Why is there not going to be an option to use the current hud over the new one?

Kanade·7/11/2015, 8:02:00 PM·71 votes·11,854 views

I was recently informed that a Rioter confirmed on reddit that there won't be an option to stick with the current hud once the new one rolls out. I understand that the majority of people seem to like it, but is there really something wrong with leaving the option there for those who don't? I find the new hud to be basically unplayable with compared to the current one, even after being exposed to it many times over. The change actually makes the game much more difficult to read and play for me. Odds are, I won't be playing much if at all once that patch comes in. I honestly don't understand why something this important doesn't have an option to stay the same. Can anyone give me some insight on why they decided not to give us the choice on this?

81 Comments

mythologia7/11/2015, 8:07:20 PM31 votes

Honestly I don't really like the over-simplistic look they're going for, and having played this game for so long, not once have I thought: "Hey this hud is really getting my way and I find it really hard to find what I'm looking for." I'm sure there are many other players that think this way as well, and for those players, implementing the old hud as an option would be nice.

TeemoJenkins7/11/2015, 8:08:01 PM12 votes

Very simple reason why not: They'd have to continue updating two HUD's... twice the programming to what end? Make a minority of users happy at a larger cost.

RiotRyedan7/12/2015, 9:29:43 PM5 votes

[{quoted}](name=Tail Silver,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=zhI5bE5N,comment-id=,timestamp=2015-07-11T20:02:00.960+0000)

I was recently informed that a Rioter confirmed on reddit that there won't be an option to stick with the current hud once the new one rolls out. I understand that the majority of people seem to like it, but is there really something wrong with leaving the option there for those who don't? I find the new hud to be basically unplayable with compared to the current one, even after being exposed to it many times over. The change actually makes the game much more difficult to read and play for me. Odds are, I won't be playing much if at all once that patch comes in. I honestly don't understand why something this important doesn't have an option to stay the same. Can anyone give me some insight on why they decided not to give us the choice on this?

[I'm a visual designer, not working on the HUD though]

Usually, the default response is "Give it time, you'll get used to it," but I think that's a little curt. I know it's frustrating to have to learn a new HUD layout. It sucks to change where you look, where you click etc. and telling someone to "deal with it" isn't exactly courteous or productive.

I will instead ask - What don't you like about the new HUD?**

** (WITHOUT using the reason of "It's different" or "I don't want to get used to it")

These reasons are perfectly acceptable reasons for not liking the new HUD, but unfortunately it's something we need to get past in order to get to the core usability issues. If you can clearly articulate what you don't like, then it's feedback we can use.

To be specific to your concerns, what makes the HUD "more difficult to read and play for me"? When you drill down and answers those questions, it's feedback we can use, process, and weigh against other people's feedback.

An example of SPECIFIC feedback might be: "As a person who loves to play mid lane, the concentration of UI elements in the bottom right makes me feel more vulnerable to jungle ganks on that side." or something like that. This feedback is self contained and does not rely on comparing it to the old HUD. It's feedback we can use against other contradictory feedback (such as "My bot lane partner and I love that the top HUD leaves plenty of space to watch for jungle activity!")

Nsqui7/11/2015, 10:20:15 PM5 votes

I completely agree with this. While I will most likely become accustomed to the new HUD once it is released (I have been using it on PBE, but not frequently enough to get used to it) that does not mean I will like it. The old HUD, while perhaps clunky and a bad usage of screen space, is a functional HUD that I have been using for ages. I like my CS and team score in the top right. I liked my items on the left, and I liked being able to see my champion stats in a larger box. The new HUD looks like Vain Glory or some similar mobile MOBA. Don't know why the old one even needs this much of an overhaul - just touch up the small things (such a re-arranging the scoreboard). Gonna be a rough patch, guys.

MohawkBird7/11/2015, 8:25:42 PM5 votes

[deleted]

Ximlee7/12/2015, 3:47:49 AM4 votes

If it isn't broken.. Why would you throw it away and remake it?

LaceUp237/12/2015, 9:29:34 PM3 votes

Simple reason, rito cares about what they like, not about what the players like.

Zenthon Prime7/11/2015, 10:59:53 PM3 votes

My only real problem with the new HUD is the location of the inventory, but it's the same as Dota so I'll get used to it pretty quicky.

Infiny Mage7/11/2015, 11:45:40 PM3 votes

Everything's getting smaller these days -_- my eyes ain't what they used to be.