Skip to content

"I trust my ISPs so I'm against Net Neutrality"

Destaice··105 votes·3,942 views

In South Korea the average household pays roughly equivalent to 20 USD a month for 1,000 Mbps of internet speed.

In America there are people who think a 1,000 Mbps is impossible because they're used to paying 20 dollars a month for 10 Mbps.

Also worth mentioning that many ISPs already have patents for technology that will allow them to discriminate against websites unless you pay extra.

Most trustworthy people I swear.

71 Comments

Jamaree53 votes

"We promise we won't throttle your internet, we just want to be able to have the ability to if we wanted to...BUT, we PROMISE we won't."

CLG ear36 votes

also google fiber offered 1 gigabit internet but ISPs hated having to compete so they bribed local officials to make it so Google couldn't lay cable

and google said fuck this shit so they slowed their fiber optic plans

and these fucking retards think that removing net neutrality will make this better somehow? Because if you live in kansas city before google fiber ur internet was 1 mbps. After google fiber it's 600 mpbs

what a fucking world we live in

IllusoryLumines2 votes

[{quoted}](name=CLG ear,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=0002,timestamp=2017-12-05T08:58:38.433+0000)

also google fiber offered 1 gigabit internet but ISPs hated having to compete so they bribed local officials to make it so Google couldn't lay cable

and google said fuck this shit so they slowed their fiber optic plans

and these fucking retards think that removing net neutrality will make this better somehow? Because if you live in kansas city before google fiber ur internet was 1 mbps. After google fiber it's 600 mpbs

what a fucking world we live in

Google fiber didn't take off because there aren't enough people who actually need a 1 gigabit internet speed so badly they can take extra costs.

CLG ear9 votes

{quoted}

Google fiber didn't take off because there aren't enough people who actually need a 1 gigabit internet speed so badly they can take extra costs.

no it actually did

it was popular but fucking

ISPs comcast didn't like that they had to actually be competitive

so they just bribed local governments that google fiber wanted to lay their fiber

and they made it hard as shit to do it as a non guy

CrisisEchoes1 votes

[{quoted}](name=CLG ear,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=0002,timestamp=2017-12-05T08:58:38.433+0000)

also google fiber offered 1 gigabit internet but ISPs hated having to compete so they bribed local officials to make it so Google couldn't lay cable

and google said fuck this shit so they slowed their fiber optic plans

and these fucking retards think that removing net neutrality will make this better somehow? Because if you live in kansas city before google fiber ur internet was 1 mbps. After google fiber it's 600 mpbs

what a fucking world we live in

... nobody can block google, they just decided google fiber wasnt lucrative enough for their time. Google probably has the most resources of any company ever.

CLG ear3 votes

{quoted}

... nobody can block google, they just decided google fiber wasnt lucrative enough for their time. Google probably has the most resources of any company ever.

it wasn't lucrative enough because ISPs paid off local politicians to make it hard for google to lay their fiber

Xonra2 votes

I live in NC, and less than a mile down the road they have Google. We can't because the HOA didn't want the cable. In the next zip code google isn't allowed to lay cable cause they have an exclusive deal with Time Warner (now spectrum), so spectrum is the ONLY option they have, and they are less than 5 minutes down the road.

Google had to loophole to even get INTO the Charlotte area cause they signed an exclusivity deal with Time Warner and keep renewing it because all the businesses want to keep it...because Time Warner made a deal to give all the local banks and businesses free T1 lines.

CLG ear23 votes

We literally could have gigabit internet in every major city but comcast/time warner/cox cable do not want to improve their infrastructure

look at kansas city. There was 1 real ISP there before google: comcast. Comcast's internet speeds were maybe 10 mbps if u paid 120 a month for it. Google fiber comes in and offers 1 gigabit internet for 70 a month. all of a sudden comcast want to increase your speed to 600 mbps to stay with them.

fucking bullshit

Busty Demoness10 votes

I don't trust them. But Net Neutrality doesn't help the actual problem.

What needs to happen is using the anti-trust laws to break down the companies into smaller ones. There's no competition and Net Neutrality doesn't create it.

CLG ear21 votes

[{quoted}](name=Busty Demoness,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=0004,timestamp=2017-12-05T09:10:47.526+0000)

I don't trust them. But Net Neutrality doesn't help the actual problem.

