Skip to content

I believe that you should get punished for playing bad.

PonTacôs··5 votes·1,386 views

Just realised the title sounds like i want to get players banned or something for playing bad but that's not the case.

I have never understood the concept behind some abiltities/passives or even items in this game.

Passives. Take KogMaw passive as an example, in a lot of cases the battles of who's dying and who's not in the botlane are very close so let's say that you're playing Kog'Maw and dies to their Lucian which survives with 15-20% hp but then you kill him with your passive. at this state you already failed because you died first, so why would you still get rewarded for dying (playing bad).

Aatrox ,Anivia and Zac has wierd passives aswell. you die = playing bad but still you can get away with it without giving the enemy anything, Aatrox is probably worst since you cant kill his "passive form" i'm not saying it makes them broken or OP champions i'm just saying that it's a unfair ingame mechanic to have.

Abiltities. Tryndamere and Kayle have similar ultimates. the thing is without this sort of ultimate both of them would be pretty much useless champions but that doesn't keep them from being unfair, you "kill" tryndamere but he ults so at this moment he basicly already lost his hp bar because he played bad most likely, but still get's a few extra seconds to kill you and if he does he survives. Same thing goes for Kayle which can be worse since she can use it on allies, so let's say the enemy team got a really fed adc that just destroys your team in matter of seconds if you dont get rid of him/her. So your teams Zed goes for the adc which gets ulted by kayle cant die and this is legit unoutplayable, it's completely impossible for the Zed to win at this point which is unfair aswell since it gives their adc the opportunity to not have to care at all about being cautious and becomes allowed to make huge mistakes without getting punished for it. And yes, Tryndamere and Kayle would most likely be useless even if they got new updated ultis because the ones they have are needed for their kit, but this is why they shouldn't have gotten their abilities from the whole beginning they shouldn't have been made from the start. they would need complete reworks to actually be relevant.

Irelia is the only champion that i have in mind that have this type of passive to her ability and this triggers me everytime i face irelia in toplane. It is her E the only thing i can think off when i read this """ACTIVE: Irelia pierces the target enemy, dealing them magic damage and slowing them by 60% for a short duration. IF HER CURRENT HEALTH IS EQUAL TO OR LESS THAN HER TARGET'S SHE STUNS THEM INSTEAD.""" is that if you're playing bad and losing trades against your lane opponent you will get the upperhand next time because you will stun them. I mean, i would litterly feel better about this ability if it stunned me everytime she used E.

Finally we're here

Item.(s)

item 3026 So guardian angel, the item that let's you die just to get back to life. some people might argue that this is a fair item since everyone can buy it. But let's say you're in the losing team and then suddenly their adc and toplaner appears with an guardian angel at this point you almost have to kill 7 enemies, and the game is next to impossible to win because of this item that let's them make a mistake but still get away with it.

This was all from me this time, might come back and cry some more next year. would be fun to see if someone agrees or disagrees with me so leave a comment summoner 6

28 Comments

Dorans Shuriken2 votes

[slayer-pantheon-popcorn]

Mecha MaIphite2 votes

Death passives do not necessarily reward you for dying, nor does abusing a death passive make you "bad" because you died.

Anivia, Aatrox, Zac, Guardian Angel, these do not reward you for dying. They're just a safety net that goes away after one death. Logically, you'd want to keep that net, so you still have a strong incentive to stay alive.

Karthus or Sion passive arguably do reward you for dying, in very specific circumstances. However, this doesn't mean it rewards bad play; a Sion or a Karthus dying at an inopportune moment could make their passives useless. However, a good Karthus or Sion will understand how to use the death passive, and perhaps die in the middle of the enemy team, to make full use of them. This is not bad play. If anything, these death passives add another element of strategy to a champion.

As for Irelia's E . . . okay, she can go fuck herself.

PonTacôs1 votes

i never said that anivia,aatrox,zac passives gives you any reward, i'm just saying that if you're dying in the first place you should be dead, not get a second chance to stay alive and not give up anything (except the passive cooldown). thanks for the reply though! and damn i missed to bring up sion and karthus, brainfreeze when you're trying to come up with everyone that has that sort of passive.

Tenth Leper2 votes

I can kind of sort of barely understand in the case of kogmaw/sion/karthus (though you aught to account for their retribution damage beforehand or once you were low enough the passive was going to kill you if you killed them YOU had lost) but in the other cases this is simply a matter of you being baited.

Particularly you pointed out kyle ult allowing adcs to "make huge mistakes", but assuming (and it is not always the case) the adc was planning on/reacting to the invulnerability better than your team then the daring moves are not huge mistakes at all but the appropriate response. The huge mistake would be failure to take advantage of the damage immunity by playing the same as you would without it.

zrWQMdGHtY1 votes

You should get banned for suggesting that people should get banned... Why? Cuz why not?

