Skip to content

DoTs can feel impactful if you show how much damage they WILL do as soon as they hit

Hyrum Graff··825 votes·85,850 views

Riot has basically said they don't like DoTs because they lack clarity:

  • As the caster, it's hard to appreciate how much damage they do.
  • When hit by one, it's hard to tell how much damage it's going to do.

Both of these are NOT problems with DoT, they're problems with how we show DoT in game.

#The real problem is there is no visual indicator of how much TOTAL damage a DoT will do.

There's a really simple solution. When you get hit by a DoT, your health bar immediately shows how much damage you WILL take in a different color (kind of like Tahm's grey health shows how much shield you WILL get). Then this hp ticks down while the DoT runs. Here's a really quick mockup:

http://i.imgur.com/Tz9HvyU.png

######I know this particular example might not work well for color-blind people, but we can change the colors in color-blind mode.

2015.6.17 Edit

Since some people have been discussing things like "What if they get shielded during the DoT?", here's an alternative design that works better with shields:

http://i.imgur.com/yNghdzP.png

http://i.imgur.com/BfaHbXA.png

2016.07.03 Edit in Response to Riot Reinboom

[{quoted}](name=Riot Reinboom,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=i2xERtsd,comment-id=003b,timestamp=2015-09-15T04:40:20.853+0000)

I like these types of clarity gains. :3

I experimented with something akin to this (in a few different iterations) earlier in the year for different effects. We ran into some problems with it, namely along the lines of it feeling really bad when it was wrong. We have a lot of small adjustments that can make damage prediction not be accurate. Examples: Resistances can change a lot (like going in and out of Abyssal Range). This was especially bad when the dot types were mixed (e.g. true damage and magic damage). Penetration isn't consistent. It looked REALLY weird when interacting with shields.

-snip-

Getting accurate prediction is just a hurdle though. So this isn't a "we won't do it", but more like it was uniquely difficult enough that we just focused on something else for the time being.

Here's an idea that I believe addresses these concerns:

On hit:

https://i.imgur.com/LWyzkB9.png

As the DoT ticks down:

http://i.imgur.com/rfWO6RR.png

This solves the "prediction is inaccurate" problem in a different way. Instead of making prediction more accurate, it makes the display less precise. Take this example:

http://i.imgur.com/e5MMZKE.png

Is Kat going to die, or live with a sliver of health left afterwards?

She's going to live. There's 1 pixel of health bar left at the end.

Prediction doesn't need to be perfect; it just needs to be as good as the way you display that information. And perfect information is not needed to make DoTs feel impactful.

2017-10-27 edit

A strict wedge might make it hard to see shields if there's a long-running DoT. You could mitigate this by colorizing the top part, instead, or aligning the bottom of the wedge to 1/4 of the way up the hp bar, instead of all the way at the bottom.

356 Comments

ScreamPaste187 votes

This is a really good idea. +1

Prospector Pete34 votes

But it can give people heart attacks. Just imagine stepping on a Teemo shroom and having your entire bar of health turn orange.

Toa Innodence63 votes

heart attack? no. spiraling depression that leads to alcohol and substance abuse? I can see that.

honestly, I would think not knowing how much life you'll be left with would make you crap yourself a lot more.

Vonspooker34 votes

A diagnosis of Stage 4 Teemo shroom.

AutoreactiveCD42 votes

So league is responsible for more than just my lack of social skills? That actually makes sense.

Toa Innodence2 votes

I'm no expert, but it's a possibility.

DeadPuddle6 votes

Pretty sure I'd like to know if it would kill me though, I can then back out and take pots, try lifesteal or a teammate could heal me.

At the very least I can pray

RiotRiot Reinboom144 votes

I like these types of clarity gains. :3

I experimented with something akin to this (in a few different iterations) earlier in the year for different effects. We ran into some problems with it, namely along the lines of it feeling really bad when it was wrong. We have a lot of small adjustments that can make damage prediction not be accurate. Examples: Resistances can change a lot (like going in and out of Abyssal Range). This was especially bad when the dot types were mixed (e.g. true damage and magic damage). Penetration isn't consistent. It looked REALLY weird when interacting with shields.

