Improvements to the tribunal

HolowHall of Hal·6/10/2015, 1:20:16 PM·2 votes·450 views

By my understanding the reports that have an heavier weight are the ones that come from people that usually are correct in reporting (in which the reported player gets warned/punished). But even if those reports are taken in account much more than other reports, the punishment will still not be immediate. So here is my idea: Basically those people that are always/most of the times correct in their reports should have a sort of 'instant tribunal case' (not really sure what to call it). Basically it means that once in a while they can have a perk (they have to choose to use it or not) making that a report on someone that was extremely toxic be on a priority queue. That means the guy who was in their team that fed 100 kills in 20 minutes and bought 6 types of boots can be punished almost immediately. We also could make it that ,when they use that power of them to make them instantly be reviewed by the tribunal , they could not play until their case gets reviewed. To make sure that this system does not get abused, if it seems like they are using that power to troll someone they shall not be able to use that perk and are not able to use the tribunal for a set amount of time. If they abuse it 3 times, their account counts as banned in sake of the tribunal, they can no longer review tribunal cases, they can no longer use the perks that they had.

Also when the replay system gets implemented make it so that we can send that replay along with the report(but make it so that players have to identify the instances of time at which there is some sort of toxic behavior)

Remember to point out stuff that might be abused with this system besides what I said. Feedback is appreciated.

6 Comments

OhBoyItsaMegaman6/10/2015, 7:02:56 PM2 votes

Tribunal's been out of service for well over a year now.

Handing people nuclear buttons seems like all downside... If somebody hit YOU with the instant ban, would it make you want to change your behavior? Or would you just figure that they gave the button to the wrong guy?

Punishment needs to feel like it came from the whole community so that people realize that they're acting in a way that the entire playerbase disapproves of. Otherwise there's no reform taking place.

ChrisV6/10/2015, 11:03:32 PM1 votes

I received an instant permanent suspension yesterday for my behavior in one game, without ever receiving a warning, chat restriction, or suspension on my account prior to this. I was permanently suspended 2 minutes after the game ended, for that same exact game. I contacted Riot and all they can keep bringing up is the chat transcript from that one game.