Esports will never be comparable to "normal" sports as long as they're run by gaming companies

BobaFlautist·10/10/2017, 9:10:43 PM·1 votes·292 views

Imagine if baseball could only be played on MLB-owned fields with the professional-level rules, different positions and equipment had to be "unlocked" by grinding, and MLB was the only licensed producer of baseball jerseys.

Or imagine if the NFL technically "owned" any football equient you had, and all that equipment and the game itself was utterly dependant on the NFL being up-and-running, actively hosting it for you.

Or if you couldn't play two-hand-touch football without the NFL releasing an official version, and even then you had to follow their exact rules. Otherwise, it's tackle or nothing.

Video game companies tend to prefer to keep as much as possible in-house and heavily protected against pirating, intellectual theft, cheating, and independant servers, which is completely understandable when the product you're trying to market is the game itself, but also inherently limits how many people will ever play it.

As long as league cannot be played without learning a million clunky rules and interactions and a pickup game can't tweak the specifics, the general population will never get a good enough sense of how it works to enjoy watching it. The "sports" model is very specific, and "Esports" fail to meet the basic qualifications.

I'm not necessarily saying this is a bad thing, but if Riot really wanted to embrace the spectator-sport aspect of their game, they would have to give up a lot of control over how and when it's played. I very much doubt they're willing to take that risk.

Esports are a fun idea, but the current generation will always have a niche audience - mostly comprised of people that play the game recreationally.

4 Comments

BigBellBrute10/11/2017, 12:14:20 AM1 votes

Well baseball is pretty much played on fields someone else owns and pay and travel leagues are beginning to supplant recreational ones which cost less money but still cost. And instead of unlocking stuff for free with game play, you have to unlock your bat, glove, and uniforms and everything else with money. BTW you can unlock lol champions with money also. Yes the bat belongs to you if you buy it. But bats break and you have to go buy another one. Mitts wear out. Imagine if after 6 months you pick Ashe in game and get a message uh sorry. You have worn Ashe out. You'll have to purchase another Ashe or whoops. Your feet grew a size. You need to purchase a bigger Cho Gath.

MysterQ10/11/2017, 1:51:50 AM1 votes

You make no sense.

No one is watching puff football, flag football, touch football, streetball. They don't matter at all.

Virgin Ray10/11/2017, 3:17:37 AM1 votes

its never going to be comparable to any normal sports at all no matter what the condition