HotS does have a cool way of showing it. I also like Bloodborne's transparent health. Unfortunately, the damage model of these games is much simpler and thus could get away with something in a very "honest" way.

Getting accurate prediction is just a hurdle though. So this isn't a "we won't do it", but more like it was uniquely difficult enough that we just focused on something else for the time being.

Stars Shaper3 votes

Doesn't Tahm Kench have a similar mechanic for his "Grey Health"? You might start from there.

DeadPuddle6 votes

Couldn't you rework DoT into its own unique slot of damage and have it be unaffected by these changes?

Simply put, the damage you apply on activating the DoT ability is fixed (the damage it does is calculated on activation and the formula for damage per second vs defences is fixed). I know this is kinda cheating and almost all DoT abilities would have to be reworked to balance it but it would certainly fix the issue.

Penns20 votes

I think Im the only one that doesnt think this is needed at all. Like, it would probably just create more clarity issues than it would get rid of (because of shields, prediction changes, heals, etc) :s Also it would look pretty weird with Tahms E passive lol.

7ha7guy77749 votes

I can just imagine people freaking out when their entire health bar turns orange when they step in Malzahar's pool late-game

Hyrum Graff39 votes

{quoted}

I can just imagine people freaking out when their entire health bar turns orange when they step in Malzahar's pool late-game

For the purposes of this effect, I wouldn't consider that a DoT. Because you can walk out of it, it would make the indicator inaccurate / confusing.

I mean, maybe it wouldn't but I'd tend to err on the side of caution, and we can always add it in later.

7ha7guy77735 votes

It would probably make more sense on unavoidable DoTs like his E or Brand's passive

Hyrum Graff19 votes

{quoted}

It would probably make more sense on unavoidable DoTs like his E or Brand's passive

Agreed.

D2Vincent1 votes

What about Karthus E?

Hyrum Graff3 votes

{quoted}

What about Karthus E?

It it's a spell that does a variable amount of damage (ie, based on how long you stand in it), so you have no way of knowing how much damage it will do, total. Therefore, it would not appear as orange. Maybe you could make the next tick only appear in orange.

Axxuka30 votes

Shhhhhhhhhhhhht I don'T want my enemy to see how hard they will fail duel'ing my swain.

Dramos2 votes

Not only your bird is hungry. With that said: #Not so looouuud!#

EDIT: Dammit. How are you editing your text in size? EDIT 2: :/

Stephenizgod4 votes

#something like this?

######or something like this?

You use this #

Count Lieberkuhn18 votes

Heroes of the Storm does this, and it's quite nice to see.

Mimy8 votes

OMG PLEASE!!! I need to know if my basic attack will kill someone.. Teemo

hahahah... xD (Bring on the hate)

AVL Prince6 votes

It's a great idea but there are some issues with it, namely being A: what if my resists change mid DoT, and B: will this visually impact my gameplay?

First off, the damage a DoT deals over time changes per tick. If I throw a malzahar E on you and you gain 100 armor and Mr halfway through, each tick will start doing half damage effectively quartering the damage. Will this cause the bar to change? Will it be fluctuating a lot if I'm someone like wukong and my resists are constantly changing depending on where I am in the teamfight? This leads on to my second point:

Will this health be detrimental to my gameplay? I definitely don't want this health fluctuating back and forth all the time because of my changing resists. What of it tells me I'm going to die and I give up but because of my health regen I actually don't die and end up okay? But then die because I thought I was going to die, see what I mean? If I use a shield, where will that go? Before or after this grey health? What color is it? If I throw a shield and get dotted will my health bar be a rainbow?

