Suggestions for Report Tracking, Honor and Unskilled Comments
Before reading: I apologize for the lack of organization in this post, but the idea is that the program is opt-in only, you have to volunteer to participate.
Report Tracking You have the ability to see how much honor you have for each category, your wins and losses, CS, etc., but why is there no way for us to track our own reports? And by that I mean when and why we were reported.
As far as I can remember, since the new system has come up I have never been reported for anything that would give the alert that I was reported. I generally have an outwardly positive behavior, though my optimism is not infallible and I'm subject to bad moods just as much as the next guy, if not more if I'm honest with myself.
If for no other reason, it'd be a good reformation tool that's used before a ban, after a report warning, and throughout your time playing. I believe that people can change, sometimes they need a helping, supportive hand, sometimes all they need are resources and themselves. A private, anonymous report tracker can contribute to both.
Critique Comments Also, the inclusion of non-behavioral based reports, such as "unskilled" would be wonderful. Not everyone has the guts to give criticism directly, and while I agree that this may in fact cause more issues with criticisms that aren't constructive and just in fact more abuse, even a simple number can give someone a hint that hey, I'm doing something wrong. To counteract abusive comments, a counter-report system could be put in place.
For report (unskilled) comments, limit the ability to do so to people who do not have a record for bad behavior and have put a certain number of hours into the game to give constructive criticisms such as "Unskilled Player: While you played a pretty good Vayne, you need to work on your positioning in fights and practice your CSing a little more. Check out some videos on minion farming."
Honor Comments I believe there should be an addition to increase the pool of options for player ratings that only the reported/honored person can see, even small comments that may even be able to go on the player's profile, such as "Teamwork: Dude played an awesome Blitz, landed many game changing hooks, peeled well when needed, warded like a boss, and was overall a great guy to have on the team!" It feels good to be honored, and it feels even better when the honor is more than a number. It's the difference between a handshake and a high-five coupled with "Keep up the good work, you're doing great!"
TLDR; Add ability for players to track when and why they were reported, allow for unskilled report comments and honor comments.
Thoughts?
Edit: I realize that not all players would want to have this available to them. By default, if you have muted someone they should not show up on your comments feed, and players should have to opt in to the program.
Edit 2: Added rough image of what I'm talking about. The champion icons are who you played, not who honored/reported you. This should all be as anonymous as possible. It's about your own personal improvement, not a social contest, not a reason to hunt people down and poop in their boots while they sleep, just you.
