considering i keep seeing "not thresh" versing me, i can only assume he is not regarded to be a dominant pick by other support players.
I am pretty certain a lot of support players consider him to be fun, therefore it he were as strong as you suggest, i would have been seeing him more.
considering the range of champions i am seeing in the support role right now, what's missing from the role is not more champion sub-types, but more viable play-styles.
the biggest culprit i feel is "protect the carry" which seems to be an overly dominant task that is relegated to support players. What I would personally want is more roaming, more ganking, less your ADC gets to die the moment you step out of lane, and less the ADC gets instantly blown up if you don't hold your cooldowns for carry-protection.
Item wise, i'd like to see more play making items. Not play enabling; Not saving your team mates; not empowering your team mate: play making. As in you make the decisions and set the tone of the play.