These are just things to consider. I love the idea though 10/10

Hyrum Graff3 votes

[{quoted}](name=Prince Rivera,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=i2xERtsd,comment-id=000c,timestamp=2015-09-14T17:21:28.109+0000)

It's a great idea but there are some issues with it, namely being A: what if my resists change mid DoT

First off, the damage a DoT deals over time changes per tick. If I throw a malzahar E on you and you gain 100 armor and Mr halfway through, each tick will start doing half damage effectively quartering the damage. Will this cause the bar to change? Will it be fluctuating a lot if I'm someone like wukong and my resists are constantly changing depending on where I am in the teamfight? This leads on to my second point:

I imagine the size of the orange bar will change.

B: will this visually impact my gameplay?

Will this health be detrimental to my gameplay? I definitely don't want this health fluctuating back and forth all the time because of my changing resists.

I imagine it would fluctuate. Might want to put a limit on how often it can change (twice per second?) though. And remember, your total hp is not fluctuating. Your total green+Orange hp still shows the same amount of health that your current green hp shows, so it's not like your hp bar is moving all over the place.

What of it tells me I'm going to die and I give up but because of my health regen I actually don't die and end up okay? But then die because I thought I was going to die, see what I mean?

I see what you mean. In this particular case, I think that:

  1. It's your own fault for giving up.
  2. It's still more information than you had before the change.

I feel like it's more frustrating for me to do everything I can to not die (particularly, blowing a flash), and then die anyway, than to die because I gave up. In the second scenario, at least I feel like, "guess I shouldn't have given up, then." In the first, I feel like it's the game's fault, not mine.

If I use a shield, where will that go? Before or after this grey health? What color is it? If I throw a shield and get dotted will my health bar be a rainbow?

It goes at the end of your hp bar. Then the orange shading is updated. If the DoT would not break through your shield, it is not visible. If it would, the amount it will do after eating through all the shield (it does not consider the fact that the shield might time out) will be orange on your hp bar.

These are just things to consider. I love the idea though 10/10

Yeah, there are definitely a lot of edge cases to consider. I still think it's worth implementing because worst case scenario you can always just ignore the colors on your hp bar and now it works the exact same way as before.

DeusVult6 votes

This would be a terrible, horrible, game ending nerf to Singed, as people chasing him would know when they are taking too much damage

I like when people chase me to their doom

IcyPepper5 votes

DoT before: "Am I going to die?! No? Whatever."

DoT after: "OH SHIT I'M GOING TO DIE WHAT DO I DO?!"

I would enjoy the latter. People would respect the poison champions more, and fear them.

Hyrum Graff3 votes

{quoted}

DoT before: "Am I going to die?! No? Whatever."

DoT after: "OH SHIT I'M GOING TO DIE WHAT DO I DO?!"

I would enjoy the latter.

As someone who doesn't play much of poison champs, I would absolutely enjoy the latter as well. No more guessing games about whether I'm going to win a trade or not.

People would respect the poison champions more, and fear them.

Yeah. Hopefully kind of like the feeling when there's a Zilean bomb on your head.

BakedLotion5 votes

So you want to add more counterplay to an already weak system? DoT's aren't powerful at all since they were all gutted, or were never strong in the first place. Just think about ass' or Brand's DoTs. They already suck. Now you want people to know if its going to kill them or not? "oh its not gonna kill me, not gonna use heal"

Hyrum Graff2 votes

{quoted}

So you want to add more counterplay to an already weak system? DoT's aren't powerful at all since they were all gutted, or were never strong in the first place.

I'm not sure I agree they were gutted. I think they feel weak because it's hard to see how much damage they actually do (more than you think).

But let's say for a minute they actually are gutted. That's because Riot doesn't like them, because they lack clarity. This change adds clarity, so maybe Riot would buff them.