What needs to happen is using the anti-trust laws to break down the companies into smaller ones. There's no competition and Net Neutrality doesn't create it.

and you think dickhead ajit pai who is a verizon shill is going to do that

do you even think any politician will stop ISPs

removing net neutrality makes things worse not better

Busty Demoness8 votes

[{quoted}](name=CLG ear,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=00040000,timestamp=2017-12-05T09:19:33.866+0000)

and you think dickhead ajit pai who is a verizon shill is going to do that

do you even think any politician will stop ISPs

removing net neutrality makes things worse not better

Let me rephrase a little bit.

If the people keep asking for something that doesn't solve the actual problem, then they are contributing to the whole problem.

Keep asking for a bandaid on a blood clot and that's what you'll start getting instead of a heart transplant. Keep asking for cough medicine for your cut hand and you'll start getting it for your broken bones.

Stop acting like this does anything more than contribute to the entire problem. This is not a solution and it does not make things better. All it does is delay the solution to the true problem.

If you want to keep kicking the can down the road under the idea that this does something GOOD, be my guest. I'm not going to support something that is not going to alleviate, let alone solve, the problem.

Malza10 votes

[{quoted}](name=Busty Demoness,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=0004,timestamp=2017-12-05T09:10:47.526+0000)

I don't trust them. But Net Neutrality doesn't help the actual problem.

What needs to happen is using the anti-trust laws to break down the companies into smaller ones. There's no competition and Net Neutrality doesn't create it.

So because net neutrality doesn't create competition between ISPs we should just get rid of it and make the monopolies even bigger

Busty Demoness4 votes

{quoted}

So because net neutrality doesn't create competition between ISPs we should just get rid of it and make the monopolies even bigger

There's another legal answer already in place called "anti trust laws" designed to keep monopolies from punishing consumers.

People who want Net Neutrality are not asking for the monopolies to be broken down so they can have a choice in who their ISP is.

Malza1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Busty Demoness,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=000400010000,timestamp=2017-12-05T12:15:05.636+0000)

There's another legal answer already in place called "anti trust laws" designed to keep monopolies from punishing consumers.

People who want Net Neutrality are not asking for the monopolies to be broken down so they can have a choice in who their ISP is.

Just since they're actively speaking out against the one that will impact that their user experience more (net neutrality going away) doesn't mean they don't also want the ISP monopolies to go away.

We wouldn't need net neutrality if there weren't ISP monopolies but the problem with that is they're a natural monopoly and they always will be unless you regulate them out of being one.

And even if we completely the near impossible task of breaking down the ISP monopolies and also allowing for more competition there will still always be tons of areas that are only serviced by 1 ISP. Which means they'd just have a monopoly in that area anyways, and it's not economically viable to avoid that.

Busty Demoness2 votes

{quoted}

Just since they're actively speaking out against the one that will impact that their user experience more (net neutrality going away) doesn't mean they don't also want the ISP monopolies to go away.

We wouldn't need net neutrality if there weren't ISP monopolies but the problem with that is they're a natural monopoly and they always will be unless you regulate them out of being one.

And even if we completely the near impossible task of breaking down the ISP monopolies and also allowing for more competition there will still always be tons of areas that are only serviced by 1 ISP. Which means they'd just have a monopoly in that area anyways, and it's not economically viable to avoid that.

Net Neutrality doesn't actually affect the consumers anywhere near as much as you think.

We still get throttled. We still don't get improvements in service. We are still massively overcharged.

And none of that has changed since BEFORE Net Neutrality was put in.

Malza2 votes

[{quoted}](name=Busty Demoness,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=00040001000000000000,timestamp=2017-12-07T18:38:35.927+0000)

Net Neutrality doesn't actually affect the consumers anywhere near as much as you think.

We still get throttled. We still don't get improvements in service. We are still massively overcharged.

And none of that has changed since BEFORE Net Neutrality was put in.

There is no "BEFORE Net Neutrality", we effectively had it as we do now from practically the inception of ISPs to January 14, 2014 with this court case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verizon_Communications_Inc._v._FCC_(2014)

In the early 2000s whenever ISPs were violating net neutrality the FCC was putting a stop to it.

Busty Demoness2 votes

{quoted}

There is no "BEFORE Net Neutrality", we effectively had it as we do now from practically the inception of ISPs to January 14, 2014 with this court case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verizon_Communications_Inc._v._FCC_(2014).

In the early 2000s whenever ISPs were violating net neutrality the FCC was putting a stop to it.

So what about before that when we were still on dial up connections? Internet was picking up speed in the late 1990's and it wasn't there.

Meanwhile, the true problem isn't being solved by NN and NN does very little to actually protect the consumer.

