Investigation: Marcin “Kori” Wolski and MeetYourMakers

Riot·2/12/2015, 6:56:53 AM·0 votes·46,028 views
Immediately prior to the start of the 2015 LCS season, we were informed that Marcin “Kori” Wolski had decided to leave MeetYourMakers (MYM). LCS officials accepted it was an emergency situation and the team was allowed to use a substitute for the upcoming games in Wolski’s absence. Subsequent facts have come to light which exhibit significant mismanagement and unprofessional behavior from a senior member of MYM’s management team. In this kind of complex case, full investigation of the facts takes time to complete, but after review we wanted to give insight into our internal investigation and next steps. Although teams and players are ultimately responsible for navigating their own contractual relationships, we will do everything in our power to discourage and work against unacceptable environments involving our teams and players. We have zero tolerance for intimidation of players within an LCS organization. On January 23, 2015 Wolski reached out to LCS officials stating that he had been threatened by MYM management. He also informed LCS officials that he had a recording of the conversation. We took this matter very seriously and continued our open investigation into the mistreatment of the player, although given legal concerns regarding the recording which was obtained without all parties’ knowledge, we did not request or use it to inform our ongoing investigation. The severity of the situation has since emerged through the recording being made public by Wolski, showing that he and his immediate family were threatened with legal action by MYM manager Sebastian Rotterdam. Our investigation found fault on behalf of both player and management. Despite Wolski’s claims that payments had been withheld, we found the only missing payments stemmed from the Supa Hot Crew (SHC) organisation, of which Wolski was a player in the 2014 season. As we understand it, the failure to receive payments from SHC arose due to Wolski's own failure to provide requested tax documentation, and this problem can be resolved once Wolski produces these documents. As a separate organization, MYM has provided us with documentation verifying that they have not withheld any payment from its players. As such, it appeared that by leaving the team ahead of the beginning of the spring split Wolski was breaking an active contract and commitment to MYM. It is not our intention to create a precedent that discourages teams from discussing legal issues or informing players of their liabilities should they seek to disavow an existing contract, as in Wolski’s case. In fact, teams and players should have these conversations and negotiations independently and with full context and knowledge of the legal commitments and restrictions. What we also believe, however, is that teams have a moral commitment to treat players - who are often inexperienced and vulnerable - with dignity and respect. Rotterdam’s actions in conversation with Wolski when addressing this contract break were both unprofessional and unjustifiable. As confirmed by the team earlier today, MYM, of its own accord, has taken action against Rotterdam and fired him from his position as team manager. Rotterdam will also be indefinitely suspended by Riot from competing within the LCS as a manager or any other team position. An entire LCS organization shoulders the responsibility for the behavior of their team members and ensuring their players have a safe and professional environment. MYM will be held accountable for Rotterdam’s actions towards Wolski and for failing to protect their team members from his unacceptable and bullying behavior. As such, Riot will be issuing MYM with a fine of €5,000 for unprofessional behaviour. We know this fine may not satisfy those hoping for a harsher punishment for MYM, but there’s some important context as to how we reached this amount. In deciding the severity of the fine we took several factors into account. Primarily, we considered the fact that Rotterdam’s actions - and MYM’s failure to protect players from them - created an unprofessional work environment for the team. We also took into account the fact that MYM acted decisively to remove Rotterdam from the organization once the full facts of his behavior had come to light. Lastly, although it in no way justifies threats or intimidation, we also considered when deciding on a punishment the fact that Wolski appeared to break a commitment to a team, which put not only his career but those of his teammates in jeopardy. We’re aware that questions have been raised as to whether MYM should be stripped of their LCS slot. After concluding our investigation, we feel that MYM has taken significant steps to remove toxic influence from within their organization and is prepared to move forward in the best interests of their players and their competitive careers. We believe that forfeiting the slot would unnecessarily penalize players and interrupt their pro careers through no fault of their own. Even though MYM has acted swiftly to correct this issue, any further violations can and will put them on a path to suspension from the LCS. We appreciate the strength of community sentiment against any influence that would threaten or otherwise challenge the safety and security of pro teams and players. For Riot, cases like this tread a difficult balance between relying on the contractual relationships negotiated between teams and players to appropriately guide their behavior, and using our influence to try and ensure a professional, and ethical environment for those parties operating within the LCS ecosystem. Where we feel strongly that unprofessionalism is putting player security at risk, we can and will use our influence to try to ensure that the LCS pro experience is a positive one.