Mecha MaIphite4 votes

Uh, the post is talking about mechanics that reward people for "playing badly", like Irelia stun, not actually punishing people with bans.

zrWQMdGHtY1 votes

My opinion still stands, there's tons of people who suggest that you should be banned for playing bad. ^^ And if what you're saying is true, then why is Katarina getting reworked and not Irelia insteaD? :>

Mecha MaIphite1 votes

My opinion still stands, there's tons of people who suggest that you should be banned for playing bad.

But that isn't relevant here, because he isn't one of those people.

And if what you're saying is true, then why is Katarina getting reworked and not Irelia insteaD? :>

First of all, I'm not saying this, I'm just reiterating what he said (although I do kind of hate Irelia's stun). And Kat's rework is coming first because although Irelia is bland, boring, and has a stupid mechanic that rewards her way too much for losing trades, she isn't so broken/useless that she needs an immediate rework.

zrWQMdGHtY1 votes

If kata is broken/useless then you're playing her wrong... Plus his title is 100% reffering to what I commented, I comment the title not the text. maybe you should consider thinking on that point :p A book is as good as the title, if the title is bad, no point to read the rest.

100% tested. MY tale has a bad title and nobody reads it :p

Mecha MaIphite1 votes

No, you don't have to be broken or useless to get reworked. That isn't my point; I'm saying that's the reason Irelia isn't being reworked immediately. She's probably going to get tweaked when they move on to divers.

And yes, while I agree the title is misleading, it doesn't constitute the entire post. You're just arguing against a strawman.

zrWQMdGHtY1 votes

I dont know who's strawman, but title is title. I dont argue, I just state. If you dont like my statement aint my problem. Have a good evening.

EndlessSorcerer1 votes

That would be because this is the assassin update.

Irelia will probably be changed in the diver update.

zrWQMdGHtY1 votes

I don't see what kind of a diver she is, if she can kill an ADC/mage/assassin than any assasin, I think her role is a bit missunderstood. She's bascially an assassin, with sustain and tankiness.. ^^

SithesisLord1 votes

She is a diver. Because assassins can´t go head first into the frontline just to get to the backline. Assassins actually have to flank, be unexpected. Irelia doesn´t even need to be unexpected. And she does have less than assassin levels of damage, much like Diana, which is also a diver.

Just forget about Riot's old classifications. The new class/subclass system is way better, way more accurate and here to stay.

zrWQMdGHtY1 votes

I'm sure Q E basic attack (literally) is less level of damage... and later R R R R, to kill 2 champions in less than 2 secs... Definitly not the same as an assassin, but tanky... and I'm sure Ekko, Fizz or Zed need much positioning and don't just go frontline killing half the enemy team and running back safe, simply because the lack of tankiness Irelia has...

Or and DIana? Def, lower damage than an assassin... One thing douh... Why does Kat for example need full combo + ult to drop an enemy to 10% HP while Diana is just ... Q R R dead... Def not assassin like to OS the enemy just no reason with no items...

SithesisLord1 votes

I'm sure Q E basic attack (literally) is less level of damage... and later R R R R, to kill 2 champions in less than 2 secs... Definitly not the same as an assassin

Unsure if salty, bad or just exaggerating.

Or and DIana? Def, lower damage than an assassin... One thing douh... Why does Kat for example need full combo + ult to drop an enemy to 10% HP while Diana is just ... Q R R dead

The holy trinity, it seems.

Irelia actually has to time her ult right in order to get TriForce spellblade procs right and thus, actually kill a squishy. Her Q is only a high damage ability after she gets TriForce and maxes it. Yes, when she does both, not one or the other.

Kat is a cleanup assassin. As a "main", you should know that.

And Diana is indeed a diver. As is Irelia. Once they jump in, they can´t jump out. Diana needs to spellweave her Q between ult to properly get resets. Irelia needs low HP minions to reset her Q. The maximum level of skill Katarina needs is a stockpile of replacement Q, W, E, R keys.

They aren´t assassins. They can´t even be played as such because their kits just don´t scream assassin to anyone who actually plays them long enough. Diana has a refreshable shield and a pull-in, Irelia has a gap-closer and a stun. Now, if they tower dive someone, how can they escape without a risk of burning flash?

Kat can just shunpo to the nearest minion or ward. Diana can´t do that. Neither can Irelia. They´re supposed to jump into your backline, kill them and stick around to deal with the tanks, not pussy out, that´s why they have forms of sustain. Irelia with tenacity, the ability to build bruiser-ish after a single damage item and heal. And Diana with her refreshable shield.

