occasionally had some adrenaline coursing through my veins too from pure frustration. But I would never retaliate in game, it won't get me anywhere.

scazzman1 votes

not everyone can do that though. and originally. permabans were meant only for the people who were truly toxic beyond the point of reform or forgiveness. now. anyone can be permabanned if they get reported enough

balbraaksel1 votes

Everyone SHOULD be able to do that. It's either that or get reported and banned. And I disagree to that anyone is possible to get permbanned, if you don't do anything wrong you would not get punished.

scazzman1 votes

untrue. the automated bot. is designed to adjust the perameters of whats punishable via what the community deems "offensive" . lets say for instance. a popular streamer puts a report bounty on you. eventually you will be punished because even if you arent toxic, after enough reports . the automated system will consider your existence toxic.

Qiy4na1 votes

Toxic negativity spreads like poison and makes more than one person angry but its still just a form of negativity, so negativity (being a downer n such) encompasses more*[zombie-nunu-bummed]*

OneMustFall1 votes

Being negative isn't an automatic cause for punishment. There are plenty of people who will say "WTF Team, you just let me die! We're gonna lose now..." <- That's negative but it doesn't mean they should be punished for expressing frustration in the game.

Being toxic is repeatedly spamming the /ff everytime it comes up and saying "GG just surrender, you guys all suck, we can't win". That's toxic and that should be punished. I think there's a big difference between expressing some frustration once because of a bad situation and being constantly negative regardless of your team's effort.

Morality Coach1 votes

This protest against the standard Riot toxic label seems passive aggressive.

Myrin Deez Gains1 votes

I think your opinion really doesn't matter on this because YOU WERE REMOVED FROM THE ARBITER SYSTEM for being TOXIC, even though you were Riot's #1 "YESMAN." You are literally the epitome of toxicity and then try to put on this "holier than thou" act every time you come on the boards. It makes me sick to my stomach to watch someone get away with such atrocities.

Get off your high horse and get over yourself!

And I have SEEN someone get banned for calling another player "poopoo head."

More from Player Behavior

The indefinite banning of Tyler1
Player Behavior4,799 comments
2,942
votes
14 day ban because playing Nunu Support with Smite is "stealing other people's roles"...?
Player Behavior1,525 comments
1,086
votes
Riot should add monthly status cards
Player Behavior241 comments
843
votes
Reminder that we haven't gotten our Summoner report cards yet :/
Player Behavior145 comments
619
votes
I'm not "triggered" by you throwing insults.
Player Behavior361 comments
548
votes
Black Alistar, King Rammus!!!!
Player Behavior462 comments
503
votes

More by Deep Terror Nami

When you want some alone time with your significant other, but you've got a kid
Memes & Games45 comments
296
votes
@Riot: I'd like to donate all my RP
Memes & Games127 comments
263
votes
It's my birthday; upvote to get me PBE and Alpha client access
Memes & Games85 comments
230
votes
How the discussion over Mastery 6/7 implementation went.
Memes & Games61 comments
214
votes
Tibbers! How about have Annie toss the bear, so there's chance to react?
Gameplay182 comments
204
votes
Hey guys, just wanted to let you know I've stopped playing League
Memes & Games71 comments
201
votes