Skip to content

What do people/Riot think about making league role-based versus position-based?

MorsLillaBulldog··1 votes·972 views

As it is right now almost everyone seems to focus positions. People in solo queue main positions, LCS players have certain positions (even though they don't always play in their assigned position) and even seems to balance champions by what position they are mostly played in.

This obviously works just fine, but as League evolves I think maining a certain role over a position offer more possibilities. Mages will know exactly how to position in team fights etc., Tanks will know when to engage and Assassins will know when to strike. Since they have mostly done just that.

You can look at it from another perspective as well. Top, Mid and Bot have barely any differences. It's all about last hitting and harassing your opponent. Jungle is slightly different, because you fight jungle monsters (and they fight back) instead of standing in lane. You could argue that the jungler needs to gank, but you could leave that to others and cover their lane in the meantime or counter-jungle and deny the opposing jungler. And last but not least the support position (!!!), which to me is that person that helps you getting through laning phase by sacrificing some of his or her own income.

This shift is sort of already happening, but instead of focusing on a role people tend to assign roles to positions (i.e. mid = Mage/Assassin, support = Tank/Mage). In LCS however they start to switch around positions somewhat, but they haven't really made the step yet. Personally I'd love to build a team myself around this, for the lack of a better word, strategy(?).

Anyway I wanted to see what people think of it. It might just be to early or perhaps it is happening (slowly) as I described above.

Thanks for reading! :)

11 Comments

Lasersniped2 votes

I like this idea, but I also like the uniqueness of how each lane seems to have it's own mechanics. Also, I think that it separates, LoL from DotA and HoN which I feel are much more role based like you are asking for. I do however think that there's a lot more room for variety than people think. There was a post about a month or so back about different duo lane combos that could be used, while putting the ADC in a solo lane. I think this should be looked into more, as we already see the re-emergence of the roaming support strategy with the solo-lane ADC in the pro scene.

I think the main issue with trying to get more people to experiment is that the LoL community as a whole, myself included, has an obsession with competing and competitive play. Because of this, people don't want to try-out new things because they aren't used to them and don't want to risk losing because of it. They would rather lose on their own merits, playing the style that they know.

It's this mentality, that I think is holding back LoL from having the uniqueness of other MOBAs in compositions and gameplay style. People's unwillingness to try new things, change, and adapt. There's a reason why Dawngate's tagline is "Break the Meta"

MorsLillaBulldog1 votes

I agree and I had some thoughts myself about different lane-setups, which led me to think about this role-focus. Because it makes building teams so much easier.

I guess it's something Riot should look into and try to evolve the game towards. Team builder seems to offer some potential of that.

Angry Monster1 votes

There are more possible roles compares to positions. How do you resolve that? Also what about the fact that meta is designed around positional thinking.

Postions top mid adc support jungle.

Roles Tank, assassin, fighter, CC mage Nami , Dps mage(Cassiopeia , burst mageSyndra, Ad caster, ADC. Some people think bruisers and fighters are different so you could have another one their.

MorsLillaBulldog1 votes

Can you explain positional thinking a little more? not sure I know what you mean.

The roles you listed are in some cases just nuances of the main roles which I think are: Tank, Assassin, Mage, Marksmen(ADC or whatever people like to call it) and Fighter

The example you made here with Nami ,Cassiopeia and Syndra is somewhat valid, but they all have a similar play style. Do AoE damage from range and use your utility to help you/your team in fights etc.

And this is mostly true for all roles, but when playing the same position you won't gain as much as knowing one role in and out.

Edit: Just as a side note. The meta can and will change in some way. This post wasn't about something that has to happen today. Also you don't have to have one of each role in your team you could have two tanks for example or two mages (as it is often the case today).

Angry Monster1 votes

Look at team builder. that has 6 listed roles for a team of 5. One or more role will not be used every game. I would call team builder the dumb down version of champ select and builds. You are stating in advance what you are going to do instead of being organic and adaptive. Most people when they say tank do not go out side of this and build damage. But this thread is not about team builder, moving on.

Real games are where players are adaptive. There are more than 6 possible roles in league. Jax can be built total glass, bruiser, even tank(not popular, but possible). By saying a role you are saying I am doing X and only X. The team should count on you following your word and building X not Y(anything else).

Their are different purposes for each build also. So saying I am a light fighter(glass) main will mean that you are useless out side of that role. So instead of developing a range of styles for Top(mage, fighter, tank ,brusier AD, and bruiser AP) players will master roles. It will be litterally playing with Rivan only players. One style wonders(which is very very bad).

Now about all the different roles i have listed. Every single one of them are different play styles and mean different things. AD caster and ADC do not even come close to equaling each other. Ad caster uses his spells for most of his damage (blu EZ, Urgot). ADC mean auto attacking champ that is not counting on his spells for damage late game(cait, trist,). What is the major diffeence between the two? How fast they can take towers. Spell casting does not damage them. Auto attackers build more AS than casters.

All the other examples of roles have similar stuff. A CC mage could be Ori or morg and can go mid. But try taking new sona, leo, or nami mid and what what happens. Most of the time they will fail cause they are not designed for these roles.(especially the new sona). So the role of CC mage does not work.