If you want to truly protect consumers from the conglomerates, support something that actually does it. Stop acting like NN does anything but kick the can down the road and nothing else.

CLG ear2 votes

[{quoted}](name=Busty Demoness,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=0004000100000000000000000000,timestamp=2017-12-08T00:20:29.013+0000)

So what about before that when we were still on dial up connections? Internet was picking up speed in the late 1990's and it wasn't there.

Meanwhile, the true problem isn't being solved by NN and NN does very little to actually protect the consumer.

If you want to truly protect consumers from the conglomerates, support something that actually does it. Stop acting like NN does anything but kick the can down the road and nothing else.

removing net neutrality creates more problems it doesn't solve them

Busty Demoness2 votes

[{quoted}](name=CLG ear,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=00040001000000000000000000000000,timestamp=2017-12-08T00:23:18.509+0000)

removing net neutrality creates more problems it doesn't solve them

"Keep net neutrality" = "keep the conglomerates and use title 2 to give the regulating power to the FCC that won't do it"

You want to protect consumers but you still vote for the conglomerates.

CLG ear2 votes

[{quoted}](name=Busty Demoness,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=000400010000000000000000000000000000,timestamp=2017-12-08T00:31:56.081+0000)

"Keep net neutrality" = "keep the conglomerates and use title 2 to give the regulating power to the FCC that won't do it"

You want to protect consumers but you still vote for the conglomerates.

i don't think you know what title 2 is

Busty Demoness2 votes

[{quoted}](name=CLG ear,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=0004000100000000000000000000000000000000,timestamp=2017-12-08T00:39:18.051+0000)

i don't think you know what title 2 is

Title 2 puts all of the regulating power in the FCC as opposed to the FTC. Treats bandwidth as a utility (utilities should be regulated by the FTC anyway).

FCC is much more easily bought out than the FTC. FTC can impost stricter punishments on companies. FTC is the organization that's actually in place for consumers.

That is what Title 2 is. That is what you're defending. That is why I can't support NN.

DariusDemiurge10 votes

But muh "America is too large to build an effective net infrastructure unlike those small Asian countries!"

CLG ear9 votes

{quoted}

But muh "America is too large to build an effective net infrastructure unlike those small Asian countries!"

too bad we gave them billions of dollars to actually improve internet infrastructure but they didn't do that

instead they focused on wireless because it was easier

meanwhile the american consumer is

https://i.imgur.com/IOoFoQB.jpg[]

ADC Bard15 votes

[{quoted}](name=CLG ear,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=00060000,timestamp=2017-12-05T09:25:57.348+0000)

too bad we gave them billions of dollars to actually improve internet infrastructure but they didn't do that

instead they focused on wireless because it was easier

meanwhile the american consumer is

https://i.imgur.com/IOoFoQB.jpg[]

american consumers are waifus ?

Bard

CLG ear6 votes

[{quoted}](name=I Play Rats Only,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=000600000000,timestamp=2017-12-05T09:54:21.115+0000)

american consumers are waifus ?

Bard

well this is a guy so

ADC Bard3 votes

[{quoted}](name=CLG ear,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=0006000000000000,timestamp=2017-12-05T10:01:17.512+0000)

well this is a guy so

And your point ?

Bard

Nęçrømąnçęr8 votes

net neutrality is a superficial bandaid fix to an issue and doesn't solve the long term problem.

Abolish the FCC and all the regulations it had and in the same motion add a temporary regulation that big telecom companies MUST split into smaller competitive companies under penalty of law with a monopoly tax that forces them to pay money into a government fund that helps startups in the field under a certain bracket with infastructure. After enough market freedom is allowed by choking the monopolies per the regulation remove all government regulation and allow it to operate under free market principles.

BobaFlautist2 votes

[{quoted}](name=Demon Empress,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=0007,timestamp=2017-12-05T10:07:40.810+0000)

net neutrality is a superficial bandaid fix to an issue and doesn't solve the long term problem.

Abolish the FCC and all the regulations it had and in the same motion add a temporary regulation that big telecom companies MUST split into smaller competitive companies under penalty of law with a monopoly tax that forces them to pay money into a government fund that helps startups in the field under a certain bracket with infastructure. After enough market freedom is allowed by choking the monopolies per the regulation remove all government regulation and allow it to operate under free market principles.

