Skip to content

A 'Bug/Loophole' in the terms of service that's about to be exploited (not sure where else to post

The Mäd Pätter··5 votes·2,039 views

Good afternoon Riot Team,

I am here to let you know that there appears to be an oversight in your Terms of Service regarding third party hardware that uses information from the game to enhance gameplay. While I can totally understand why this oversight exists (because who would have thought the following product would ever be created), it seems that a ToS update would be required to prevent the use of the following tool which is currently in development:

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1710261071/the-omniwear-arc-the-wearable-haptic-interface-for

This "Omniwear" would allow players (who are willing to pay a third party company for their product) an advantage in game over other players... which to me is the textbook definition of a third party tool. However currently, due to the wording of your ToS, this cheating tool does not actually violate your user agreement:

"Using any unauthorized third party programs, including mods, hacks, cheats, scripts, bots, trainers and automation programs that interact with the Software in any way, for any purpose, including any unauthorized third party programs that intercept, emulate, or redirect any communication between the Software and Riot Games and any unauthorized third party programs that collect information about the Game by reading areas of memory used by the Software to store information;"

The ToS only specifies -software- which interacts with your software. I can understand why this is... before this product, there weren't any forms of hardware that would facilitate this level of cheating, and thus having a hardware component to the ToS would simply be overcomplicated and pointless... but now there is a company positioning itself to offer your player-base a pay-to-win cheating tool, that uses this loophole/emission in the ToS.

I don't know if you are already aware of this tool, or whether or not you are prepared to condemn its use, but I figured I would bring this to your attention. Personally, I would view this tool no differently than a software plugin that caused the game to automatically ping your screen when it saw an enemy player on the minimap, which would be a blatant violation of the terms of service. This product violates the spirit of the ToS, I hope that you take the steps required so that it violates the letter of the ToS as well.

If you choose not to condemn this tool, that is also well within your rights... although I have to admit, I don't imagine your players would appreciate having to pay some random company a minimum of $99 USD to get a tool which other players may be using, so they can stay on the same competitive level. I know personally, I'd rather spend that money on skins or champs, but if not having this tool made me less effective in game versus my competition... I'd feel like I wouldn't have a choice but to buy their product. Considering that you have done so well in designing a game that doesn't make players feel like they -need- to spend money, that would seem a little backward.

Anyways, enough rambling. Looking forward to hearing what, if anything, you plan to do in combating this new generation of third-party cheating tools.

36 Comments

Flaherty2 votes

Making this against the TOS is kind of pointless because there's no way to even prevent people from using this or any way to tell that people are using it unless Riot asks the company to just not make it available for their game

Slythion2 votes

I mean, the product itself uses software that would be considered 3rd-party software (because...well...it is) so it would still be considered an illegal 3rd-party software. The frame/shell of the product (aka, the hardware) would be allowed so long as the software it uses isn't function...so basically you'd technically be allowed to wear it, just not use it.

Do you get what I mean?

My only concern is whether Riot has a system that can detect 3rd-party software from an external device that is being used, but I'd imagine they would because that stuff already does exist

DrCyanide1 votes

It uses your phone to get all the information and relay it to the device. Riot would be unable to know it's even being used.

I've got mixed feelings on it. It's 100% using information that's already available to the player (the minimap), so it's not like they're getting any information a player who doesn't use this can't. I kinda see this like highlighting what's already there.

I feel like shout outs from teammates on voice chat can do the same job as this, and voice chat is an approved "third party software".

The Mäd Pätter1 votes

{quoted}

It uses your phone to get all the information and relay it to the device. Riot would be unable to know it's even being used.

I've got mixed feelings on it. It's 100% using information that's already available to the player (the minimap), so it's not like they're getting any information a player who doesn't use this can't. I kinda see this like highlighting what's already there.

I feel like shout outs from teammates on voice chat can do the same job as this, and voice chat is an approved "third party software".

Yeah the difference being though that voice chat (like you said) is approved, free, and only needs speakers (which you need to play anyways) and a mic (which you can get for 20$)... rather than a $300+ phone and a $100+ piece of hardware that people may not be able to afford.

Akira Tsurugi1 votes

Unfortunately that's not how it works. If you read the ToS the guy posted they said software that interacts with the software in some way. This is pretty external and undetectable. So its not like they even need to plug it to the PC. The camera reads the display of the screen. Kinda like a third eye but you feel if rather than see it.