Please, stop making Kat look like a champion harder than either of those two. You´re only embarrassing yourself. Post-rework, she might become actually harder to play. But until then she's still the 'smash head on keyboard for pentakill' champion we all love to meme about and i love leaving 0/10 by 15 minutes every time i play either Kayle or Diana.

zrWQMdGHtY1 votes

She is harder "kata just shunpoes" with her 11 seconds shunpo CD... as we all well know, while Irelia has 3 sec CD even if she doesn't kill with her Q... cheers... Diana hardly has a CD on her R anyway, or Q in that matter and has AOE slow CC and don't forget a shielda nd she can basically delete anyone in 1-2 hits and yes, I'm bad... 10/0 Kata, attacked by 0/6 irelia, Irelia clicks Q E, for the time I get out of her stun I'm dead... Because her "W" doesn't give her tons of true dmg per hit...

Not sure if you got an idea how either of the 3 works but kay...

And you meme, because of her 2-3 year sago state, where her ult had double the dmg and she had half the CDs... so quit acting amazing... You got no idea how to play Diana even if you cant OS anyone with her...

SithesisLord1 votes

I know how Diana and Irelia works. And in order to one shot people they need a lot of items. Diana especially. She can´t one shot or heck, even 4-shot someone with just double Doran's. Irelia can´t one-shot people with just Corrupting Potion. And she can´t kill people as effectively being 0/6 unless you can´t keep her irrelevant and let her farm up to the point those deaths won´t matter anymore.

If you get caught by Irelia, that´s your own fault. And your team's for not doing anything. Irelia and Diana can´t delete anyone in a short amount of hits unless people just stand still and let them do it. Irelia will never engage with Q unless she can do it onto a minion to get the reset, stun you and then Q after her enemy's HP is low enough a single Q will kill them.

Diana only can kill someone quick enough if her R-Q combo is perfectly executed. Otherwise, it´ll take a while longer, which still makes them Divers, not Assassins, because they actually need to stay in the brunt of the fight. It´s why Diana's passive can´t be applied to her abilities, only her AAs. After she blows all her CDs, she has to stay and fight.

zrWQMdGHtY1 votes

Diana needs rod, Irelia needs trinity... Don't make jests, I went 0/10 Diana my first time, after I got rod I ended 12/10 because I was OSing ppl with 2-3 items more than me... Irelia is literally the same...

PonTacôs2 votes

Wow the title actually worked as a clickbait^^

zrWQMdGHtY1 votes

wow you actually expect me to spent time reading all you said...

PonTacôs1 votes

No, but at least the first row where i mention that people will see the title as it says.

zrWQMdGHtY1 votes

You literally just added it :)))) Just cuz i act stupid doesnt mean I didnt read it and I wont notice the edit.

Brutalitops011 votes

Irelia's E is her outplay mechanic. It means that, unless you've already traded with her and you came out on top, she can't use her Q to dash to you because it will make her E no longer stun. It doesn't reward bad play, it allows her to outplay and punish her opponent's mistakes a lot better. Go and watch some Gbay99 on YouTube, you'll see what I'm talking about. It isn't inherently a bad or toxic mechanic, it's an outplay tool, no different from Yasuo's Wind Wall or Zed being able to swap places with his shadows. Here, go watch this video by Jeremy with Gbay there talking about the likely changes in a future rework for Irelia. Gbay talks a lot about how Irelia's Q is the best-designed ability on her kit, giving her some outplay stuff with the resets if it kills the enemy. The W, E, R, and passive all have some design problems.

AdeBug1 votes

About kog, that is his passive, if you replace that passive with another one, then it prolly wouldn't be the case of them dying first. But imagine the jg and support are there too and low, it could turn into a triple. Dying first doesn't mean anything if you trade 1 for 1, with ignite or deathfire or some other shit. It's called a fair trade.

Same for the others, replacing their passives or ultimates would make em stronger in other areas, weaker in some. It's just what they are atm, part of their kit. If u think something is unfair or OP, try playing it, see their shortcomings (1 being you can mistime trynd's and Kayle's ult, btw; it's about making choices), maybe learn to appreciate those champs more after seeing they're not as easy as they look. And if they are, by all means main them and go pro.

And once those passives are down, they are forced to play safe cus they're vulnerable, so you're free to engage.

Chalizard1 votes

Irelia is actually great example but rest of them are questionable imo. Anyway nice Point.

SithesisLord1 votes

And yes, Tryndamere and Kayle would most likely be useless even if they got new updated ultis because the ones they have are needed for their kit, but this is why they shouldn't have gotten their abilities from the whole beginning they shouldn't have been made from the start. they would need complete reworks to actually be relevant.

Come to think of it, if Riot actually went for gameplay/thematic balance in Kayle's rework, her ult would most definitely stay, otherwise, it would bring along massive buffs, if their intention is to keep her as a solo lane marksman like Quinn, of course.

More from Gameplay

More by PonTacôs