Just think about Cass' or Brand's DoTs. They already suck. Now you want people to know if its going to kill them or not? "oh its not gonna kill me, not gonna use heal"

Yes, I do. For every time that I don't have to use heal because I know the DoT isn't going to kill me, the DoT champ will know to aa one more time because it won't kill me. This change is not a nerf to anyone, and is only a buff to clarity.

BakedLotion3 votes

[{quoted}](name=Hyrum Graff,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=i2xERtsd,comment-id=00200000,timestamp=2015-09-14T21:50:11.017+0000)

I'm not sure I agree they were gutted. I think they feel weak because it's hard to see how much damage they actually do (more than you think).

But let's say for a minute they actually are gutted. That's because Riot doesn't like them, because they lack clarity. This change adds clarity, so maybe Riot would buff them.

Yes, I do. For every time that I don't have to use heal because I know the DoT isn't going to kill me, the DoT champ will know to aa one more time because it won't kill me. This change is not a nerf to anyone, and is only a buff to clarity.

Feel weak? I know how to read tooltips. Riot doesn't like them because they don't look like they have any impact. They want results for their lcsbigplays IMMEDIATELY. If a Zed throws something at you, they want it to do damage so their audience goes OOOOOO. No one sees a DoT says "OH MY GOD ITS GOING TO KILL THEM!!" Riot wants them to say "OH THE SHURIKEN HIT AND KILLED HIM!"

Now on to the actual weak DoT's (almost all of them)

Liandrys barely does damage. I can use it on a tank and it'll only do like 30 damage per second. And that's at their max hp. 8% max hp over 4 seconds is okay i guess, since its just a passive. (Brand) Nid's traps. They do almost no damage. Cait's traps. Again, no damage. Talon's Bleed. Weak. Teemo's poison. Weak. Even his shrooms are weak cause they got gutted real hard. Trundle's DoT weak as hell. You only ever notice the initial cast. Your HP regen outheals his ult lel. Twitch's passive does damage???? Urgot's is weak. Morde's ult gets out healed by base hp regen lel. Naut's is weak too. Don't even mention Cass. Her poison is a joke without her e.

To your second point, if I'm just going to shoot some DoT at you while you're low, chances are, you're running away and I probably cant attack you again. No one just throws away the chance to auto their enemy another time. If I can auto them, i'm going to auto them. If a cass shoots you with her Q while you're at 10% hp, you don't know whether or not its going to kill you, so you just heal or barrier anyways before the last tick. If they add your system, they'll know if they need to actually heal.

Knalxz4 votes

LoL this will be a great change because attackers will know when to burn and walk while receives will know when to all in. Because

KogMaw "If I'm going to die, we're all going to die."

daggers of denak4 votes

The only problem with this is that it may affect Teemos' early game a lot. He is able to constantly reset his dot. Players aren't gona over extend vs him as much, his making people over extend is the way he wins trades early game , his toxic shot on hit and passive are a lot less effective late game.

Seth the Bum4 votes

I have mixed feelings about this. One the one hand, I agree with you, and it would definitely show more clarity and the use of another colored bar is pretty clever. But on the other hand, the one thing I love about DoTs is that they are "sneaky" in a way. If someone gets hit for half their damage by someone's burst, they immediately think, "Oh sh--, I'd better back off!" If someone is hit by a DoT that will do just as much damage, they don't usually think about how much damage they'll be taking, and only see their health as it presently is. I know DoTs can be impactful, so I don't need them to instantly feel impactful for me to appreciate them.

Now, you might be thinking that that's a problem with DoTs, as Riot has shown their stance, that they're considered too powerful because of being a form of "hidden power." I will say that keeping the power of a DoT hidden is exactly the point of a DoT in the first place. Bear in mind that, unlike instant damage, a champion using DoTs is already making a sacrifice in that they have to play much more carefully in order to make use of the DoT, since other champions can simply burst someone into the ground with instant damage and not have to worry about retaliation. With a DoT, you have to keep yourself alive while you wait for your damage to sink in, which in my opinion is the balancing point of not immediately revealing your hand, so to speak.