There's two options so far I see. Not counting the one that seems unlikely which is to shut it down before it becomes a thing.

  1. Try and Incorporate it or make their own.
  2. Somehow make a patch each week that can somehow mess with the reading of the minimap that doesn't destroy the feel of the game.
Slythion1 votes

There has to be some sort of software to allow the phone to read the minimap from the client, in which case that could be considered an interaction. Perhaps I'm wrong, but because of how the phone is connected during the video, it seems pretty apparent that they do have software to read the minimap (material recognition isn't reliable or advanced enough to be how a simple phone reads a section of the screen). Not to mention the apps that they mentioned in the video would be considered to be against the rules as well.

Akira Tsurugi1 votes

I probably wrote too much and you forgot what I first said. It has to touch the game software in someway. The software will be in the phone which Riot has no control over. What the thread creator said was that, in their terns of service it states that it has to alter or read the game in a software point as in read from the .exe. or alter your gameplay as your mouse moving the problem is it doesn't touch any software in the computer. The software seems to be in the phone and reads anyzes and sends the vibrations.

Akira Tsurugi1 votes

I probably wrote too much and you forgot what I first said. It has to touch the game software in someway. The software will be in the phone which Riot has no control over. What the thread creator said was that, in their terns of service it states that it has to alter or read the game in a software point as in read from the .exe. or alter your gameplay as your mouse moving the problem is it doesn't touch any software in the computer. The software seems to be in the phone and reads anyzes and sends the vibrations.

Akira Tsurugi1 votes

I probably wrote too much and you forgot what I first said. It has to touch the game software in someway. The software will be in the phone which Riot has no control over. What the thread creator said was that, in their terns of service it states that it has to alter or read the game in a software point as in read from the .exe. or alter your gameplay as your mouse moving the problem is it doesn't touch any software in the computer. The software seems to be in the phone and reads anyzes and sends the vibrations.

Adding to that. An example of why this is could be a problem might be in the future if we ever get implants on our body such as cyber eyes and we could alter the software, riot can't control any of that at all as it is external or even part of our bodies. Now I'm not saying it's that extreme or that the line is that thin, in the future if that ever happens it'll be a whole different story. But updating the terms of service to stuff outside the game is really hard to control.

Akira Tsurugi1 votes

Sorry for the spam. Mobile seems to add the prompt to all my replies. I wish I could fix it

The Mäd Pätter2 votes

{quoted}

I mean, the product itself uses software that would be considered 3rd-party software (because...well...it is) so it would still be considered an illegal 3rd-party software. The frame/shell of the product (aka, the hardware) would be allowed so long as the software it uses isn't function...so basically you'd technically be allowed to wear it, just not use it.

Do you get what I mean?

My only concern is whether Riot has a system that can detect 3rd-party software from an external device that is being used, but I'd imagine they would because that stuff already does exist

{quoted}

Making this against the TOS is kind of pointless because there's no way to even prevent people from using this or any way to tell that people are using it unless Riot asks the company to just not make it available for their game

[{quoted}](name=Zyra Suit Samus,realm=NA,application-id=LqLKtMpN,discussion-id=dH8iOjPp,comment-id=0002,timestamp=2016-10-19T16:19:59.479+0000)

Riot is also able to redefine the ToS as they see fit if a new problems arise. Granted, the fact that it uses your phone could make it harder to track... It's not like they're going to be able to trace this properly. It's kind of like an extra set of eyes I suppose and it would use the minimap. It is definitely cheating. It also technically has 3rd party software attached, it's just on your phone, unfortunately.

If they update the ToS then they could look at taking action against the developers of the tool.

For example: If they put in their ToS that you are not allowed to use League of Legends to develop or aid in the development of hardware/software without riot's express permission, then the company developing Omniwear would not be able to develop/maintain/patch the aspect of their product that reads the LoL minimap. Because they would have to accept the ToS to use the game and would have to use the game to be able to develop their cell-phone app that parses the LoL minimap data that it reads off the screen.

Obviously, I'm not a lawyer (I am; however, a software designer + programmer), and there may very well be an exploitable loophole with the example I came up with in 15 seconds. (i.e, the company could watch a stream and gather their data from that)... But the point I'm putting forward is that the ToS should not only target the people using the tool, but also the company developing it. If they can stop the Omniwear developers from including the LoL aspect of their product altogether, then it would really cut down on its use for cheating.

