I feel like people over-exaggerate what champions constitute as "broken" rather than "overpowered"

IronyAndSublime·8/1/2019, 1:01:33 AM·2 votes·831 views

From what I've noticed, people call champs like Darius Renekton Yasuo Zed as "Broken" without realizing that they're overpowered, not broken.

Overpowered would mean that have way too many strengths in their kits that make it seem very one sided. They're TOO powerful. However, they're not particularly "braindead" as much as you would think regardless of how much you hate these champions.

Before you call me biased because I main Darius, yes, I KNOW he's too strong. In fact, I think his utility should have priority in his buffs rather than his damage. (I think his damage should be nerfed).

However, when there are champions that are just so strong regardless if their abilities being too strong or too weak, I would point the finger at champions like Riven Illaoi Jax Tryndamere , Stat check based champs. Yeah, they do have some of their mechanics, but when you really think about it, they rely more on the strengths of their items rather than their base abilities. At that point, they break and their design is a mess that's totally unbeatable.

I also play a LOT of Tryndamere, but even I THINK HE'S TOO RELIANT ON STAT CHECKS. From my experience, he's ALWAYS thinking about his items over his abilities. A Tryndamere whose fed to the point of no return can just kill people without needing his r or e. He'd only use them if forced to.

So what I believe is, there's a line between overpowered and broken. Don't just use these phrases like they're the same thing. You gotta realize in order to fix these balance issues we first have to figure out what in particular is wrong with them.

13 Comments

DuskDaUmbreon8/1/2019, 1:16:23 AM3 votes

Except Yasuo is neither OP or broken.

And calling Riven, who is generally accepted as the most skill-intensive champion in the game, a statcheck...?

preternatural8/1/2019, 1:21:00 AM3 votes

darius, yasuo and zed ARE broken. renekton is generally balanced he does what he does. riven is broken jax is broken illaoi is just overpowered iunno why she's been allowed to do what she does for so long but whatever they made her better at it. trynda is the founders champion so by design he has to be broken. otherwise mark merrill can't crack diamond.

WoonStruck8/1/2019, 1:20:45 AM1 votes

What they mean by "broken" is "unhealthy" and by "unhealthy" they mean an unfun gameplay experience almost regardless of the situation, barring getting fed against them early and snowballing.

preternatural8/1/2019, 1:21:49 AM1 votes

actually i derp on my own thoughts, trynda isn't broken just blatantly overpowered into melee matchups.

ImTheJuggernauty8/1/2019, 2:07:11 PM1 votes

State some statistical evidence as to how darius is OP. He's objectively not, though I agree he doesn't need damage buffs, he needs utility and/or survivability buffs.