RELEVANT RULES

10.2.10 Moral Turpitude A Team Member may not engage in any activity which is deemed by the LCS to be immoral, disgraceful, or contrary to conventional standards of proper ethical behavior.

RULING

MYM has violated rule 10.2.10 of the LCS ruleset and will be subject to penalties.

COMPETITION PENALTIES

MYM is:
  • Fined €5000
Sebastian Rotterdam is:
  • Banned indefinitely from competing within the LCS as a manager or any other team position

43 Comments

Shkives2/12/2015, 7:49:44 AM46 votes

MYM threatens a 17 or 18 year old kid and his family. Documentation that the CEO was fully knowledgeable/involved. They say 'Big Sorry' and get off with a $5600 fine. CLG got fined 10 Large for picking up Scarra and Zion. Pretty sure they didn't threaten any minors. Riot's punishment of MYM way too soft. Guess hotshot forgot to say Big Sorry.

Sl4B Bulkhe4D2/12/2015, 7:15:57 AM27 votes

5K and the words "big sorry" are enough to compensate threatening a young naive person's family during a dispute? Oh, and the burning of an already fired scapegoat. In the language of the game: Worth Baby, they got their player back.

Groovus2/12/2015, 8:50:17 AM22 votes

This is what I have a problem with, "We also took into account the fact that MYM acted decisively to remove Rotterdam from the organization once the full facts of his behavior had come to light." because it's completely wrong.

MYM did not act to fire their manager until this whole situation became public. To repeat in easy to understand terms, MYM knew that their manager threatened both a player and the player's mother, and did not take action against the manager until their cover-up failed to work.

This is a disgusting act by MYM, and the fact that RIOT is okay with this is almost as bad.

Shuri2/12/2015, 7:14:09 AM14 votes

I'm American so I'm just gonna assume €5000 is like a million dollars.

DillyG1012/12/2015, 9:14:46 AM12 votes

We have PROOF that the CEO knew about the threats happening and was actively trying to keep them secret, yet Riot is too afraid to take real action. Boycotting EU LCS until MYM is no longer apart of it.

BabyDoll692/12/2015, 7:36:49 AM11 votes

That is pretty damn soft if you ask me. $5600 dollar fine for threatening him and his mothers house? That is bullshit, the kid is 17 or 18. I know I would be scared shitless if my employer who is much older than me makes personal threats to me or my family. Rito dropped the ball a little bit on this one, despite MYM's so called "significant steps" that they were forced to make for PR reasons. I think this is an underwhelming penalty, even if he did break part of his contract, I dont blame him for trying to leave.

dat Vayne2/12/2015, 9:31:21 PM9 votes

5K? CLG gets fined more than that just for being late. I see why Doublelift doesn't trash talk much anymore. Rito might fine him

TerraRising2/12/2015, 10:28:30 AM7 votes

My initial reaction was that the punishment wasn't enough. I'm still not sure the punishment is enough, to be honest, given the cavalier attitude MYM's people have shown since #BigSorry came to light.