LankPants1 votes

If they put in their ToS that you are not allowed to use League of Legends to develop or aid in the development of hardware/software without riot's express permission, then the company developing Omniwear would not be able to develop/maintain/patch the aspect of their product that reads the LoL minimap.

You'd also inadvertently hit sites like S@20 and anyone manufacturing things like custom mouse pads.

Because they would have to accept the ToS to use the game and would have to use the game to be able to develop their cell-phone app that parses the LoL minimap data that it reads off the screen.

There's a further loophole to this, whoever holds the company, whether legitimately or as a figurehead simply has to have not played League and not accepted the terms of service. The ToS is only applicable when accepted, Riot would have no right to get the program taken down or monitored if the person producing it never accepted the ToS.

Obviously, I'm not a lawyer (I am; however, a software designer + programmer), and there may very well be an exploitable loophole with the example I came up with in 15 seconds. (i.e, the company could watch a stream and gather their data from that)... But the point I'm putting forward is that the ToS should not only target the people using the tool, but also the company developing it. If they can stop the Omniwear developers from including the LoL aspect of their product altogether, then it would really cut down on its use for cheating.

I doubt there's much legal ground for Riot to stand on. This isn't mining the game or anything, it would be virtually impossible to police.

The Mäd Pätter1 votes

{quoted} There's a further loophole to this, whoever holds the company, whether legitimately or as a figurehead simply has to have not played League and not accepted the terms of service. The ToS is only applicable when accepted, Riot would have no right to get the program taken down or monitored if the person producing it never accepted the ToS.

It would also mean that any of the programmers or people playing the game to research how the minimap works would be hit.

Breaku2 votes

I would like to see Riot comment on this product. I think it provides and unfair advantage for sure.

The Mäd Pätter1 votes

Yeah, So would I. I would at least like someone to acknowledge that the thread has been read and passed along to the appropriate department.

Maximum Morde1 votes

Can you at least explain why/how you think this tool violates the tos?

The Mäd Pätter1 votes

Currently, it doesn't, and that's the issue.

Imagine if you will a piece of software that looked at your minimap and gave you an alert on your screen when it saw an enemy near your character. This piece of software would be condemned by riot, considered a cheat, and people using it would be banned... why? More importantly this software would be considered as a violation of the Terms of Service specifically because it interfaces with the game's software to provide extra information to specific players, thus enhancing their level of play over other people.

This new product "Omniwear" does exactly that. It watches your mini-map, and alerts you when it sees an enemy, thus enhancing the level of play of specific players and not others; however, because it's interfacing with the player's monitor by using their cell-phone to read the screen, rather than interacting with riot's software it's stepping around the ToS.

Also because it's a paid product, it gives anyone who can't afford the product a distinct disadvantage over other players... basically adding "pay-to-win" mechanics into the game.

This is why I say there is a bug/loophole in the terms of service. This product doesn't violate the ToS... what I'm suggesting is that the ToS should be changed/amended so that it does. This product is a cheating tool, no matter how hard it's developers try to deny it.

Maximum Morde1 votes

I'm not so sure. I'd say it's might just be one of the next major peripherals that change gaming. Like the mouse + keyboard vs just keyboard, though not to that extreme. Just saying.

The Mäd Pätter1 votes

Perhaps for newer games. The problem is that League has a huge number of existing players. If you treat this as the next new thing, then all those players have to go out and spend $100+ USD on the product. Money which they may not have. You then create a major segregation between players who can/can't afford this product. Even more so as some players, no doubt, do not have a smart phone.

League is designed in such a way where you do not need much to play it. The graphics can be run using on-board video cards on laptops. And you do not need any special peripherals aside from the standard things you'd already generally own with a computer: Mouse, Keyboard, Speakers, Monitor, and then the computer itself (which can have relatively low specs).

This creates an extra need for additional peripherals that would add a barrier to entry to playing the game optimally.

Then you look at the player base. Let's say players get this. They will no doubt ping, and call ss less often, assuming everyone else has the product. Blame other players for not having the product when they get ganked, etc. It will create something which will segregate the players based on income.

Maximum Morde1 votes

That isn't really any different an outcome than trackIR already has in flight sims. That's the nature of entertainment. Wouldn't see it being a problem really so long as people still have fun and enjoy the game.

The Mäd Pätter1 votes

Except the point of this game is to have fair, balanced competition. That's where the fun is. You take away that fairness and balance when you give someone people a tool that others don't have the ability to get.

