Fans BMing During Ganks in Worlds

Seranthe·9/21/2013, 12:22:52 PM·9 votes·1,374 views

With fans giving away ganks, we need either soundproof booths or a small delay on the viewers' screens. Some kind of soundproof booth that encloses only during the match but is open otherwise is a crazy but cool idea. OGN LoL, SC2 and DoTa2 use soundproof booths to keep things fair; I don't think "fan experience" should be a priority over fans influencing games' outcomes.

For more discussion see: http://www.reddit.com/r/leagueoflegends/comments/1mtqyw/tsm_fans_bming_whenever_there_is_a_gank_coming/

and: http://www.reddit.com/r/leagueoflegends/comments/1muc2r/enough_sound_proof_booths_should_be_mandatory/

8 Comments

Zielmann9/21/2013, 3:12:06 PM3 votes

Having been to a live event myself where they used the booths (MLG Raleigh), I can say that I don't really see why the booths would not be used. Fan experience? Really? I didn't feel like they detracted anything from it at all. I mean, the players are already up on a well-lit stage and are definitely a secondary focus (obviously the game feed on the screen is the main focus). If they were to have the players hidden from view entirely, that would be one thing. But I feel like as long as you can see them, that's all that is really needed. As a fan, I don't need to hear Zuna yelling at his team all game.

I kinda wonder if they didn't bother using them for the group stages while they're still playing in a smaller studio. It's what, a couple hundred people there in the live audience for these? Hopefully when they move to the larger venues for the actual bracket play, they will have the booths set up, because there will be many times more people in attendance, and it will be louder.

If they aren't using the booths, I would think that a 30-second or one-minute delay on what the audience and commentators see might help, too. It doesn't need to be the full 3 minutes that the spectator mode has, because nobody can communicate directly with the players while they're playing. It would delay the fan reactions just enough to de-sync it from the action that whatever was happening will already be done by the time the crowd reacts. The biggest downside to this is that the players reactions might give things away to the audience ahead of time. But this is far less of a concern than fans tipping players off simply by cheering.

IMSOJUICY9/21/2013, 4:14:27 PM2 votes

I read the Fans BM thread over on Reddit... wow, that is so effed up if the crowd really can tip off the "home" team about an incoming gank or whatever. Seriously so effed up.

Edit: Uh, this board doesn't auto-censor cuss words? Ruh roh, time to edit my previous posts.

lorewise9/23/2013, 8:40:39 AM1 votes

Until I read this and that link I had no idea this was even a problem. I assumed that the headsets and lights should be enough and that Riot would have taken everything into consideration. This kind of casts a shadow on the entire event to be honest. Not a horrible looming, get the pitchforks and torches shadow but a shadow none the less.

TheMasterZails9/25/2013, 6:37:37 PM1 votes

I got the feeling from watching the games that there was a 30 second delay on it already. I'm not sure why I got that idea. Can anyone from Riot confirm is there is any delay or not?

Desiderium10/6/2013, 10:52:31 AM1 votes

....Why is no one talking about the casters? The guys with the LOUDEST voices in the crowd? Should they just remove casters because the players could hear them from the speakers of the studio?

Also what does BM mean?