Another problem with showing the total damage of a DoT, as Reinboom and Penns have stated, is that it will likely cause even more clarity issues. I guess the technical side of such a seemingly small change is somewhat restricted by the way the damage is coded and calculated. Kind of a shame, really, but oh well.

Fırewood3 votes

Why not make it like Ashe's Q? The number indicating the total damage accumulates instead of popping up at each tick.

Dr Poro2 votes

Do people actually look at those numbers? I don't. I just look at how big of a chunk got taken from my hp bar.

Alpharite3 votes

This might actually be a nerf to the champions that use it. It would tell you whether you should pot/retreat to inner turret.

Hyrum Graff3 votes

{quoted}

This might actually be a nerf to the champions that use it. It would tell you whether you should pot/retreat to inner turret.

It would also tell you, as a champion who uses it, whether you need to AA again to get the kill. Six of one, half dozen of another.

I've tried to retreat to inner turret on multiple occasions when I get DoT'd. It never saves me.

But say it was a nerf. Then it opens up the way to buff most of those champions. And let's be honest, I'd rather play, or play against, a stronger champ with more clarity than a weaker champ with less.

######Although devourer diana (you can barely see her passive cleave when it's a phantom hit) is hillarious.

SouL1ess3 votes

Riot is making dumb excuses to make "reasoning" for their actions, though.

No one feels that their DoT has little effect unless they are unskilled with the champion's kit.

As the caster, it's hard to appreciate how much damage they do. When hit by one, it's hard to tell how much damage it's going to do.

The skill deals the tooltip described damage over a time period. How difficult is that to understand? How does it make one lack appreciation for its damage, and how is it unclear about how much damage the DoT is going to do?

Edit: forgot to answer to OP. I think such thing is not necessary in the game. DoTs don't need a predictable bar for "clarity" to show the enemy whether they require livelihood assistance. If Riot makes stupid statements, let them be stupid; of course what they said aren't the problems with DoT, because those two statements are not problems, but Riot's preference. There is nothing wrong with DoT skills, aside from that Riot doesn't like them. Giving the DoT an visual indicator solves nothing about Riot disliking DoT, because there is nothing wrong with the DoT system in the first place.

DoTs should have an advantage in that their total damage per cast is much higher than immediate damage skills, but their drawback is exactly that they deal damage over a given time period, instead of instantly. Why Riot dislike DoT abilities has nothing to do with how DoT damage skills are expected to work.

clanku3 votes

I feel like that's the edge DoT champions need, I mean it's a very small advantage especially in higher levels of play, but sometimes DoT's give the champ the time it needs for the enemy to stay in battle thinking he will win it. Imagine how many disengaged battles Cass would lose if the enemy could see the damage they would take from it. Stuff like this doesn't really matter early game in trading but mid game I think that's a little advantage DoT champions like Swain, and Cass really need.

Otarie533 votes

a swain nerf?? not on my watch!

YossarianSensei3 votes

I don't think this is a good idea

Not all DoTs deal the same DPS, and predicting DoTs is part of game knowledge. Heroes of the Storm has this mechanic and I've never been a fan of it, but it does work for HoTS because there's no armor/MR in that game, everything is just pure health.

Centuros2 votes

I don't really get people's infatuation with DoTs for their own sake. Surely it would be better for everyone if the damage just happened NOW. Though DoTs are still a good thing to attach to debuffs that also do something else, I guess.

Hyrum Graff8 votes

{quoted}

I don't really get people's infatuation with DoTs for their own sake. Surely it would be better for everyone if the damage just happened NOW. Though DoTs are still a good thing to attach to debuffs that also do something else, I guess.

I think things like "poisoner" are cool fantasies that some people are attached to. It's also a pretty satisfying moment when you know you're going to kill someone, and you just get to bask in that for a while (Zil bomb, Death mark, malz Aids, etc).

