@Riot: Can Xerath get the Jhin treatment on his ult?

Helmight·6/1/2016, 8:18:37 PM·4 votes·975 views

Jhin's ult gets a small refund for every shot that he doesn't fire while ulting. Meanwhile, Xerath's ult goes on full CD unless he doesn't fire a single shot. As far as I'm aware, their ults aren't dissimilar enough that one should be able to partially refund the ult CD and one can't.

1 Comments

Pyrodinium6/1/2016, 10:01:22 PM1 votes

Aside from the fact that those abilities belong to champions with vastly different playstyles, I would argue they are distinct enough to warrant a unique refund mechanic on each one.

Jhin's Curtain Call is quite restrictive and unforgiving, due to the fact that it is...

  • locked in a specific direction, which allows the opponent to exit its killzone by moving to the sides (particularly if they are close to you).
  • made up by slim linear skillshots, which can be bodyblocked, are easier to dodge if you have vision downwind and way more susceptible to projectile blockers.
  • limited to single target damage against enemy champions.
  • geared towards execution given its % of missing health scaling, which limits the scenarios in which can be used optimally.
  • on a Marksman, a class that revolves primarily around autoattacking from (relatively) short range.

Given that, I find adequate that Jhin gets a cooldown refund per unfired bullet, as he will find situations in which remaining on firing stance is just detrimental (full HP Tank blocking the shots, the teamfight moves out of his killzone).

Meanwhile, Xerath's Rite of the Arcane has the following advantages:

  • It is not locked to a single direction; Enemies can leave the blast zone only by moving outside its maximum range.
  • Has a ground-targeting paradigm, meaning that can easily reach the enemy backline with it.
  • Deals Area of Effect damage.
  • Can be used for poke, area denial, cleanup or teamfighting for the same potential damage.
  • Is a complement to a kit that already has very long-range damage.

Rite of the Arcane is just way more flexible than Curtain Call; giving Xerath a partial refund mechanic on it would allow him to extert even more pressure on the map: He would be able to rain arcane fire over the enemy team from a more than a screen away, safe from retaliation and knowing that if the enemy retreats, he can cancel the ultimate to have it available earlier instead of commiting its significant cooldown. It would also make him very strong at minion wave control; something that made Ziggs (another Artillery Mage) so hard to balance in his time.