The thing about it.....
Yes we can mute them, but voice chat would bring in more problems than solve them. You also cannot say that the toxicity it will bring is invalid because we can mute them because that IS the issue. It is like claiming and complaining that every female champ in League is booty butt ass naked and them saying that
doesn't count because she could have been considered a boy or is animal like.
- Not everyone is mature enough to use voice chat in League someone could...
- Make your ears bleed by screaming or playing some extraordinarily loud sound. (Even if riot put a limit on how dB or something like that, it will not work the same for everybody since not everyone's sound card and mic / headset / earphones / and headphones are the same)
- Put porn or something sexual / erotic in the background to play.
- Just say a whole bunch of no-no words for no reason such as racial slurs or self moaning in an attempt to be funny or make the fact that they have barely had any sexual contact whatsoever a bit more bearable (No I am not trying to be funny or insult someone when I say that)
- Toxicity
-
Words hurt, but not as much as when you hear them directly (and even more-so right in front of you) You could have a full on flame war going on in voice chat and it would be even worse for it to be something you have to hear as compared to what is being typed.
-
It may be a tad harder to ban people for the presumptuous things that they say as compared to chat. If someone is being toxic in chat and they are reported, Riot can just read the chat logs easy peasy, simple and clean and decide what to do from there.
With voice chat they will have to listen to nearly every single thing said and determine what to say about the situation, not only that, but the players themselves may not be audible and how will they know for sure who is who that is spreading all the nasties? The guy that sounds like a generic 12 year old could be anyone there. Will Riot even INVEST in the time to have a system to record EVERY SINGLE second or every single thing said in voice chat and listen to them all? It sounds like it would use up too much time as well as too much space.
-
Some people may not want to voice chat and they could disable it, but their team may pressure them into activating it and the pressure is rarely if ever positive.
(That is not all I have to say about toxicity, I could go on and on, but that would cause this to be larger than it already is)
- Issues with sound
- Believe it or not... not everyone has access to voice chat or even sound on their laptop / computer and while everyone else is speaking instead of pinging, the other person doesn't know what the hell else their team is planning or thinking, even if they notify their team that they cannot voice chat, not everyone will be willing to compensate for it.
- Things such as static can still occur or people may voices sound bat shit terrible over a mic
- Voice changers. While not bad can be abused. People who use programs to make themselves sound feminine (if they know how to act feminine as well that is an even bigger bonus) could trick the weak minded / horny / lonely into buying them skins, treating them differently or being more lax on them and realizing someone is a girl or being around one can be distracting even for the strong minded / sated / (semi) popular. (not all the time or in every situation mind you).
I could go on and on like I said on multiple subjects or advance on what I have already stated, voice chat may be able to work on plenty of games, but League is definitely not one of them due to it having some of the most toxic communities in online gaming.
Until they can get a mass majority of these trolls, feeders and whatnot (I am not saying that they are or are not), League is not ready for voice chat. While there will be some situations where there won't be anyone severely autistic (Not trying to be mean or funny) screwing around in voice chat, we sure cannot count on everyone.
Despite that, plenty of people on League are down to voice chat, so if possible while in the champ select screen or at the start of the game you can ask if anyone wants to Skype / Raid call or something