I am not against the meta changing but it can not expand out of a the current lane assignments. League is all about gold and the most efficient way for gold is the 1 1 2 plus jungler assignment. Things like 3 2 0 lanes work in DOTA 2 for special reasons that are not applicable here. Some of those reason is that their is a long lane that is just safe and early game items are more efficient than late games items. Unless Riot decides to completely abandon 5+ years of live map testing and the new beta map, lane numbers will not change in that aspect of meta. Though the 2 person lane could move mid (have a theory about that but not this thread).

MorsLillaBulldog1 votes

About Team builder roles, I don't consider support a role since it's only Mages (or CC mages as you refer to as) and Tanks. Which is quite a difference in my opinion.

The next part is where we have our difficulties. While Jax has many builds he will always be a fighter. That's how he is designed. That's where he has his strengths. To make a weird example, you can go tank LeBlanc, but it won't be as effective as say tank Malphite and even if you would go that build you will still need similar mechanics to be able to play her.

Fighters can be considered the one fits all kind of role. they have all some utility(CC), durability, mobility and damage. So if I would main fighter I can still decide what type of fighter my team needs me to build.

In the example of ADC vs AD caster, you're still ranged, squishy and deal tons of (sustain) damage and use AA for bigger parts of your damage. They aren't the same and they offer certain advantages in different situations, but they have a lot of similarities in mechanics. A example would be the E Q combo from Ezreal. You can do the same with Caitlyn or Tristanas rocket jump plus explosive shot.

To come to your next part about CC mages, not all champions work everywhere. That being said sona or nami mid can surely be a possibility. They might not have the goal to kill you in lane or even beat you in it, but rather survive laning phase and defend her tower. On the other hand this might be more difficult on LCS/challenger level, because they might not be perfectly balanced.

Truly League is about gold and it is very important that you collect as much as possible but also deny as much as possible to your opponent. If you remember last season, I believe, 4-1-0 Lane setups were the norm. Right now we see a lot of 3-1-1 with the jungler being mostly top (whilst not farming).

All of what I've been writing about isn't going to happen today or next month or even next season. And hopefully they don't abandon anything. It's more off an evolution of the game, which is exactly what Riot talks about when they talk about the games strengths (It being updated/changed all the time).

Angry Monster2 votes

4 1 0 was for fast tower pushing and degenerated back to 1- 1- 2 lanes still for the gold. The reason for that meta fell off was that riot increased tower defenses again and balenced the defenses to all towers. Riot said they hate non interactive play and 4 lane pushes at 4 minutes are exactly that.

Riot will not allow this. The devs feel like this pattern of play is harmful and are taking as many steps as they can to prevent it. Riot's league of legends will never be about the early game and are always forcing focus towards mid/late.(stomps being exceptions).

Some weird meta may come out again cause of something riot did not think about(like towers defenses not being equal). I doubt that riot will ever allow it to last unless it passes their interesting requirement.

Especially the new sona is not viable mid they designed it so that she can not access her full power with out one ally. You may not believe in role specific support but that is you turning a blind eye to the truth. Riot forces some champs into only one role. The only role that gets this treatment is supports though. Sona, nami, sorka, leona, and ali will always be hit with nerfs if they find a way out side of the support role. It has been time tested at this point. Riot has also made posts where they said leo and ali should only exist as a duo lane champ. you may not agree with this but this is how riot does operate.

Worgslarg1 votes

Because the only 2 things a team in league actually needs are a marksman to deal safe, high, sustained damage in teamfights, and a tank to peel for the marksmen/ engage for the team.

No other role is essential to league gameplay, and while there are 6 roles, and only 2 of them essential, you cannot balance the game around it.

The other thing that being balanced around lanes grants is the ability to see difference of role in a lane.

If suddenly adc's became worthless in a teamcomp, and assassins became priceless, you would prob see every team going support and assassin botlane to get the assassin fed.

MorsLillaBulldog1 votes

It's sounds like you're suggesting that 3 Tanks and 2 ADCs or 2 Tanks and 3 ADCs are the most OP team comps? It might but if I think about how Assassins might be able to kill those ADCs (which leaves you without good damage) and Mages offer so much damage and utility, I can't really imagine that this would be the optimal comp.

I don't suggest to buff a certain role (like assassins), but rather have a more consistent balancing throughout each role and between the roles as well of course. Also I think that if people try to master a certain role rather than a position, the level of skill would rise over time.

Worgslarg1 votes

It's not the best teamcomp, but you are hard pressed to make a viable comp without a tank and an adc.

Regardless of what you play your other lanes around ( poke, all in, aoe, 5 man yasuo ults, etc) you need a tank and adc to win any 2 sided game.

Neofederalist1 votes

The issue I have with this is that positions are mostly static, where roles are meta-dependent.

LCS caliber mid laners for most of this year have not had the luxury of playing assassins, even if it fit their personal playstyle (largely due to changes to heal and exhaust). If the competitive meta doesn't suit assassins, LCS players have very little success with them.

More from Gameplay

More by MorsLillaBulldog