Sion: The New Darius
Overview: Maybe I'm bad and I should feel bad, but I feel that Sion is very weak right now. I'm a jungler that loves to play Kha'Zix and Gragas jungle, and after having fantastic success with these two (who play very differently) it seems that Sion is really, REALLY weak. I recently tried him and there was a general feeling I was having: Sion's strengths don't get better the more skill you have, but get better with the less skill the opponent has.
Contrast: I am contrasting him with both Kha'Zix and Gragas because they are FANTASTIC playmakers that get way better with skill. Kha can assassinate and Gragas can...well, do a lot of things (pick, siege, protect, initiate, disengage, flexible build path).
Issues: Sion has a couple issues that hinder him: Q is very hard to land even if you charge for only a second (good luck against escapes!), shield is useless for damage and the tankiness doesn't matter because the rest of his kit is pretty terrible (elaborated below), E does fairly low damage and hard to get off on high-priority targets, R is easy to dodge (escapes make me a sad panda), and his passive is easily kiteable but eats up a lot of power budget because he murders things IF HE CAN ACTUALLY GET TO THEM.
Easily Telegraphed: The biggest problem is he is completely telegraphed. A lot of power in his kit is in both his Q, ultimate, and passive. Q is VERY hard to hit, even if you only charge for a second and it feels really negligible before that. His ultimate not only lets out a roar that signals he is initiating, but ultimately is extremely hard to land especially against escapes. Literally the only time it felt good to use was when you are in the middle of a teamfights and want to stun people around you. In other words, if the opponent is too stupid to move out of the way of his Q or somehow cannot dodge his ult OR just sits around and lets you auto them in your passive then you win. If they actually know how to use escapes or walk sideways, they win.
Tl;dr- He is too telegraphed, which means if the opponents are not skilled you hit them and do incredible amounts of damage, or they are skilled and use their escapes/sidestep you and win easily. In this sense, Sion doesn't really get better the more skill you have but the less skill the opponents have.
If you can, please prove me wrong: I love PvE with him but PvP feels clunky and unrewarding (but he could be so much fun...).
.