Skip to content

Anonymity and votes

Madjack01··1 votes·1,719 views

We all know that votes determine what threads people get to see and what threads never get a decent chance. The latter one is especially true if you're unlucky with a few early downvotes and the group mentality kicks in.

With votes having so much power in these forums, there seems to be a sketchy balance between said power and the responsibility that should come with it.

In that regard I was wondering why votes are as anonymous as they are. You could argue to prevent retaliation, which in theory is a valid argument, but in all my time observing different forums I've never seen this reach an actual problematic scale in practice. Certainly not enough to warrant the possible benefits for tuning down anonymity a bit.

I've seen several concepts where either positive votes (with the name of the voter) where visible for all or just the op or versions where all votes where shown at the end of a thread/comment.

I just think that voting should be a more conscious choice given the power it yield. Especially since people use votes more like a agree/disagree button than as a good/bad post button.

As a personal sidenote, I never understood the need for anonymity while voting in forums. Sure, once or twice someone dislike my opinions because I disliked theirs earlier but if responsibly stand by your opinion you should not be afraid to make it public. It also adds more weight to the decision to vote on something.

When I say public I naturally mean your username.

Edit: I got to admit, when I wrote this i did not consider the irony of being anonymously downvoted. This made me smile though.

8 Comments

Dynikus5 votes

What benefit would removing anonymity from votes have?

ModUlanopo4 votes

This is something we have discussed on the moderation team. We lack the tech resources to implement, however.

Madjack011 votes

{quoted}

This is something we have discussed on the moderation team. We lack the tech resources to implement, however.

Ah figures the technical aspect would get in the way. It has a habit of doing that even for seemingly simple things. I don't even want to know how much other stuff you had to shelve because of it.

Thanks for the response though!

ModUlanopo1 votes

{quoted}

I don't even want to know how much other stuff you had to shelve because of it.

Moving threads between sub-boards. #1 with a bullet. If we could get ANYTHING, it would be that.

Thanks for the response though!

You're most welcome.

Modi2 votes

My solution:

Sort by: New

Screw other people's opinions on what is the "best" thread, I want to see what is the freshest.

Warlord Rhinark2 votes

We all know that votes determine what threads people get to see and what threads never get a decent chance.

Only if you're on the Hot page.

Just go to the New or Recent pages.

MrFawknSunshine1 votes

well i dont upvote or downvote anything

Dr Dog1 votes

it takes a good amount of downvotes for something to get shoved down, if had posts start out with 8 or 9 downvotes then bounce getting 20-30 upvotes if your post gets buried it usually means people genuinely dont agree or like it

More from Discuss the Boards

More by Madjack01