I play Soraka mid and top since Season 6. Last 2 seasons, the oneshot&snowball seasons, toplane is the worst lane to play her. Or rather than worst the most difficult. I was queving mid lately and tried to swap if I got top because even if you manage to kill enemy AD fighter early, once they finish
or in some cases
you are done. The lane is now own by them and you can only try to lose gracefully. Even 0/6 Jax because he is stupid af and thinks he can fight me when I have barrier advantage (always play with barrier because Soraka cannot prevent the engage unlike other supports) and then dives me 5 times will just be able to kill me under tower once he get his one or in worst case two item powerspike.
Fighters/Bruisers are absolutely unbeatable 1v1 with any Mage-Support or Mage in general. Assuming they play their champion correctly. And when they play the lane correctly and make it perma 2v1 with their jungler you can't even cs. Just losing flash with Soraka means she canot cs at all if the lane is frozen and jungler is not spotted - which in diamond elo where I play that is the case almost every single game.
Soraka top works basically only against marksmen (Vayne, Quinn), juggernauts if you play it perfectly or enemy plays it poorly (Aatrox, Garen, Morde,Darius,Urgot,Yorick) and against so-called-tanks. But in soloQ for past 2 years except Aatrox and Darius, who is still very popular pick (and that matchup is heavily influenced by his rune/summoner choice and experience playing against ranged - playing against Phase Rush/Ghost/boot rush Darius who knows what he is doing is extremely hard) it was always Irelia, Fiora, Jax, Yasuo, Akali, Kennen, Ekko, Sylas and recently Diana. At least against AP bruisers there are items you can build that still makes you usefull and actually help survive. Versus AD fighters/bruisers no matter how much armor I buy I always get bursted in seconds. No counterplay.
Especially Phage is extremely broken item that if you know how to use it counters immobile ranged champions in toplane.
and still got outran by basic boots Darius after he procced Phage and flashed over my Q to avoid slow.
I don't exactly know what is happening in pro play recently, but I suspect Soraka top is viable there because:
- her ultimate is actually usefull in pro play environment where players communicate perfectly (not that much in soloQ)
- relatively easy matchups are played against her - juggernauts, tanks or AP champions (the hardest matchups aren't played in pro play and they won't start picking those champions who can destroy Soraka just because Soraka is picked especially if they are not the current annalysts-said-you-must-pick-this-so-you-instalock-it-if-it-is-not-banned champions)
- better knowledge about enemy jungler position
- the fact that players rarely fight 1v1 in pro play and that every engage becomes 3+v3+ due to teleports and globals there is also a difference of how they play the lane, in pro play they don't bully/dive you under tower they actually let you farm and instead they use that to roam/put vision/recall.
you don't get these conditions in soloQ and thus if you want to play Soraka outside of support, for whatever reason (I am troll myself so the reason is simple for me), then better pick midlane.