DrCyanide1 votes

I get the same added minimap alerts from being on voice chat with my friends. Players who have conditioned themselves to check the minimap more often wouldn't even see have a difference.

This highlights information already available to the player, it doesn't give them any new information. That sounds in line with Riot's policies on approved apps to me.

The Mäd Pätter1 votes

Except voice chat relys on other HUMAN players noticing and conveying that information. Thus is based entirely in team skill, and can be replicated in game with pings. And while a human may call mia, they won't necessarily notice where that player went, or what lane they pop up in... so you/the team still has to watch the map. You still end up having to devote lots of focus to the map... since you may pick up something your team missed.

This product uses a MACHINE to notify the player, and convey the information. It can also monitor the minimap and inform you the second someone comes into view, so you don't have to pay attention to it nearly as much. It's more equivalent to having a friend sit next to you and just watch your minimap, all game, without blinking, and tell you what's going on... and even then that friend would not be able to process the entire minimap as quickly/easily.

This takes away much of the urgency to constantly check your map, allowing you to focus on other things. It will effect how much more focus you can devote to farming, ganking, planning items, etc.

Let's pretend you're constantly doing 5 things in lane, so you devote 20% of your focus to each thing. If you take away one of those things, then suddenly you can devote 25% of your focus to the other things, giving you an advantage over your opponent. Even if you still had to devote 5% of your attention to the minimap... you can devote that remaining 15% of your focus to other aspects of the game.

You're correct in that it doesn't give them NEW information. It just circumvents the effort required to get that attention. That effort required to get that information (looking at the minimap constantly) is an aspect of the game built into the core gameplay experience. They are getting around that, making the game easier for themselves. It's a cheat.

DrCyanide1 votes

Is it fundamentally different than having a buddy in the room with you who watches your minimap and calls things out? If we're being 1-to-1 here, then the buddy would just tap your back relative to where the threats were, which would probably be faster and cleaner than trying to say things mid game anyway.

He's not in the team, he's not pinging, for the other team to have the same experience they'd need to have a buddy in the room. I think everyone's had a game where a friend or family member watched over their shoulder for a bit, cheering them on and warning them about stuff.

It just circumvents the effort required to get that attention. That effort required to get that information (looking at the minimap constantly) is an aspect of the game built into the core gameplay experience.

Riot's policy with presenting information is that they should be doing it in the easiest to access way possible. If anything, this device challenges the notion that a radar/minimap is "good enough" at presenting that information. It would be far more likely to result in Riot developing better on-screen queues for the same information.

The Mäd Pätter1 votes

It is fundamentally different because software can process far more events in one moment than a person can. It can also react much faster. The machine will always be faster at doing this than a human can be. The only advantage a human would have would be to specify what's going on. Where a machine might vibrate to say "Enemies spotted close to your right". A person could say "Rengar and Elise are in the bush to your right preparing for a gank".

"He's not in the team, he's not pinging, for the other team to have the same experience they'd need to have a buddy in the room." That's correct, that's why this would be considered cheating, even though it's 100% undetectable.

"It would be far more likely to result in Riot developing better on-screen queues for the same information." This may happen... but the point of this would be that EVERYONE would then have access to this new for of information display... Not everyone has access to this new Omniwear product.. thus making it unfair, unbalanced, and very cheaty.

This device would be akin to giving players the option to pay $100+ USD to modify their minimap in such a way that gives them better feedback, but not making it available unless you paid that $100. That's the point.

Whether this device is cool, or is the "next step" in immersion, or better at presenting information is 100% irrelevant to this discussion. The point is the fact that this creates a divide between players, as this is not something everyone can have. Allowing this product would essentially be telling players "Hey i know you're already playing this game, and you've been playing it for x number of years for free, and we've never charged for it, and never made you pay for anything that improved your level of play. But now you have to either fork out the money to get this product from some random company... or you have to settle with being at a constant disadvantage to other players who did choose to pay."

It goes against the design of fairness and balance that LoL has had since it's design.

Sarutobi1 votes

I'm not quite sure about the tech you have listed,but I'm going to assume it's in it thinking stage and not even close to release. Riot shouldn't worrying too much.but when this gets released (or even a little before that) they can change the ToS. Just like how they keep it updated from time to time!

The Mäd Pätter1 votes

Best to update their ToS sooner rather than later so that players know it's cheating and don't spend money on it. This would also help to prevent the product from being funded, thus preventing it's use all together by players who would think to use the tool anyways.