How do you think monopolies get established in the first place? Free market principles don't work without consistent, effective regulation, because companies don't want a free market. Whichever company happens to be the most successful just grows and grows and buys/chokes out all competition so they don't have to maintain a high quality product. It happens in every single industry without thorough enough anti-monopoly regulations, again and a fucking gain.

Nęçrømąnçęr1 votes

{quoted}

How do you think monopolies get established in the first place? Free market principles don't work without consistent, effective regulation, because companies don't want a free market. Whichever company happens to be the most successful just grows and grows and buys/chokes out all competition so they don't have to maintain a high quality product. It happens in every single industry without thorough enough anti-monopoly regulations, again and a fucking gain.

Absolutely Wrong. That's not how reality works. The government has been regulating telecommunications since the beginning, Imposing rules and regulations that must be followed that, over time, allowed the corruption of the FCC and regulations commities before it to enable a select few to become incredibly powerful using their own custom made laws to choke out the competition and form the monopolies we have today which would not have occurred if there was no regulation to begin with.

Telecommunications have never operated on a free market in the US since it's creation.

Regulations create monopolies. It allows the companies to infiltrate and take over the regulators, which is legal might I add, to pass laws that favor their businesses.

Every monopoly has occurred because of government regulation.

notFREEfood2 votes

[{quoted}](name=Demon Empress,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=000700000000,timestamp=2017-12-06T14:30:41.395+0000)

Absolutely Wrong. That's not how reality works. The government has been regulating telecommunications since the beginning, Imposing rules and regulations that must be followed that, over time, allowed the corruption of the FCC and regulations commities before it to enable a select few to become incredibly powerful using their own custom made laws to choke out the competition and form the monopolies we have today which would not have occurred if there was no regulation to begin with.

Telecommunications have never operated on a free market in the US since it's creation.

Regulations create monopolies. It allows the companies to infiltrate and take over the regulators, which is legal might I add, to pass laws that favor their businesses.

Every monopoly has occurred because of government regulation.

That's bullshit.

Monopolies are simply an efficient way of doing business.

Let's take two enterprises: a vertically integrated table store and a table store that buys its tables from a factory, which then buys its wood from a logging company.

For starters, the vertically integrated business does not need to profit at each step along the way. This means they can be more competitive with their pricing if they decide to undercut the non-integrated store. If not, well that business makes at least triple the profits of teach of the businesses in the non-integrated chain. Of course then you have to take into account administrative costs - the integrated business can centralize, meaning less duplicated positions across the entire supply chain, thus lowering costs.

A monopoly is not inherently bad. If they respect market forces and generally treat their customers well they will provide the same goods at a lower cost to consumers as a non-integrated business. The problem with monopolies is that their position makes it easy for them to abuse their power and take advantage of consumers and stifle their competition.

Of course some monopolies are inevitable - we call these natural monopolies. These companies aren't monopolies because they're efficient; they're monopolies because the barrier to entry for their market is so high it is impossible to compete without significant backing. Wired internet service is one of these areas. Infrastructure is EXPENSIVE and breaking up the monopolies and banning the franchise agreements and apartment building agreements (forgot the name for these) will do jack shit for when it comes to creating competition. The baby bell mergers didn't happen because of regulation; they happened because the mergers would make the companies more efficient. Over time the exact same thing will happen and we will be in the exact same position.

If you want true competition then you need the government to split the infrastructure from the service provider. That way the natural barrier to becoming an ISP - the cost of running infrastructure - is eliminated and ISPs could truly compete.

CLG ear7 votes
Kitsuki055 votes

have you actually heard anyone say that, or is it just an easy strawman for you to shill to Net Neutrality for?

Grundy75 votes

It's 40-50$ here in upper MI even for the lowest package, and even then they double charge you sometimes knowing full well there isn't a damn thing I can do about it. They're the only company here, it's either them or nobody. I can only imagine what these fuckers are gonna do when the gloves come off after neutrality is gone.

Teémò3 votes

They have internet cafe's for a reason... to say 20$ is nonsense. I've played in korean servers plenty of times and their lack of knowledge about the outside world is insane. The only things they know are what they're taught because their internets block them from seeing other points of view.

Destaice5 votes

{quoted}

They have internet cafe's for a reason... to say 20$ is nonsense. I've played in korean servers plenty of times and their lack of knowledge about the outside world is insane. The only things they know are what they're taught because their internets block them from seeing other points of view.

Cafes are more of a cultural thing.

And yes them having censored internet is an issue. But them having astonishingly faster speeds than us at a lower cost is ridiculous and says a lot about the quality of US ISPs.