Still, light fine and all, let's face facts:

  • Despite the possibly light punishment, MYM's reputation is soiled. I wouldn't be surprised if someone brought a "#BigSorry" sign to the EULCS tonight (and equally unsurprised if Rito confiscated every sign at every other LCS event, starting on Friday night.)
  • If Kori's lack of payment came from his failure to provide tax documents, that should have been clearly explained to him. This isn't just a problem with LCS but all professional organizations that hire teens with a lack of real world experience. Riot-sponsored classes on this sort of thing may need to become a requirement for LCS participation in the future.
  • I'm not sure that getting rid of Rotterdam removes the "toxic influence" from MYM. MYM's people seem to be pretty cavalier about where they stand in the whole thing. Also, Rotterdam wasn't fired until after the story leaked, meaning he was around the rest of the team for at least three weeks after the threat. Then, there's the way the CEO tried to spin Kori's return. Getting rid of one manager, I fear, doesn't bode well if the CEO can just go "Heh, we got away with it" in private.

I'm also hoping that when the next incident of "toxic team management" comes to light, the player doesn't need to be completely clean to be trusted by Riot.

Narthsin2/12/2015, 8:13:51 AM7 votes

Riot got this one right, it would be a shame to screw things up for 4 other players who weren't involved. However, I will agree that the fine may be a bit lower than I expected.

TrollFan012/12/2015, 8:21:34 AM4 votes

Holy shit! This is the first tie I eve heard of a damn manager threatening a player. WTF was wrong with him? Glad MYM as a whole isn't going to be punished too harshly for this but I'm still worried.

ninbushido2/12/2015, 2:40:57 PM4 votes

I like how they state "facts have come to light" rather than mentioning Richard Lewis and his involvement in exposing the situation. They must really not like to give credit, information, or really anything to RL.

Smuglator2/16/2015, 7:08:08 PM3 votes

What about the fact that the CEO lied to Wolski about him not being able to play in the Challenger Series in the skype logs? Articles have noted that the contract only kept him from playing in the LCS. That is immoral conduct and an intimidation tactic... That was the CEO, not Rotterdam..

"However, Roar’s CEO, Eric Wong, spoke with someone at Riot Games, about a week earlier, and Wolski playing for the team in the Challenger Qualifiers was not a breach of contract with Riot nor MeetYourMakers. It turns out that what was said to Wolski by Khaled was a lie and Wolski could have played with Roar, but only in the Challenger Series.

Unfortunately due to the threats from MeetYourMakers, Wolski returned to MeetYourMakers for Week 3 out of fear. He came out on the MeetYourMakers’ website with a statement, of which can be found here. After, Khaled schemed with Wolski of how to cover the situation to make both ends seem in the right. " ( http://www.esportsheaven.com/news/view/64692 )

The CEO WAS in fact also intimidating Wolski and spreading lies.

This was not enough punishment to the MYM organization. Blackmailing is a CRIME, not a breach of contract subject to fines.

RIOT, an answer? Hello?

Bunny Molester2/12/2015, 1:29:41 PM3 votes

i understand all of you guys not accepting the punishment, but lets wait and see if Kori is alright with this, if he is, so am i, and lets move on, as Riot said, if they keep doing this , they will be banned from LCS, let that hang for a bit, thats the real threat and punishment here

Cool Calm Cam2/12/2015, 7:12:35 AM3 votes

I'll take it.

Jambat2/12/2015, 11:37:58 AM2 votes

I'd love to see what would happen if someone pulled this in the NFL or NHL and people caught wind of it.

I bet they'd have more balls than to slap them with a 5k fine.

sdchargers172/12/2015, 7:26:21 AM2 votes

[deleted]

Meanie402/12/2015, 1:50:37 PM2 votes

5000 euro? That's all?

.#BigSorry Riot, you screwed this one up.

NΦtSoFΔmΦψs2/12/2015, 2:00:07 PM1 votes

TLDR > don't threaten people. doesn't work Kappasummoner 31

Mee7er2/14/2015, 2:01:11 AM1 votes

They fined the organization. They banned the person directly involved in the dispute who was in the wrong.

I don't really see what else is left to be done.

Yeah, yeah. Fine everyone 10k. Fire everyone. Ban everybody.

That's totally fair for the other four players on MYM. Totally fair for the support staff.

And this is assuming they don't get a nasty backlash from any of their sponsors.