Sniper 01 votes

Riot is also able to redefine the ToS as they see fit if a new problems arise. Granted, the fact that it uses your phone could make it harder to track... It's not like they're going to be able to trace this properly. It's kind of like an extra set of eyes I suppose and it would use the minimap. It is definitely cheating. It also technically has 3rd party software attached, it's just on your phone, unfortunately.

tabmanlikebatman1 votes

Well, the thing is, this is really only worth it in a lower level of competition. I am 100% sure that a pro player would be annoyed by how slowly this thing detects threats. Also, the amount of information being passed to you is very little. It is giving direction and intensity. When it comes down to it, it is simply a tool that encourages a person to look at the minimap, because whenever you see an enemy on the minimap it is usually moving- and you can tell a lot more from that than this device can.

So, in conclusion, a bronze player would benefit greatly, because they would feel the vibration and just run for their turret/safety. Whereas a plat+ player would either find the vibration useless or it would force them to look at the minimap. Just knowing that an enemy has been spotted is useless in that level of play- especially because vision fades- it can not turn on and off in milliseconds. I doubt a bronze player could advance more than one subtier with this.

One example of when this thing is useless- the jungler is spotted crossing the mid lane- this event would probably be so far if you were in the top or bot lanes that this device wouldn't even trigger. And even if it did, the information it gives you is that you need to place wards or just cower behind turret. The first case is something which is integral to the game and encourages better play. while the second is something that won't reap you too many benefits (this game rewards risk quite heavily).

While it may be "cheating", it isn't very hard to do what this company has done with machine vision. I could code this within a few days worth of free time (without the vibration hardware aspect), but personally, I wouldn't find it worthwhile. I would more equate this to a peripheral. There are some really great keyboards and mice out there that could be said to increase your ergonomics and response time. There are bad keyboards that don't let you press more than a few keys at once. Also, like that youtuber MagiKarpUsedFly, you could literally use something like the razer nostromo (sp?) instead of a keyboard.

Akira Tsurugi1 votes

This thing hasn't been made but its not hard to correctly advise with different modes. It's a bit more than you're thinking of it as though. I personally don't think it can make a better player overall with it, but it does help those with tunnel vision.

The queues will be instantly there will be no delay there's lots of things that work instantly like that, the data transfer doesn't have to be slow at all. The image is detect it immediately and through Bluetooth there will be maybe 50ms delay at best doesn't stop you from noticing yourself but also noticed things you might not. So yeah depending on the vibration it tells you when someone is recalling. Just by seeing the recall animation in the minimap might even be able to do a countdown for you for when you saw them recalling so you know if you can make it if they have gone back yet or they haven't. It doesn't need to turn on and off as quickly. It would use different type of queues. Could use an intensifier of vibration if there's more than one person in a certain angle. So yeah it wouldn't detect things slow, and it can provide multiple feedback at the same time. Vibrating from two different locations can also be a hard thing to spot normally if youre in a middle or a fight. Usually you would look at the minimap not as often during a team fight, you would look at it maybe between skills or auto atks maybe if you're good even between kills but this won't stop working and will keep looking at the minimap and could potentially tell you where someone ran to that you weren't even chasing. Now, I'm not sure if can do all of that but it wouldn't be that hard to detect all that stuff.

Dark0nB100d1 votes

OH holy crap. It's like scripting without the scripting......

Ýisus1 votes

Not sure if anyone has said this yet ... but ... for it to "watch" the radar it must be linking to some software ... the hardware does not have eyes. So in order to track all these things it certainly is using a software.

The Mäd Pätter1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Ganksta Yisus,realm=NA,application-id=LqLKtMpN,discussion-id=dH8iOjPp,comment-id=0009,timestamp=2016-10-20T09:16:37.476+0000)

Not sure if anyone has said this yet ... but ... for it to "watch" the radar it must be linking to some software ... the hardware does not have eyes. So in order to track all these things it certainly is using a software.

Yes it uses software. That's a no-brainer. But it does NOT interact with Riot's software in any way... which is the problem.

Unstoppable Monk1 votes

lol looks like a waste of money

probably a just money grab. do you really think something buzzing your nipples will make you a better player? XD

Akira Tsurugi1 votes

Depends on what type of player you're talking about ;)

More from Report a Bug

More by The Mäd Pätter