Counterplay VS Counterpick
Yesterday I had a jungle Ekko tell me that I lost lane because I counterpicked myself against a Trundle as Garen. Keep in mind, this is B4 Flex, so I'm mostly playing what I know and to have fun. I know exactly why I lost, and it wasn't counterpick. I lost lane because I was counterplayed. I had several bad engages and several bad plays. I cleaned up my act and mustered a little comeback for myself, but it was too late, our boy lane had lost, and the enemy Ahri has gotten fed off it.
Turn around next game against a top lane Ekko and I absolutely crushed him due to an early gank and subsequent kills on him that shut him down hard.
Point being that counterplay>counterpick. I've been shut down by Ekkos that played much better than the last one I faced, and I've won against Trundles just as skilled as the last one I faced.