Thresh in just about EVERY game is getting incredibly stale.
It's been like this for just about as long as I remember. Hook, Flay, Prison, Lantern. The lane bullying. The late game hook that ends it. The cheese kill, the cheese escape. The 53% win rate. The absolute dominance. Does he have a counter? No. Does he determine the out come of games consistently. Yes. Give us a break Rito.

, out of 140+ champions, fulfills the correct amount of tanky-ness, damge, AND cc. He can engage, save allies with shields and re-position them, hook and pull a target, displace enemies in team fights, provide 5 large walls with great slows which are good for team-fights, chasing and retreating.
He also gains power as things die and, if you so chose, you can build him as Combat Thresh and his whole kit supports it. Fairly beefy still, has a gap closer, slow, and displacer.