Skip to content

Does the scoring thread without argumentation make any sense?

Neosphoros··2 votes·4,291 views

Some of us are evaluating some threads on board positively or negatively without giving any questions for better explanation. Is that make any sense? For example - scoring specific thread negatively without commenting - might means that this player do not understand thread... but not understanding it does not mean that something is "stupid".

Positive or negative topic valuation is only... suggestion. Sugestion that thread is good or bad, but how it can be bad or good if nobody know what is right or wrong with specific thread if there is no arguments about that? It should be not like that after/before scoring we should argument our evaluation?

11 Comments

Kai Guy2 votes

Last time I checked you seemed to very much not want to have anything resembling a conversation with me.

"No, for the 2nd time I do not want you here. You feeling plesure by argueing with me... so discuson with you is like scrubbing with concrete. ABRA KADABRA ! Go away you bad spirit !"

May I have your permission to go back to my old ways of disproving things you say?

I would love a formal invitation to get back to trying to teach you what burden of proof is and try to enlighten you about team MMR systems.

Or would you rather take 1 downvote with out comments?

Look, I am probably going to be eternally frustrating for you if you still building all your arguments around trying to prove this to be true.

I'm hardstucked in silver. Not becouse my skills, it is because broken system that selecting weak players to my team. Experience is not exactly the same as skill, but if you will be more experienced than your enemy - you should know more, you should be better prepared and if you are not stupid you should win the game.

I will try to abide by board rules here. Let me know if the following bolded bit is relevant to our interactions.

"Seek to offer constructive advice in a civil and friendly manner, and understand that things you find obvious about the game, the behavior system, or the Boards community may not be obvious to others. Have a little patience and try to help the player reach a better understanding. At the same time, don’t be discouraged if they aren’t receptive. Some small percentage of players won’t want to listen to your advice, no matter how politely you try to lend a hand. In these situations, simply exit the conversation gracefully."

Modi1 votes

The same can be said about a lot of topics, including politics, movies without seeing them (based on actor/director), music without hearing it (based on artist/composer), foods without tasting them (based on restaurant/chef).

It is endemic to society that people have precharacterizations of a subject, based on its surface attributes (e.g. the title of a post). While it would be better if people understood a topic at a certain depth before prejudging it, the reality is that it won't happen. It is a sad truth, but it is still the truth.

Neosphoros1 votes

{quoted}

The same can be said about a lot of topics, including politics, movies without seeing them (based on actor/director), music without hearing it (based on artist/composer), foods without tasting them (based on restaurant/chef).

It is endemic to society that people have precharacterizations of a subject, based on its surface attributes (e.g. the title of a post). While it would be better if people understood a topic at a certain depth before prejudging it, the reality is that it won't happen. It is a sad truth, but it is still the truth.

But do not you think that is stupid?

Just only because you don't understand quantum physics you will say that it is stupid?

Becouse of ours threads/comments evaluation, board moderators may decide about removing/closing specific thread... so our valuation should be argued.

For example look at one of my threads:

https://boards.na.leagueoflegends.com/pl/c/gameplay-balance/cc4ojkEZ-did-not-i-already-said-that-dev-position-ranks-in-action

There is 11 negative votes but only 1 neutreal comment.... so what is all about? Where is the sense?

I do not even know what is "wrong" with my topic... so I can not even respond to negative "opinions" to defend my point of view.

Modi2 votes

But do not you think that is stupid?

Not necessarily. Just because someone doesn't post a response, does not mean that are entire ignorant to the topic. For example, if the topic is, in my opinion, trivially useless or patently false, I might not even dignify the thread with a response.

Just only because you don't understand quantum physics you will say that it is stupid?

People see entitled to their own opinions.

Becouse of ours threads/comments evaluation, board moderators may decide about removing/closing specific thread... so our valuation should be argued.

If the thread or post doesn't break the rules, it will not be removed by moderation.

For example look at one of my threads:

https://boards.na.leagueoflegends.com/pl/c/gameplay-balance/cc4ojkEZ-did-not-i-already-said-that-dev-position-ranks-in-action

There is 11 negative votes but only 1 neutreal comment.... so what is all about? Where is the sense?

I do not even know what is "wrong" with my topic... so I can not even respond to negative "opinions" to defend my point of view.

Some people choose to vice the fact that they disagree with your topic with a simple vote up or down without replying.

I find it interesting that you only care about downvotes without comment, but not upvotes, when they are essentially the same, simplistic voicing of an opinion.

Vegito1012 votes

Well i read your comment and your post and I simply disagree with your thoughts...no wounder you got 11 dislikes

Neosphoros1 votes

{quoted}

Well i read your comment and your post and I simply disagree with your thoughts...no wounder you got 11 dislikes

To disagree with some opinions - arguments are needed. Do you have any?

I have provide a prove and RIOT have proved my prove by changing his system... so it is even not possible to not agree.

Vegito1011 votes

Are you sure that Riot changing system?Check it again...

Neosphoros1 votes

{quoted}

Are you sure that Riot changing system?Check it again...

Yes. I'm sure

https://nexus.leagueoflegends.com/en-pl/2019/01/dev-position-ranks-in-action/

Vegito1011 votes

This is just bad idea ... community is against it and I agree If you are diamond1 level mid player,and you can't play support or jungle as diamond 5 u just suck in game . Second u get autofiled one in 10 games or more ...

Neosphoros1 votes

{quoted}

This is just bad idea ... community is against it and I agree If you are diamond1 level mid player,and you can't play support or jungle as diamond 5 u just suck in game . Second u get autofiled one in 10 games or more ...

It is the greatest idea what can be.

Till now system favoured players that was swapping lanes in every game because system simply could not deal with that variable, but because of that system hurting really good one-lane-players.

Vegito1011 votes

For me personally it is very boring to play just one lane or eaven worst one champion.if I am good just in 1 lane or just one champion I would consider myself as bad league player .That doesn't mean I play all lanes equally...I am very good on one lane,but I am decent on others ... It is more fun to play more lanes and you learn more about game. 2.problem with this system is the fact that most of players will not care about winning on other lanes then their main, which will make more toxiciy...only reason why people would care to win on off role they got was lp...now they won't care ... So if you got player with off role support in silver, who is main mid on diamond ,u will get 0 effort from him when he get autofill...which ruins experience of others 4 in team...

So if this system goes through in live servers ,that will be first step to league of legends downfall ,and if it stay to death of lol...

More from Discuss the Boards

More by Neosphoros