2nd Chance3 votes

People are idiots

Nothing surprising here

NocturnalSheild2 votes

{quoted}

In South Korea the average household pays roughly equivalent to 20 USD a month for 1,000 Mbps of internet speed.

In America there are people who think a 1,000 Mbps is impossible because they're used to paying 20 dollars a month for 10 Mbps.

Also worth mentioning that many ISPs already have patents for technology that will allow them to discriminate against websites unless you pay extra.

Most trustworthy people I swear.

Isnt south korea smaller than florida?

People seem to forget america is fucking huge. And full of 10s of thousands of different regulations due to it basically be 50 different countries.

Destaice2 votes

{quoted}

Isnt south korea smaller than florida?

People seem to forget america is fucking huge. And full of 10s of thousands of different regulations due to it basically be 50 different countries.

Except that isn't how supply/demand works. The limitations of the internet are the servers required to host it and the technology used to transfer information. Both of these things are not in limited supply for ISPs. Rather ISPs intentionally choose to provide low quality services to make money.

There is no rational argument for why we have 1% of the services South Korea is offered for the same price. If they were getting something like 100mbps for the same price then maybe you'd have a case there.

The fact of the matter is you're being provided intentionally bad services and high prices because your choices of available ISPs are limited so there's no competition between the companies. You're fucked because you need internet to keep up with modern society and they know it.

IllusoryLumines1 votes

{quoted}

There is no rational argument for why we have 1% of the services South Korea is offered for the same price. If they were getting something like 100mbps for the same price then maybe you'd have a case there.

It's not exactly the same price, rent is a lot more expensive in SK just because it costs more to dig up and rebuild streets or houses to put wires in them. Rent is still not more expensive in raw terms than the USA just cuz it's a poorer country but still, it factors in.

notice me Sin pi2 votes

internet in KR is cheap cuz land is so much more tiny than NA. We even have ISPs going monopoly in some regions within NA. KR ISPs have to compete against 10+ other ISPs in that tiny land, so demand vs supply curve actually applies there. Not to mention laying cables n stuff also costs less in KR cuz the ISPs dont have to do it over large area like NA.

SciFi Scrivener2 votes

"I trust Donald Trump and the US congress to control content on the internet, so I support Net Neutrality" - ya, count me out of that one.

AMYS GRAVE2 votes

In America there are people who think a 1,000 Mbps is impossible because they're used to paying 20 dollars a month for 10 Mbps.

Where can you get internet in the US for $20/month at any speeds? The cheapest internet around me is $75/month for 40 Mbps.

EDIT: Boulder CO area btw

CLG ear2 votes

the government literally gave all the ISPs millions of dollars to improve our internet infrastructure

and the ISPs used it for wireless

the FCC said it was ok though

blackrose782 votes

[{quoted}](name=CLG ear,realm=NA,application-id=yrc23zHg,discussion-id=0WuFbYWJ,comment-id=0014,timestamp=2017-12-05T19:04:58.002+0000)

the government literally gave all the ISPs millions of dollars to improve our internet infrastructure

and the ISPs used it for wireless

the FCC said it was ok though

I'm not sure you understand your own line of reasoning. You're saying ISPs pay off politicians to avoid competition and improve wireless instead of infrastructure. But all of that would have been happening under net neutrality already, so how does keeping it fix the problem exactly?

Just Jangle1 votes

{quoted}

In South Korea the average household pays roughly equivalent to 20 USD a month for 1,000 Mbps of internet speed.

This is a complete lie.

Akali is SO HOT1 votes

Can I sue Comcast for being a bully?

GlobDaBlob1 votes

So your point is that net neutrality doesn't do anything anyway

AHeroNamedHawke1 votes

Net Neutrality is basically a strawman at this point.

Actually proving your ISP is doing anything to your connection on purpose is nearly impossible, hence why there have been so few cases. Even up here in the frozen north, 2 companies basically control the entire market, and you have to fork up $100 a month to hit 150mbs.

Except you don't hit 150mbs, and they don't have to do anything about it. Thanks to shitty infrastructure they can't be fucked to improve, I will almost always get a whole 4-6 mb/s when downloading, get choppy connections when I try to play Street Fighter and even have videos struggle to buffer. Even right now the video I have open in another tab can't keep up. No one else is awake right now, I have 1 program utilizing a network connection.

I'd be more up in arms about this sort of thing if there was literally any potential to hold companies responsible, or entice them to make improvements to their technology.

More from General Discussion

More by Destaice