In general, I agree that DoTs for their own sake are kinda meh. But I also don't have anything against DoTs, just against how they're shown in game.

There's also some specific cases (like Malz) where DoT is really important. Imagine if Malz could literally instakill a wave with E. It be ridiculously broken. Either poof, wave gone and you just got chunked for standing near it, or poof, it fizzles before malz has a chance to get the minions low enough for it to do its thing.

Dr Poro5 votes

DoT is a good mechanic that allows you to deal a lot of damage without giving you insane burst potential. Even if your enemy will inevitably die, they'll have the opportunity to take you with them.

Shroom Junkie1 votes

Good idea, but one problem: Healing. I mean think about Mundo ult while this goes. Lol.

Hyrum Graff12 votes

{quoted}

Good idea, but one problem: Healing. I mean think about Mundo ult while this goes. Lol.

Healing makes the red bar go up. Orange/yellow stays the same, on the end, ticking down.

Shroom Junkie1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Hyrum Graff,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=i2xERtsd,comment-id=00030000,timestamp=2015-09-14T17:02:27.462+0000)

Healing makes the red bar go up. Orange/yellow stays the same, on the end, ticking down.

Tru, that makes sense.

What about damage reducts? Like Master Yi's W? Would it just shorten?

Hyrum Graff5 votes

{quoted}

What about damage reducts? Like Master Yi's W? Would it just shorten?

Here's a scenario where I totally changed numbers to make it easy to follow:

I'm malz, you're yi. My aids deals 1000 damage over 10 seconds (100 dps). You have 2000 hp and no resists. We're both at full. Your current meditate heals 250 over 4 seconds and has 50% damage reduction.

  • I put my aids on you. Your bar immediately updates so it has 1000 green hp, 1000 orange hp.

  • You let it tick halfway. Now your bar has 1000 green hp, 500 orange hp. 1500 total hp

  • You meditate. IMMEDIATELY your hp bar changes to 1250 green, 250 orange. 1500 total hp

  • Over the course of the meditation, you heal 250 --> 1500 green hp and take the 4 sec * 100 dps * 50% = 200 DoT. You end up with 1500 green hp and 50 orange hp. 1550 total hp

  • Meditate ends and your HP bar changes to 1450 green hp, 100 orange hp. 1550 total hp

  • Orange hp ticks, you end up with 1450 hp.

Notice how the damage reduction changes how much is green vs orange, but NOT the total -- because it's a purely visual indicator.

Shroom Junkie1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Hyrum Graff,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=i2xERtsd,comment-id=0003000000000000,timestamp=2015-09-14T18:12:00.383+0000)

Here's a scenario where I totally changed numbers to make it easy to follow:

I'm malz, you're yi. My aids deals 1000 damage over 10 seconds (100 dps). You have 2000 hp and no resists. We're both at full. Your current meditate heals 250 over 4 seconds and has 50% damage reduction.

  • I put my aids on you. Your bar immediately updates so it has 1000 green hp, 1000 orange hp.

  • You let it tick halfway. Now your bar has 1000 green hp, 500 orange hp. 1500 total hp

  • You meditate. IMMEDIATELY your hp bar changes to 1250 green, 250 orange. 1500 total hp

  • Over the course of the meditation, you heal 250 --> 1500 green hp and take the 4 sec * 100 dps * 50% = 200 DoT. You end up with 1500 green hp and 50 orange hp. 1550 total hp

  • Meditate ends and your HP bar changes to 1450 green hp, 100 orange hp. 1550 total hp

  • Orange hp ticks, you end up with 1450 hp.

Notice how the damage reduction changes how much is green vs orange, but NOT the total -- because it's a purely visual indicator.

What if Yi has rank 5 W? :D eheheheheehhe jk <3

Hyrum Graff4 votes

{quoted}

What if Yi has rank 5 W? :D eheheheheehhe jk <3

Then he 100-0's me and i cri myself 2 slep

More from Gameplay

More by Hyrum Graff